Speculation: Trade Rumor/Speculation Thread XXII: St Louis vs St Louis
- Thread starter NYR Viper
- Start date
-
Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
- Status
Kel Varnsen
Below: Nash's Heart
- Sep 27, 2009
- 3,554
- 0
Was the last post in the last thread, but I figured people would want to see this. Audio http://newyork.cbslocal.com/2014/02/24/boomer-im-hearing-ryan-callahan-for-martin-st-louis-straight-up/
GordonGecko
First Ping Pong Ball
silverfish
got perma'd
The only curious part to this situation to me now is, if Boomer is confident enough to say that this has been in the works for a while - and he's hearing Callahan for St. Louis straight up - where are the rest of the beat guys on this one?
Anyway, getting St. Louis for Callahan straight up would be an absolute steal by Sather.
You guys want to stockpile draft picks and prospects? We'll flip St. Louis for that if we need to. He'd be a much more pure rental than Callahan, too. Despite that he'll be what, 41 when his contract expires? He'll garner interest even then as a rental, I'm sure.
Anyway, getting St. Louis for Callahan straight up would be an absolute steal by Sather.
You guys want to stockpile draft picks and prospects? We'll flip St. Louis for that if we need to. He'd be a much more pure rental than Callahan, too. Despite that he'll be what, 41 when his contract expires? He'll garner interest even then as a rental, I'm sure.
The Gloaming
23
I've warmed up to it. Even at his age, MSL is an elite player in the league. Plus, he torches us everytime we play the Lightning. If you can get an elite player like him for Ryan Callahan, you do it.
The part that does not make sense is that Boomer must know that leaking this would essnetially kill the deal. If you are the GM of Pittsburgh, Anaheim, San Jose, LA and read that St Louis could be had for callahan wouldn't you call Yzerman with an offer that blows that out of the water.
Boomer is also regarded as an "insider" of sorts. I don't think he would want to ruin that rep and get bashed by Rangers fans for being full of it:
Only three scenarios I can come up with that make any sense are:
1 St Louis requested a deal and specifically asked for the Rangers. Out of respect for what St Louis has done for the Bolts Yzerman is complying?
2. The Ranger organization is looking to get rival GMS to up the ante for Callahan. One way to do that is to get people to think that Callahan is being dealt somewhere else. When it's all done and St Louis does not come here Boomer will talk about tthe elaborate ruse he helped pull off.
3. Boomer engaging in an exercise in the "Power of Social Media" How a few random tweets between fans can turn into a three ring circus where respected media (dreger, McKenzie, etc.) are werighing in on the subject.
Boomer is also regarded as an "insider" of sorts. I don't think he would want to ruin that rep and get bashed by Rangers fans for being full of it:
Only three scenarios I can come up with that make any sense are:
1 St Louis requested a deal and specifically asked for the Rangers. Out of respect for what St Louis has done for the Bolts Yzerman is complying?
2. The Ranger organization is looking to get rival GMS to up the ante for Callahan. One way to do that is to get people to think that Callahan is being dealt somewhere else. When it's all done and St Louis does not come here Boomer will talk about tthe elaborate ruse he helped pull off.
3. Boomer engaging in an exercise in the "Power of Social Media" How a few random tweets between fans can turn into a three ring circus where respected media (dreger, McKenzie, etc.) are werighing in on the subject.
LORDE
I am Lorde, YA YA YA
As soon as they announce school closings in hell.
Or
When the Pink Floyd album cover "animals" happens for realsies
To get a scoring leader at $5.6M cap hit, a consistent 90 plus point player at that cap hit allows you to do a lot. There is nothing to dislike about the trade other than losing the player that is Ryan Callahan. But hey the dude's going to the highest bidder, and that just happens to be his home town team.
I cannot fathom how someone can poo-poo a 1 for 1 or prefer draft picks and middling prospects. Thank the good Lord there are people out there that actually want to win, rather than have some more things to talk about on HFBoards.
A 90 point player at $5.6 as opposed to something like an $8.5M cap hit means the roster won't need fillers, a quality player can be a part of the team.
A $3.5M third liner, or excellent depth players. Rangers get better.
Let it be true.
