Toggle sidebar

Top 15 from 2017-2020 drafts

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
Status
Not open for further replies.
1) Lafreniere
2) Heiskanen
3) Q. Hughes
4) Pettersson
5) Makar
6) Svechnikov
7) Dahlin
8) J. Hughes
9) Dach
10) Stutzle
11) Zegras
12) Tkachuk
13) Byfield
14) Cozens
15) Seider
HM) N. Suzuki, Sandin and Drysdale

clear drop off after the top 7. Still lots of good young players to choose from after that though.
 
Dion TheFluff said:
1) Lafreniere
2) Heiskanen
3) Q. Hughes
4) Pettersson
5) Makar
6) Svechnikov
7) Dahlin
8) J. Hughes
9) Dach
10) Stutzle
11) Zegras
12) Tkachuk
13) Byfield
14) Cozens
15) Seider
HM) N. Suzuki, Sandin and Drysdale

clear drop off after the top 7. Still lots of good young players to choose from after that though.
Click to expand...
You couldn't resist :laugh:
It was physically impossible for you to not include a leaf on a list where he is quite obviously the odd man out
 
ColoradoCanes said:
You couldn't resist :laugh:
It was physically impossible for you to not include a leaf on a list where he is quite obviously the odd man out
Click to expand...
- was top defenseman at the world juniors last year
- has the best U19 and 3rd best (min 10 games) U20 (behind Erik Karlsson and John Carlson) seasons for defenceman in the AHL over the past 20 years
- was ranked the 6th best NHL affiliated prospect by Craig Button last year

I don't see what's so controversial about me having him listed as an HM but then again you are quite notorious for being extremely biased towards and against certain teams.

Also if you are gonna call out a list, there are far worst ones on here than the one I presented IMO.
 
Dion TheFluff said:
- was top defenseman at the world juniors last year
- has the best U19 and 3rd best (min 10 games) U20 (behind Erik Karlsson and John Carlson) seasons for defenceman in the AHL over the past 20 years
- was ranked the 6th best NHL affiliated prospect by Craig Button last year

I don't see what's so controversial about me having him listed as an HM but then again you are quite notorious for being extremely biased towards and against certain teams.

Also if you are gonna call out a list, there are far worst ones on here than the one I presented IMO.
Click to expand...
I'm "notorious for being extremely biased towards and against certain teams" when you're the one who just said Sandin was the 17th best player drafted between 2017-2020.

Sandin was ranked 28th among prospects (as a consensus on a board with a ton of leaf fans).
HFBoards TOP 75 Prospects Ranking #69 (nice)

And that list of prospects ranked ahead of Sandin doesn't include current NHL players like: Heiskanen, Q. Hughes, Pettersson, Makar, Svechnikov, Dahlin, J. Hughes, Kakko, Dach, Suzuki, Hischer and Tkachuk.

In what world is Sandin the 17th best player drafted over the past 4 drafts?
So I'm the biased one because I called you out?
Get a grip.

Edit: And what lists are worst? I disagree with a couple people who said Raymond was in the top 15, but at least he is somewhat close. And that one guy listed a bunch of Canuck prospects but some people already called him out. So yeah, if I was going to call any list out it'd be yours. And your list wasn't even bad until the Sandin HM. I didn't even call your list out, I was just laughing that you didn't have the self control to not include a leaf player.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: AvsFan29
This will be an interesting thread to look back on. This is my list:

1. Lafreniere
2. Pettersson
--
3. Makar
4. Stutzle
5. Heiskanen
6. Dahlin
--
7. Q. Hughes
8. Svechnikov
9. Seider
--
10. J. Hughes
11. Hischier
12. Zegras
13. Byfield
--
14. Tkachuk
15. Dach

Jack Hughes and Byfield being the two with the most potential to move up or down. Drysdale/Lundell/Raymond next in line.
 
