He was chosen cause he was the least offensive pick. They looked around the room and they really had no idea whom to pick. Nobody was standing out. (Except Price, he is the real leader). So they had the chance to choose between the crazy guy(PK) and the boring guy(Max), they picked the boring guy.
BTW, MT is stupid but boy Villeneuve is nuts. Why would he report something that was said in confidence. After that they wonder why management act all secretives like a siege mentality.
I heard something interesting on the radio yesterday on the subject. MT supposedly said that people tell him a lot of crap all the time, and he doesn't have time or want to argue with these people. I can see it. The guy is well known.
The host was just putting this scenario out there, that seems like something that could have happened.
MT : Hey, how are you? (shaking hands with people).
Guy1 : Boy, I gotta tell you Michel, huge Habs fans, but you guys have the wrong captain.
MT : Is that so? (continues to shake hands of people around).
Guy1 : Yeah, he's the worse in the Habs' history!
MT : Hmmm mmm. (not even paying attention, moving down the line).
Guy1 : YOU SEE, MT AGREES WITH, HE SAID THAT HE'S THE WORSE CAPTAIN IN HABS HISTORY.
I mean, MT can't argue with everyone that says **** about the team, his players, etc. I think he's a huge tool, but I can't possibly see a scenario where he would say such a thing in public. Especially not in the heat of a bad moment. Especially about a guy that supposedly has his back.
THe whole thing smells like BS.