HF Habs: Trade Proposal Thread #91: 2025 Trade Deadline edition

  • Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.


We should be in on Carlo. Right shot defenseman, size, bit of jam.. he would pair well with Hutson.. then we could look at Guhle-Reinbacher on pairing 1 long term.

That is weird. RHD is the last thing Flames need. They have Andersson, Weegar, Pachal, Miromanov and prospects like Parekh or Brusztewicz.
 
Yeah that might be Vachon who used the term elite but you said he is one of the best in the league defensively.. more about the same.

Anyways, my point his, I think you both guys overvalue him right now.

Just to say, I wouldn't pay a 1st for him or a solid prospect. 2nd round and B prospect is the most I would pay.


Minten and their 2nd.

f*** Domi the Douche.
Well I offered Mailloux and a 3rd I guess were offering the same thing.

Carlo is #6 in the NHL in the NHL in the last 3 season in +-.

Aren't these elite D on that list?

 
That is weird. RHD is the last thing Flames need. They have Andersson, Weegar, Pachal, Miromanov and prospects like Parekh or Brusztewicz.
Andersson is having a tough time right now. I'm pretty sure those trade rumors affect him a lot. Or maybe there is more to it and they trade him knowing how much he asks for his next contract.
 
Well I offered Mailloux and a 3rd I guess were offering the same thing.

Carlo is #6 in the NHL in the NHL in the last 3 season in +-.

Aren't these elite D on that list?

+- is not that relevant to evaluate players. I don’t think he’s a top tier defensive defenseman but he’s not as bad as the Bruins fans claim to be. He could be a replacement for Savard, depending on the price.
 
The question to ask then is: can he open pickle jars?

He can always call Karl to get special deals on Easy Grips:


Polish-20250303-130127188.jpg


If he calls fast enough, for a limited time, buyers will also receive Karl's signature Snow Angel cookie cutters!
 
Well I offered Mailloux and a 3rd I guess were offering the same thing.

Carlo is #6 in the NHL in the NHL in the last 3 season in +-.

Aren't these elite D on that list?


Man I don't know what to tell you. He sucks this year. This can be only an off year and he come back to is old self next season or he may not.

I don't pay one of our 1st for him.

I might change my mind about Mailloux but I think he still has some value and could be used in a package for a greater player but I wouldn't cry over it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: EveryDay
Yeah that might be Vachon who used the term elite but you said he is one of the best in the league defensively.. more about the same.

Anyways, my point his, I think you both guys overvalue him right now.

Just to say, I wouldn't pay a 1st for him or a solid prospect. 2nd round and B prospect is the most I would pay.
Defensively, previous years he was in the best of the league. Maybe he has a bad season but I think it’s only a bad year.

 
Defensively, previous years he was in the best of the league. Maybe he has a bad season but I think it’s only a bad year.


Could be I agree.

But it's a risk. The thing I like though is he is not a long term risk.

Would be a pretty good compliment to Hutson.
 
+- is not that relevant to evaluate players. I don’t think he’s a top tier defensive defenseman but he’s not as bad as the Bruins fans claim to be. He could be a replacement for Savard, depending on the price.
+- is not always relevant but sometimes it help with additionalcontext. I believe most of that list includes top defensive defenseman in the league.
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20250303_124558_Chrome.jpg
    Screenshot_20250303_124558_Chrome.jpg
    72.1 KB · Views: 1
  • Like
Reactions: sampollock
And?? Come on man whatever reason you might say. If Carlo was that elite defensively, he wouldn't have the same amount of time 5 vs 5 and on the PK as Andrew f***ing Peeke.

I think he is good and would fit great on our D core but elite?? I don't think so.


He's regressed, and is not at all physical. He's also slow as molasses. One of the slowest defensemen in the league. He is decent defensively, but he's nothing more than a Hall Gill without the Cup experience.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Benstheman

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad