The Worst player since the last lockout(04-05) for the Leafs?

[TMLegend]

Well have at her...

I'll say Andy Wozniewski...

The guy was beyond brutal offensively and defensively.

Click to read more...

 

[4evaBlue]

 

[Bomber0104]

Should make a rule though for this.

Guys who have actually spent a whole season here.

No AHL pluggers allowed.

 

[InShannyWeTrust]

Toskala...... come on he let a goal in from over 100ft!!

 

[7even]

Vesa Toskala. There's horrible, and then there's advanced horrible. And then there's Toskala.

 

[Suntouchable13]

Vesa Toskala. There's horrible, and then there's advanced horrible. And then there's Toskala.

He had a good run in 07-08 so he was not completely useless.

I will have to go with Stempniak, maybe a little bit off the board. Absolutely useless player.

 

[Bomber0104]

 

[LV*]

1. Vesa Toskala
2. Brett Lebda
3. Rickard Wallin


edit: switched Van Ryn for Wallin, both were awful though. I win this thread.

 

[Stephen]

I'll say Andrew Raycroft. In addition to being a flake and a sieve in net, he also came across like an arrogant, disinterested ***** off the ice.

 

[JAMmer124]

 

[InShannyWeTrust]

I'll say Andrew Raycroft. In addition to being a flake and a sieve in net, he also came across like an arrogant, disinterested ***** off the ice.

he did have 37 wins one season

 

[Bomber0104]

We as Leafs fans have plenty to choose from.

Thanks Burke/JFJ!

 

[LV*]

he did have 37 wins one season

Along with a stellar .894% save percentage and an amazing 2.99 GAA, right?

Such a joke the 2009-10 team was, remember Primeau and Exelby? Omg..

 

[TootooTrain]

Jean-Sebastien Aubin. Nobody has gone from hero to zero as quickly.

 

[TMLegend]

Along with a stellar .894% save percentage and an amazing 2.99 GAA, right?

That's what I find amazing about Raycroft.. He had 37 wins.. but he was plain awful. We could of had probably basically any other goalie and probably make the playoffs that year..

 

[TMLegend]

Along with a stellar .894% save percentage and an amazing 2.99 GAA, right?

Such a joke the 2009-10 team was, remember Primeau and Exelby? Omg..

Don't forget Rickard Wallin.. wasn't Jamie Lundmark apart of that team too?. lol

 

[Dangles McGavin]

Lombardi is up there, though I think he could bounce back... maybe.

Of course there are worse players... but last year he was good at literally nothing.

 

[Suntouchable13]

Along with a stellar .894% save percentage and an amazing 2.99 GAA, right?

Such a joke the 2009-10 team was, remember Primeau and Exelby? Omg..

Yeah, very unfortunate that we have lots of candidates to choose from for this thread.

 

[Bomber0104]

Wallin is the darkhorse pick in my opinion.

But I still believe it's Komisarek.

He still has plenty of bloopers left to show us.

 

[Dangles McGavin]

Dupuis has got to be up there too.

 

[charliolemieux]

MATS SUNDIN

Why?

His refusal, and the subsequent refusal of the rest of the Muskoka 5, to waive the NTC's set this team back in terms of a rebuild more than the Rask trade, the Toskala trade, and the Steen trade combined.

HE is the worst because he ****ed this team the most.

Appologies to those confused by that perspective.


............................

Talent wise there has been too many to count.

Teams used to target Hal Gill's side of the ice when he was in Toronto because he was such a freaking pilon. Then in 2009 he wins the cup as PIT's shutdown d-man. Bizarre.


Toskala is probably the #1 when you factor in what was expected.

What was expected was Kiprussof v2.0. What we got was garbage. Cost us a 1st in the process.

 

[Warden of the North]

In no particular order

Jason Allison
Brett Lebda
Rickard Wallin
Toskala
Hollweg

Boyd Deveraux earns a special spot for denying us Brayden Schenn with his season ending hat trick

 

[Kessely Snipes]

No way Komi is the worst...

IMO it has to be a close between Ledba and Toskala.

Toskala has the 100 ft goal, and Lebda, I remember he had a game where the Leafs had like 7 goals (or something, I'm sure someone can correct me) everyone was + and Ledba was somehow -3 haha.

 

[Stephen]

MATS SUNDIN

Why?

His refusal, and the subsequent refusal of the rest of the Muskoka 5, to waive the NTC's set this team back in terms of a rebuild more than the Rask trade, the Toskala trade, and the Steen trade combined.

HE is the worst because he ****ed this team the most.

Appologies to those confused by that perspective.


.

Oh shut it.

What was Montreal's offer to us, Grabovski, Higgins and a 1st?

Well, we got Grabovski for just about nothing, Higgins was a 43 point scorer last year, which represents his highest point totals since 2009 and that Montreal first in 2008 was Greg Nemisz.

 

[charliolemieux]

In no particular order

Jason Allison
Brett Lebda
Rickard Wallin
Toskala
Hollweg

Boyd Deveraux earns a special spot for denying us Brayden Schenn with his season ending hat trick

I see that and raise you one Martin Gerber going 6-5 to close out 08-09.

We could be talking Duchene or Kane here.