Proposal: Van / Car

[Halla]

this is bad for the canes

the difference between dougie and tanev isn't a dude that is oft scratched and a 2nd

 

[GoldiFox]

Terrible for Carolina. One of Hamilton, Pesce, or Faulk will go in a fair hockey deal. Offer a 1 for 1 piece rather than a collection of scraps.

 

[notsocommonsense]

Is Goldobin a better prospect than I think?
Otherwise this is horribad for Carolina.
No one wants Tanev.
And Carolina needs Offense.

I've suggested in the past something around Boeser to Carolina for one of their D, makes more sense for both sides.

That makes zero sense for Nucks. While we def need D, Boeser is our only top line wing and we are seriously bereft of Winger depth.

I like Hamilton, but I do have serious questions about the locker room issues

 

[Moosetache]

canes laugh so that is awful. a way to often injured offensively challenged defenceman. a B level prospect and a second round pick. Hamilton costs Thatcher Demko +++, or Bo Horvat ++, Brock Boeser ++, or Elias Pettersson . You don't like the cost that is fine but it would be around that. take canes needs in to account a young goalie or offensive minded top 6 talent

as a canes fan, I laughed at this. If the Canes could get Boeser I'd give up Hamilton and Ferland. probably add a pick too.

 

[CP4]

Seems like both fans don't like the trade so maybe the value isn't that far off?

 

[GoodbyeLuongo]

canes laugh so that is awful. a way to often injured offensively challenged defenceman. a B level prospect and a second round pick. Hamilton costs Thatcher Demko +++, or Bo Horvat ++, Brock Boeser ++, or Elias Pettersson . You don't like the cost that is fine but it would be around that. take canes needs in to account a young goalie or offensive minded top 6 talent

The OP sucks but Carolina doesn’t have a player on their roster that is worth EP. Slavin is the only guy in the same stratosphere

 

[Addison Rae]

The OP sucks but Carolina doesn’t have a player on their roster that is worth EP. Slavin is the only guy in the same stratosphere

Slavin is fantastic but there’s not a chance in hell I’d even consider moving Pettersson for him.

 

[SaskCanesFan]

Bahaah . No thanks. Hamilton is a cancer. Another team trying to dump him asap. I'd inquire on Ferdlund

Please link where the Canes are trying to dump him asap. Or, ya know, don't make up garbage

 

[Icebreakers]

Hamilton is like Duchene. Hes good, but do people really want to give up a lot for him?

 

[GIN ANTONIC]

Since Boesser, EP, and Horvat are obviously off the table for Hamilton and/or Ferland there isn’t much to consider. I’m sure the Canucks don’t want to part with a Demko and that would be the only other player that interests Carolina

 

[Lenerdosy]

Is Goldobin a better prospect than I think?
Otherwise this is horribad for Carolina.
No one wants Tanev.
And Carolina needs Offense.

I've suggested in the past something around Boeser to Carolina for one of their D, makes more sense for both sides.

Nobody really knows what Goldobin is still. The coach still doesn't like his defensive game so he gets benched or limited minutes constantly while there are players who can play defence but are offensive black holes so its really hard to tell.

Either way this is bad for Carolina from a value standpoint. And I wouldn't even entertain Boeser for Hamilton even for a second. There seems to be way to may issues with Hamilton on each team and he keeps getting moved around raises some red flags. Yea he is a hell of a D and can put up points but something is off about him that is causing problems and he can't seem to find a long term home for whatever reason.

 

[Taluss]

Hamilton is like Duchene. Hes good, but do people really want to give up a lot for him?

Why yes Ott was very happy to do so thanks for asking!

On a serious note I agree. Hamilton’s value certainly isn’t as high as some on here think. Very talented player but seems like something goes on in the lockerroom that doesn’t fit well.

 

[GIN ANTONIC]

Why yes Ott was very happy to do so thanks for asking!

On a serious note I agree. Hamilton’s value certainly isn’t as high as some on here think. Very talented player but seems like something goes on in the lockerroom that doesn’t fit well.

No sane Canes fan thinks Dougie is worth BB, EP, or Bo

 

[Cardiac Jerks]

Why yes Ott was very happy to do so thanks for asking!

