HF Habs: Trade Proposal Thread #88: 2024-25 Season

[BaseballCoach]

NJ says no. And block Montreal's number. They don't need Matheson.

No thanks, we have enough young talented defencemen, we don't need to trade our ripe talented defenceman for one more.

 

[Beendair Donedat]

Did you watch the playoffs last year? The guy sucks. Not sure he's a NHL player he certainly did not look like one last year. If we try to improve the team let's imrpove it for real. Let's try to grab a 26-28 years old right handed defensive dman who can be a 3rd / 4th dman.

Let's not repeat the mistakes of MB and try to surround young players with the likes of end of career Douglas Murray ad Francis Bouillon. If we need help let's grab some real help not some guys we found at the salvation army. We already have those and we can't wait for them to be gone.

Stop gap.

He’d be here this year and part of next. I agree he’s not ideal. But at this point I’d rather take him and the pick rather than Barron, and Mailloux and/or Reinbacher are at least another year away.

He’d just be a placeholder.

 

[Sterling Archer]

Habs need a POS 4th liner who’ll run the other team at will. Tired of Habs always being the victims.

 

[Vachon23]

Habs need a POS 4th liner who’ll run the other team at will. Tired of Habs always being the victims.

Try Luke Tuch

 

[Boss Man Hughes]

Try Luke Tuch

Does he do that?

 

[Treb]

Does he do that?

He hits a bunch.

 

[Vachon23]

Does he do that?

He finish every check and he’s an easy option to bring in

 

[vokiel]

Some Canucks fans are considering Matheson, involving their 2026 1st, so ...

There's a chance...

 

[Sterling Archer]

Try Luke Tuch

He’s not a dirty rat who will get under the other teams skin.

 

[Garry Valk]

He’s not a dirty rat who will get under the other teams skin.

The answer a Brendan Lemieux

 

[Vachon23]

He’s not a dirty rat who will get under the other teams skin.

He’s the easiest option to bring to for a physical player

 

[Sterling Archer]

He’s the easiest option to bring to for a physical player

He’s not the profile I’m talking about. I want a dirty, irritating player who’ll run at players. Tuck is a solid physical player but he’s not going to get the other team off their game or run players.

 

[Vachon23]

He’s not the profile I’m talking about. I want a dirty, irritating player who’ll run at players. Tuck is a solid physical player but he’s not going to get the other team off their game or run players.

I understand what type of player you want and I agree but those type of player are usually not available by trade. Maybe as FA