I cannot fathom how someone can poo-poo a 1 for 1 or prefer draft picks and middling prospects. Thank the good Lord there are people out there that actually want to win, rather than have some more things to talk about on HFBoards.
A 90 point player at $5.6 as opposed to something like an $8.5M cap hit means the roster won't need fillers, a quality player can be a part of the team.
A $3.5M third liner, or excellent depth players. Rangers get better.
Let it be true.
DudMan28
Registered User
- Jan 30, 2013
- 3,042
- 2,014
Its really a no brainer if its 1 for 1. NYR is gaining a year of MSL for a pending UFA. Who knows what the other offers for Cally are.
I think I read that St Louis has a full NMC that kicks in shortly. I love your logic in that we could always move ST Louis in the summer, but I think that NMC would preclude us from doing that.
Ghost of jas
Unsatisfied
Someone posted yesterday that Boomer runs in the same circles as Richards. Could be why he might have the info and the beat writers don't. Frankly, the beat writer I'd expect to be on top of this story is Brooks.
nyrpassion
Vetted.
I don't get it. He's almost 40, we should've just got Jagr haha.
Why would Tampa trade MSL their leading goalscorer for a grinder that is Cally, especially with Stamkos out.
Why would Tampa trade MSL their leading goalscorer for a grinder that is Cally, especially with Stamkos out.
silverfish
got perma'd
Do NMC's get wiped out when a player is traded?
capgeek said:
Marty has his NMC already. Probably ruling my theory/logic void.
The only way this happens straight up is if Callahan agrees to a deal with Tampa Bay. Sounds to me like Tampa may have been the team that was granted permission to speak to Callahan's agent several weeks ago, as it would coincide with the alleged incident where MSL asked for a trade.
I admire Marty very much as a player. He's one of the best in the game, but he's pushing 40 and certainly can't play forever. This screams desperation from Sather. Instead of building for the long haul, he's trying to catch lightning in a bottle once again (no pun intended).
I admire Marty very much as a player. He's one of the best in the game, but he's pushing 40 and certainly can't play forever. This screams desperation from Sather. Instead of building for the long haul, he's trying to catch lightning in a bottle once again (no pun intended).
This. It's hard for someone to miss his kids growing up. Yzerman named an injured player over him when MSL has been going all out every night.
MSL signed below market value to stay in TB, and be away from his family. I can understand why he would make a request specifically to NYR.
He gets to drive to practice from home, and play 45 min away from them. Those early years in a kid's life aren't something you can really ever get back.
Hockey players know what they sign up for with all the road games. But for MSL it was on another level.
Beer League Sniper
Homeless Man's Rick Nash
I think I read somewhere that, generally, the team acquiring the player who waived their NMC will agree to honor the NMC of said player.
I would love this trade. It would make my Callahan jersey irrelevant, but I don't care. This would be a nice deal for us.
Fitzy
Very Stable Genius
- Jan 29, 2009
- 36,350
- 24,136
It'll be another great player to finish his career in NY, but hopefully we get some good seasons out of him in the process.
As much as anything, I think Zuccarello can learn a lot from MSL. And there is no reason he can't play until 42 like Selanne.
As much as anything, I think Zuccarello can learn a lot from MSL. And there is no reason he can't play until 42 like Selanne.
The Gloaming
23
For real, I'm listening to it right now. Are you in my head?
What are the specifics of MSL's NTC? Is there a list of teams he won't go to, etc?
Beer League Sniper
Homeless Man's Rick Nash
If we are able to get a good 3-4 years out of MSL, this trade is far and away a huge win for us, and more than we are likely to ever get out of a late 1st and some B prospects, which is what we would probably get for Callahan.
silverfish
got perma'd
NYRFAN218
King
None of the beat reporters have any sources besides Brooksie. Doesn't shock me that they haven't said anything.
LORDE
I am Lorde, YA YA YA
Even if this is the case Stevie Y isn't gonna call Sather, explain his dilemma and say "Thanks for ur help Glen" and hang up as soon as Sather says "I've got this pending UFA who wants the moon that I can give you... He kills penalties"
The Gloaming
23
When he waives it, does that just mean to any team out there, or is there a list? That's what I want to know. Need details. Where's RB when you need him?
- Status
