Last 3 seasons combined:
Drai - 209 games, 299 points, 124 goals (1.43 ppg)
Mack - 199 games, 257 points, 96 goals (1.29 ppg)
Last 2 seasons only:
Drai - 127 games, 194 points, 74 goals (1.53 ppg)
Mack - 117 games, 158 points, 55 goals (1.35 ppg)
Gap grows looking at just past 2 years.
Drai swept the awards last year - Mack has no awards to show.
It's true that Mack has been better in the playoffs - but Drai has actual decent enough production there, just low game count. 11 points in 8 games past 2 years. Are Mack's playoff performances really enough to outdo the massive edge in regular season production Drai has over the past 3 years? Especially since - Colorado still has yet to make it out of round 2 in the playoffs, so it's all early round performance.
Similar tier players - but my vote is Drai. I'd have Mack at #4