Not even close:
Lindsay: 5'8"/160
Hart voting - 4th(1949), 5th(1948), 6th(1947), 6th(1950), 7th(1959), 10th(1956)
Points finishes: 1st, 2nd, 2nd, 2nd, 3rd, 3rd, 7th, 9th
Goals finishes: 1st, 2nd, 2nd, 3rd, 3rd, 5th, 6th, 6th, 6th, 6th, 9th
Assist finishes: 1st, 1st, 3rd, 3rd, 3rd, 4th, 7th, 9th
All Star LW for 9 straight seasons:
1st Team All Star in 1948, 1950, 1951, 1952, 1953, 1954, 1955, 1956, 1957
2nd Team All Star in 1949
4x SC
Play-off Points - 1st(1952), 2nd(1949), 2nd(1955), 5th(1950), 6th(1953), 6th(1954), 7th(1956), 10th(1957)
Play-off Goals - 1st(1952), 3rd(1956), 4th(1950), 4th(1954), 4th(1955), 5th(1953), 6th(1948), 7th(1965), 9th(1957), 10th(1949)
Play-off Assists - 1st(1949), 1st(1955), 6th(1954), 8th(1950), 8th(1953), 9th(1957), 10th(1952)
5 Year Peak: 1948 to 1952
2nd in Points, 97% of 1st place Gordie Howe
3rd in Goals, 89% of 2nd place Maurice Richard
1st in Assists, 105% of 2nd place Gordie Howe
3rd in Play-off Points, 82% of 2nd place Ted Kennedy
10 Year Peak: 1948 to 1957
2nd in Points, 85% of 1st place Gordie Howe
3rd in Goals, 81% of 2nd place Maurice Richard
2nd in Assists, 91% of 1st place Gordie Howe
2nd in Play-off Points, 95% of 1st place Gordie Howe
Scoring Percentages:
Points - 116, 113, 110, 102, 100, 100, 89, 87, 70, 70, 67, 55, 51
Best 6 Seasons: 641
Next 6 Seasons: 438
"defensive ability" - Frank Orr
"ability to get under the skin of opponents" - Frank Orr
"(We could all) could shoot and score, everybody could carry the puck, and everybody's full intent was, "if I had to hit somebody, I would do so."" - Gordie Howe
Marchand: 5'9"/181 (needs to be updated)
Stanley Cup (2011)
1st in playoff EV goals (2010-11)
6th in goals (2015-16)
1st in goals, World Cup of Hockey 2016
4th in goals (2016-17)
5th in points (2016-17)
2016-17 NHL All-Star Team (1st)
Since Marchand’s first full season in 2010-11, through February 20, 2017-18 he ranks high in several categories among NHL players.
1st in plus-minus (+185)
1st in shorthanded goals (23) and in shorthanded points (36)
1st in backhand goals (49) and backhand shooting percentage (29.3%)
6th in shooting percentage (16.1%)