Nothing hype train about it, Matthews is literally on pace to be the greatest goal scorer of all time, hasn't done shit in the playoffs. Marner is probably top 20 in terms of production in the season last 20 years. Tavares was a legit top 10C in the league for a while, all of them disappear in the playoffs.
Nylander and Rielly have been better in the playoffs, so you add all that together you'd expect a run or two.
It's not even cup or bust, if they were legit contenders every year and had a cup appearance, I think 90% of reasonable fans would be happy.
This team has failed utterly and spectacularly, I think failure is somewhat ok if it hasn't been so top down as well. Shanahan was trash, Dubas was trash, Keefe was trash and they all more or less are off the hook (like the players).
They squandered arguably the most talented team we've had in 60 years.
It's so bad that there is an outside chance one of McDrai may outscore Matthews/Tavares/Nylander/Marner's CAREER playoff production in a single year. Hyman may score more goals in a single playoffs than Nylander's entire playoff career, he has already outscored Tavares (his toronto stats anyways) and Marner. I use Edmonton as a comparable because people thought Matthews and co were on that level (not even CLOSE while being paid the same/more than McDrai)
This team legit had a chance to win a cup and go on RUNS, but due to sheer typical Leaf incompetence that funneled its way down to the players, they failed. Matthews/Marner/Tavares/Nylander/Rielly have in a single playoffs 2 more wins than Kadri and Kessel.