On a serious note I agree. Hamilton’s value certainly isn’t as high as some on here think. Very talented player but seems like something goes on in the lockerroom that doesn’t fit well.

Teams calling inquiring about his availability means he has problems in the Hurricanes lockerroom?

 

[ToDavid]

canes laugh so that is awful. a way to often injured offensively challenged defenceman. a B level prospect and a second round pick. Hamilton costs Thatcher Demko +++, or Bo Horvat ++, Brock Boeser ++, or Elias Pettersson . You don't like the cost that is fine but it would be around that. take canes needs in to account a young goalie or offensive minded top 6 talent

OP’s offer was bad but your counters are equally ridiculous.

 

[kanucks25]

OP's offer is awful for Carolina.

If the Canucks call asking for Hamilton, the Canes ask for Boeser and then the conversation ends.

It's safe to assume that Carolina is looking for an impact forward in a 1-for-1 trade, not scraps.

 

[Siludin]

Canes really have no negotiating leverage when it comes to dealing Hamilton if they intend to move him so soon after acquiring him.

 

[SaskCanesFan]

Canes really have no negotiating leverage when it comes to dealing Hamilton if they intend to move him so soon after acquiring him.

They don't intend to move him. Seriously, have we gotten to the point in society where reading comprehension doesn't exist anymore?

 

[kanucks25]

Canes really have no negotiating leverage when it comes to dealing Hamilton if they intend to move him so soon after acquiring him.

There's zero indication that he's been a problem in Carolina. Them maybe talking about him with other teams doesn't mean all leverage is lost.

 

[Rowlet]

Is Goldobin a better prospect than I think?
Otherwise this is horribad for Carolina.
No one wants Tanev.
And Carolina needs Offense.

I've suggested in the past something around Boeser to Carolina for one of their D, makes more sense for both sides.

There's a post on this board from a Vancouver insider saying that people are interested in Tanev, so clearly someone wants him and Goldobin is 4th in scoring on the Canucks, not the most impressive feat by any means but if you're looking for someone to make offense, he's capable of that

 

[kanucks25]

There's a post on this board from a Vancouver insider saying that people are interested in Tanev, so clearly someone wants him and Goldobin is 4th in scoring on the Canucks, not the most impressive feat by any means but if you're looking for someone to make offense, he's capable of that

Someone might want Tanev, but that's not Carolina. They're overloaded on RD.

 

[Canadian Canuck]

Is Goldobin a better prospect than I think?
Otherwise this is horribad for Carolina.
No one wants Tanev.
And Carolina needs Offense.

I've suggested in the past something around Boeser to Carolina for one of their D, makes more sense for both sides.

tanev is an offensive black hole and is good for about 60 games a year. he is a solid defensive d man but canes don't need that.

canes laugh so that is awful. a way to often injured offensively challenged defenceman. a B level prospect and a second round pick. Hamilton costs Thatcher Demko +++, or Bo Horvat ++, Brock Boeser ++, or Elias Pettersson . You don't like the cost that is fine but it would be around that. take canes needs in to account a young goalie or offensive minded top 6 talent

Dear God....do poeple watch Tanev or hockey in general if they think he's "scraps and nobody wants him". Please dont post if you dont have a clue about the topic.

 

[Brockon]

canes laugh so that is awful. a way to often injured offensively challenged defenceman. a B level prospect and a second round pick. Hamilton costs Thatcher Demko +++, or Bo Horvat ++, Brock Boeser ++, or Elias Pettersson . You don't like the cost that is fine but it would be around that. take canes needs in to account a young goalie or offensive minded top 6 talent

What's wrong with Nedeljkovic? I was under the impression that he was developing into a good AHL starter with the Checkers and well on his way to getting a shot at NHL duty in the not so distant future?

As for your listed prices, Hamilton is underperforming in a big way - there's little chance Boeser, Horvat or Petersson are part of any realistic discussion in a trade from Benning.

 

[Rowlet]

Someone might want Tanev, but that's not Carolina. They're overloaded on RD.

I agree, the post I quoted said "nobody wants Tanev" to which I said that is false

 

[JPeeper]

Canes traded Hanifin and Lindholm for Hamilton (and Ferland and Fox), they ain't trading him away for, pardon my English, garbage pieces.