Toughness or two way

[895]

Player for player, Team 1 is better.

I just don't think there's any chemistry there.

 

[HolyHagelin]

Assuming “at peak,” team 1 easily.

 

[Neutrinos]

Pronger and Weber are/were better 2 way players than Pietro. Iginla wasn't just tough he was an elite 2 way power forward, same goes for Lindros. OV is the only one in group 1 who lacked defensively, pretty easy vote.

Also Marchand is the weak link bringing team 2 down


Last D man to win the Hart I believe

Last to win the Hart, and the only since Orr...

Also lead the league in +/- multiple times... last Dman to do that since Orr as well

 

[Roof Daddy]

I think it’s close, but I’ll take team 1. Even if they were even in terms of success, or possibly team 2 wins a bit more, I’d still take team 1 because they’d be infinitely more entertaining to watch.

 

[Jack Spider]

Perhaps power forward/defensive dman with skills vs 2-way player ?

Toughness is not a type of player. I think it's more of a trait of skills. Ovi is a sniper that brings toughness.

Idk if it's meant to compare the value of one type of player or just this lineup. voted for option 1.