Proposal: - [TOR/CAR] Blockbuster: Matthews and Rielly for Slavin and Aho | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League

Proposal: [TOR/CAR] Blockbuster: Matthews and Rielly for Slavin and Aho

Do both teams do it?

Carolina gets a superstar forward that will fill seats. Also an elite game breaker. Nikishin replaces Slavin.

Toronto gets their #1D. Moves Tanev down to the 2nd pair.
I don't think Carolina does this unless they know Matthews will resign with them.
 
The Triangle is rolling in money, the team is good, and a rudimentary search shows that "filling seats" is not a problem for a team that sells out every game.

Carolina already has superstar forwards, already fills seats to capacity, and has had routine playoff success. They need to figure out how to push past the wall they commonly encounter in the second or third rounds. Yet both Toronto players have consistently failed to thrive in the playoffs. How are they the solution to Carolina's issues? They'd be better off targeting a Bennett type to complement their mix.

Slavin's a top-tier No. 1 defenseman on an extremely team-friendly deal with lots of good term. Nikishin is a kid, eight years younger than Slavin. It will be years before he might become that caliber of player. Carolina's window is open right now. Rielly hardly makes up for the loss, and has his own travails to work through.

Carolina says no, and I doubt they need much time to consider it.
 
Carolina easily says no. Toronto easily says yes. Matthews and Aho are similar players in terms of resources needed to make them work well and Aho comes in at a cheaper price. And then Slavin is the superior defenseman.
 
Carolina easily says no. Toronto easily says yes. Matthews and Aho are similar players in terms of resources needed to make them work well and Aho comes in at a cheaper price. And then Slavin is the superior defenseman.
Huh ? Matthews is a 69 goal scorer, Aho’s best season is 89 points and he’s never been a top 5 player in the league
 
Have to consider contracts and playoff performance. Add in concerns about Matthews’ back and huge gap between Slavin and Reilly and there is no chance the Canes consider this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DaveG and SnS

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

Ad

Ad