Pettersson
Makar
Heiskanen
Svechnikov
Dahlin
Tkachuk
Zegras
Lafreniere
Stuetzle
Cozens
Q Hughes
Dach
Kotkaniemi
Kakko
Drysdale
Byram
J Hughes
Hischier
Byfield
 
Dion TheFluff said:
about the same level probably. Outside of draft position, I don't see anything Byram has done to be ranked considerably higher.
Click to expand...
I thought Sandin was supposed to be a big deal until a Leaf fan told me he was behind Holl, Bogo, and Dermott aka crap. I was shocked. So hearing that, no he isnt in Byram universe yet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ColoradoCanes
  1. Elias Pettersson
  2. to 4. Cale Makar/Quinn Hughes/ Miro Heinskanen


  5. Rasmus Dahlin
  6. Alexis Lafreniere
  7. Tim Stuztle
  8. Andrei Svechnikov
  9. Jack Hughes
  10. Jamie Drysdale
  11. Bowen Byram
  12. Brady Tkachuk
  13. Kappo Kakko
  14. Nico Hischier
  15. Kirby Dach
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: AvsFan29
ColoradoCanes said:
I'm "notorious for being extremely biased towards and against certain teams" when you're the one who just said Sandin was the 17th best player drafted between 2017-2020.

Sandin was ranked 28th among prospects (as a consensus on a board with a ton of leaf fans).
HFBoards TOP 75 Prospects Ranking #69 (nice)

And that list of prospects ranked ahead of Sandin doesn't include current NHL players like: Heiskanen, Q. Hughes, Pettersson, Makar, Svechnikov, Dahlin, J. Hughes, Kakko, Dach, Suzuki, Hischer and Tkachuk.

In what world is Sandin the 17th best player drafted over the past 4 drafts?
So I'm the biased one because I called you out?
Get a grip.

Edit: And what lists are worst? I disagree with a couple people who said Raymond was in the top 15, but at least he is somewhat close. And that one guy listed a bunch of Canuck prospects but some people already called him out. So yeah, if I was going to call any list out it'd be yours. And your list wasn't even bad until the Sandin HM. I didn't even call your list out, I was just laughing that you didn't have the self control to not include a leaf player.
Click to expand...

Imagine trying to use an HF poll where Oilers fans voted in Broberg as the 16th best prospect as an accurate reflection on prospect ranking :laugh:

Outside of Kakko (who was terrible in the NHL last year) and Hischier (who i don't believe has a ton of upside) I had all of those NHL players ranked ahead of him.

for the record, after Byfield I believe there are probably a dozen - 2 dozens players who are all in and around the same tier. Those are just the 3 that I decided to list.

As for other questionable/bad ratings how about Askarov in the top 15 or Seider ranked 4th above Q. Hughes, Dahlin, and Makar or Kotkaniemi ranked 11th or Zegras and Stutzle ranked above Pettersson or Byram ranked above Q. Hughes and Dahlin or Chinakov as an HM?
Are you going to call out any of those?
 
1. Pettersson
2. Heiskanen

is clear top2 on my books. Makar, Dahlin, Svech following from some distance.
 
Dion TheFluff said:
1) Lafreniere
2) Heiskanen
3) Q. Hughes
4) Pettersson
5) Makar
6) Svechnikov
7) Dahlin
8) J. Hughes
9) Dach
10) Stutzle
11) Zegras
12) Tkachuk
13) Byfield
14) Cozens
15) Seider
HM) N. Suzuki, Sandin and Drysdale

clear drop off after the top 7. Still lots of good young players to choose from after that though.
Click to expand...
Lol! Nice try to sneak that one in. :laugh:
 
  • Like
Reactions: ColoradoCanes
1. Sandin
2. Robertson
3. Liljegren
4. Amirov
5. Niemela
6. Abramov
7. Hallander
8. Hirvonen
9. Abbruzzese
10. Kokkonen
11. Der-Arguchintsev
12. Kral
13. Miettinen
14. Ovechinnikov
15. Scott
HM: Alexis Lafreniere, Elias Pettersson, Rasmus Dahlin, Miro Heiskanen
 
  • Like
Reactions: Thomp94, Nosskire ot Elgaeb and WetcoastOrca
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom