Top Ten Best Fighters of All-Time?

[authentic]

I know Lindros didn't fight as much as these guys but you figure he would be right up there if he did. Anyway, my list.

Domi
Domi
Domi
Domi
Domi
Domi
Domi
Domi
Probert
Domi

 

[Sheppy]

I know Lindros didn't fight as much as these guys but you figure he would be right up there if he did. Anyway, my list.

Domi
Domi
Domi
Domi
Domi
Domi
Domi
Domi
Probert
Domi

 

[Vachon23]

I'm 22 so Laraque was probably the best I saw

 

[salibandy2581]

Bob Probert
Nick Fotiu
Behn Wilson
Dave Brown
Donald Brashear
Clark Gillies
Marty McSorley
Stan Jonathan
Tim Hunter
John Kordic

 

[mulefarm]

Dave Ricther of the North Stars would be in top ten.

 

[scallionjj11]

Does Cam Jansson get a mention?

 

[Drytoast]

Probert
Wilson
Brashear
Chara
Domi
Gillis
Clark
ORielly
McSorely
Simon

 

[Sheppy]

Does Cam Jansson get a mention?

I thought Janssen was pretty bad, honestly. He was a willing guy, but would rarely ever land good punches. He'd always dip his head as far away as possible, tell the refs to go away, and proceed to punch a shoulder pad for a minute.

Willing guy, but insanely overrated imo.

 

[Therick67]

Does Cam Jansson get a mention?

Loved Janssen, he'd fight anyone. But he wasn't all that good at it.

 

[scallionjj11]

Loved Janssen, he'd fight anyone. But he wasn't all that good at it.

You're right, I think his craziness and willing to fight anyone really drew my attention to him.

 

[Therick67]

You're right, I think his craziness and willing to fight anyone really drew my attention to him.

He was also usually giving up a lot of height and weight. Think he was maybe 6'.

 

[scallionjj11]

He was also usually giving up a lot of height and weight. Think he was maybe 6'.

They had him on a podcast the other day and he was very entertaining to listen to.

 

[Therick67]

They had him on a podcast the other day and he was very entertaining to listen to.

Do you recall which one?

 

[scallionjj11]

Do you recall which one?

Spitten Chicklets podcast, it was yesterdays episode.

 

[Therick67]

Spitten Chicklets podcast, it was yesterdays episode.

Thanks. I'll check it out...

 

[skuzzycuzz]

I think if Rick Rypien was still playing he’d be on most people’s list. What an interesting little player he was. RIP

 

[lancer247]

Dave Ricther of the North Stars would be in top ten.

Very underrated

 

[lancer247]

I know Lindros didn't fight as much as these guys but you figure he would be right up there if he did. Anyway, my list.

Domi
Domi
Domi
Domi
Domi
Domi
Domi
Domi
Probert
Domi

Needs more Domi.

 

[lancer247]

I would sneak Berube in on that list. He is one of the few guys to win the majority of his fights with Probert.

 

[Frenchy]

Not placing him in the top 10 , but pound for pound , Mario Roberge was underrated in the 90's.

 

[Fred McCarthy]

Stan Jonathan , Clark Gillies , Orland Kurtainbach,

 

[Boxscore]

1. Bob Probert
2. Tony Twist
3. Dave Brown
4. Behn Wilson
5. Derek Boogaard
6. John Ferguson
7. Donald Brashear
8. Joey Kocur
9. Tie Domi
10. Chris Nilan

HM: Chris Simon, Stu Grimson, Troy Crowder (peak), Schultz/Williams/O'Reilly for straight up 70's goon hockey factor.

 

[Boxscore]

Not placing him in the top 10 , but pound for pound , Mario Roberge was underrated in the 90's.

You are correct. Roberge was nasty. He had some dandies with Kimble.

 

[DaaaaB's]

Bob Probert
Dave Brown
Behn Wilson
Georges Laraque
Clark Gillies
Joey Kocur
Larry Playfair
Derek Boogaard
Marty McSorley
Tony Twist

HM's to Sandy McCarthy, Dan Maloney, Chris Simon, Bob Nystrom, Nick Fotiu

 

[SotasicA]

Bob Probert
Behn Wilson
Dave Brown
Tony Twist
Marty McSorley
Georges Laraque
Derek Boogaard
Larry Playfair
Nick Fotiu
Stu Grimson

I really wanted to include Eric Cairns, but his peak was short. Same with a lot of guys who reigned as champs for awhile.

And this list changes in time.