That Ryan Reaves vote is some nasty work for a $1.3M deal lol
Relatively speaking, Reaves is overpaid given he can't pass, shoot, skate or play hockey in general. He's below replacement level making above replacement level money. Certainly not a make or break type contract for Toronto, but by definition it is an overpayment.
Can certainly run his mouth at an elite level though.
The rest of votes are dumb tho. Seguins contract for example wouldn't look nearly as bad if his lower body didn't turn to dust just after signing it. Shesterkin shouldn't be anywhere near this list.