The thing is you also need some players with skill as well and not just big pylons. A player will not be standing in front of the net for his entire TOI, so they’ll need some other important skills as well.
So, we need both kinds of players and hopefully some larger rugged players with skill that can handle being in front of the net. There’s a lot less cross-checking, grabbing the stick, etc., so that has changed the game as well. I guess I’m agreeing with you basically but its a question of balance as well.
Thinking out loud, how I imagine my set-up based on skills:
Batherson: skilled guy around the net, bumper when back to the net, one-timer option when facing the net
Norris: one-timer option, moves in the general area of his usual office, draws a defenseman toward him to open other options.
Tkachuk: messes with the goalie's vision, retrieves the puck behind the net along the board, bumper or tips shots (DOES NOT MAKE FANCY BETWEEN-THE-LEG MOVE, DOES NOT SHOOT AT THE GOALIE'S PADS)
Stutzle: moves all over the place, provides passing option to Sanderson, shoots if conditions are suitable
Sanderson: holds the blue line, distributes the puck, shoots if conditions are suitable