Confirmed with Link: Trade with the Washington Capitals, Beck Malenstyn for 2nd round (#43)

[toddkaz]

Holy cow we traded a 2nd round pick for a 4th line player


St Louis traded a 2nd for Buchnevich.


Adams is a joke

 

[Mattilaus]

Speaking of peanut butter, I finally managed to find Extra Crunchy Skippy peanut butter yesterday. It seems to be non-existent here in Canada.

Extra crunchy peanut butter? Isn't that just like, peanuts in a jar?

 

[MarkusKetterer]

Who's a lot of people? I respect chain's opinion but he seems to be the only one.

Of course we like the trade if he's good. But it feels like an annual thing that we get some underwhelming acquisition that could be good depth, then "big surprise", they remain underwhelming.

Jost, Erik Johnson, Eric Robinson, Lyubushkin, Sheahan, Bjork, Stillman, eakin, hagg.

Aside from thompson, who was the last player we acquired that exceeded expectations?

I like the trade. Not the return but I like the player.

This bad and why?

Dude was out there to get the puck back and go the other way

 

[Husko]

Unserious franchise

 

[joshjull]

 

[markpenske]

Eric Robinson 2.0 for a 2nd.

yeap. Another guy that does nothing. Well, at least he's a bigger guy that does nothing. Maybe could have got him for a 3rd or 4th

 

[MarkusKetterer]

Extra crunchy peanut butter? Isn't that just like, peanuts in a jar?

Yup. I hate smooth peanut butter. Especially seeing I only ever eat it on pancakes or waffles

 

[oldgoalie]

some sandpaper in the lineup. who gives a f*** about some overpayment?

 

[GellMann]

there are pages and pages in the other thread, saying 'don't care if we over pay, just do something Adams'

KA trades a free 2nd round pick and people loose their minds

This is because when people want an overpay, they want kevyn to get an impact trade (Like Ehlers and Iafallo yesterday) across the finish line.

Not pull a Jason Botterill/Scandella embarrassment for a bad 4th liner lol.

 

[joshjull]

This bad and why?

He was used in a ridiculously skewed defensive role.

 

[Dirty Dog]

Who's a lot of people? I respect chain's opinion but he seems to be the only one.

Go to the main board thread and you’ll see different people saying he is a great fourth liner, that we will like him, and that he is a good addition.

Enter his name into the search bar and you’ll see a ton of posts throughout the season from caps fans praising him.

Of course we like the trade if he's good. But it feels like an annual thing that we get some underwhelming acquisition that could be good depth, then "big surprise", they remain underwhelming.

Jost, Erik Johnson, Eric Robinson, Lyubushkin, Sheahan, Bjork, Stillman, eakin, hagg.

Aside from thompson, who was the last player we acquired that exceeded expectations?

Yeah, all of those players are bargain bin acquisitions. This is a praised player we actually paid a premium to get.

 

[toddkaz]

People bitching about not making a move

He makes s move...they still bitch

Cant win

Such a bad take.

We should just eat our gruel because we expect competency

 

[Dubi Doo]

Don’t care, if he’s a good fourth liner which a lot of people think he is…I don’t care about a little overpay in futures assets.

If he’s good, I like the trade. If he ends up being bad, I don’t like it.

Weren't posters just saying we have to get role players even if we overpay because no one signs here? Strange.

Now get me Carrier, and that 4th line should be set. Still moves to be made, though.

 

[Chainshot]

Maybe would have preferred the third rounder, but I like the player. Self-starter who finishes his hits and plays responsible defensively while getting Housley'd in use.

 

[CowbellConray]

Who's a lot of people? I respect chain's opinion but he seems to be the only one.

Of course we like the trade if he's good. But it feels like an annual thing that we get some underwhelming acquisition that could be good depth, then "big surprise", they remain underwhelming.

Jost, Erik Johnson, Eric Robinson, Lyubushkin, Sheahan, Bjork, Stillman, eakin, hagg.

Aside from thompson, who was the last player we acquired that exceeded expectations?

Greenway and Tuch have been good players who exceeded expectations.

Bjork/sheahan/eakin/hagg/stillman/robinson/Jost are fodder. You could even say Jost outperformed expectations in his first year. Beck is a guy more like Johan Larsson, you see if he can build a bit more offense on a guy who is a solid NHL player

 

[Krieger Bot]

The use is Housley-esque - View attachment 889304

Yeah I was looking at some of the Caps' numbers the other day. Seems like Carbery is doing everything he possibly can to give OV nothing but premium ice time.

 

[Chainshot]

Weren't posters just saying we have to get role players even if we overpay because no one signs here? Strange.

Now get me Carrier, and that 4th line should be set. Still moves to be made, though.

Carrier and Malenstyn would be a way to make sure both Sabre fans at the rink are into the game. The boards would be rattling, for sure.

 

[joshjull]

This is because when people want an overpay, they want kevyn to get an impact trade (Like Ehlers and Iafallo yesterday) across the finish line.

Not pull a Jason Botterill/Scandella embarrassment for a bad 4th liner lol.

They also wanted to upgrade the bottom 6. Those aren’t going to be blockbuster trades, even if they're overpayments.

 

[markpenske]

some sandpaper in the lineup. who gives a f*** about some overpayment?

I remember Robinson played with some sandpaper......for about 3 or 4 periods.

 

[HOOats]

Ahh. That's where I know his name from, that 2023 series.

I was also thinking that Lindy might have developed a crush on him from division play vs the Caps.

 

[toddkaz]

Nothing wrong with the player.

Adams should have got him for a 4th.

Buchnevich was traded for a 2nd

 

[Fezzy126]

some sandpaper in the lineup. who gives a f*** about some overpayment?

The same people that utter the phrases "if you need to overpay to get your target, then do it" or "it's much easier to flip skill for toughness", are probably the same ones complaining.

Given how much less I watched of the league and the prospects this year, I trust @Chainshot's eval. So I'll sit back and see how he fits in the roster construction this year.

 

[CowbellConray]

They devalued their 1st round pick to essentially acquire a 4th line guy. It’s poor asset management for a guy desperate to make up for inactivity from years past.

So if we offer that #43 for jeannot is it a problem? Because Beck was a better player last year compared to Jeannot

And they dropped down in the draft, but still got a guy they had in their top 10.

Fans can’t have it both ways. Either we move picks and prospects at a slight devaluation to make the damn playoffs or we don’t. They got a solid 4th line guy who maybe can be a third liner. To me, that’s worth giving up the pick that can maybe make this team in 3 years

 

[Djp]

ICANT

I don't care about the trade, I care that Washington gave a 2nd to get Mangipane and then got a 2nd back to move out a 4th liner. A 2nd for a top 9 two way player and then got a 2nd for a 4th liner with 8 goals in 100 something games played.

The only thing that can make me ok now is if Adams says he tried to talk to Mangiapane and he said no.

This is an RFA who could be signed a few years at a lower cost than UFA.

Mangio might have asked not to go to buffalo

 

[Dirty Dog]

Nothing wrong with the player.

Adams should have got him for a 4th.

Buchnevich was traded for a 2nd

Maybe the capitals don’t want to trade him for a fourth. Or a third.

Maybe the Sabres could have gotten a different fourth liner for a 4th, but they wanted THIS one