And that's a reasonable belief. I'm certainly not going to try to tell you otherwise.
Personally I think the look of mental defeat traces to goaltending and coaching wasn't going to alter this season with goaltending being what it's been. The caveat to that might be a different goalie coach might have got better goalie results.
Seems this year the league average is.904. a few guys have posted stats on our winning percentage when a goalie posts a > .900 game. It's crazy good.
I think the talent is there. A bit of depth and some goaltending
Believe me, I've been very critical of goaltending since the beginning of the year. The level we've seen is simply inexcusable for a team with playoff aspirations. It's not just the weak goals either, it's the timing too. This team, with .908 goaltending, is a playoff team or, at least, mostly in control of their destiny.
The problem is the confidence of the goalies also closely aligns with the confidence of the team. The goalies are not detached from the mental challenges this team has faced, they are just as susceptible. It's one of those loops that keeps feeding itself. A few bad goals leads to the players changing the way they play in front of the goalies. Suddenly, the players are second-guessing themselves or looking for the perfect play, which exacerbates the problem in front of the goalies. The mental defeat is now going in a loop. The players were deflated from the bad goaltending and now their play is deflating the goalies and the goalies are letting in more bad goals and on and on it goes.
You break out of that cycle by resetting mentally, which is what a coaching change signifies. A new voice comes in, helps everyone get some perspective, loosen up a little, hear something different and start working towards building their confidence. At game 13, the team had 69 more games ahead of them to let that effect compound. At game 26, when DJ was fired, they were already a third of the way through the season. It was simply too little, too late at that point.
Maybe the coaching change doesn't result in a significantly higher calibre of goaltending but maybe it results in just enough of an increase to get us up from 9/20 points in each 10 game segment to 12/20 points. I don't think that's such a crazy leap to think there was just no way fathomable to do it.
Anyway, it doesn't really matter. The season was over after 10 games again and there's no way to go back and change things after the fact. I can't help but think an experienced GM/POHO wouldn't have second-guessed the decision, given the established history.