Proposal: The three way trade you're about to hate (DAL-SJS-ARI)

[The Real JT]

As an Isles fan I don’t have a dog in this fight.

I just stopped by to compliment the thread title.

 

[Groo]

But that supposes he goes from one rebuilding team for a few years to another rebuilding team for a few years. Usually players that want out, wanna get out of the ''rebuilding'' and into ''competing''.

I doubt very much were in the hunt,

 

[Kcoyote3]

As an Isles fan I don’t have a dog in this fight.

I just stopped by to compliment the thread title.

If you lower expectations from the beginning less people yell at you I feel

 

[Gecklund]

I don't love it from the sharks perspective --- Khudobin gives us Reimer, Hill, and Khudobin next year, which feels meh... So we're giving up Burns with retention, Wies, Barabanov, and a 1st for Chychrun... Chychrun is really good, and I would love him, but seems like a bit too much...

If we could get a happy Chychrun for that you take it.

 

[Dicdonya]

Not really feeling this for SJ.

I get why it would be enticing to get Chychrun, but SJ struggles offensively, desperately needs forwards with talent to fill out our terrible forward core, and Burns is still better offensively than Chychrun at this point in time.

I do not think this moves puts SJ in a better spot than if they did not make the trade at all, and depending on how Coe/Weisblatt develop, and the possibility that our 1st, even in 24 could be high, we might actually be worse in the long term. Also since we are retaining on Burns, it does nothing for our cap concerns either, assuming we do not rebuild and keep Hertl.

So while in a vacuum replacing Burns with Chychrun would be overall positive moving forward, looking at the full picture I do not think this move makes sense for SJ.

 

[chirrrs]

Didn't realize Cogliano wore out his welcome with Dallas lol

Thought he could help the PK for them

It's not so much that Cogliano was bad as much as it was him being frequently used in situations where he shouldn't have been.

 

[kthx]

I think this is very well thought out 3-way trade.
Would be interesting if this happened.

 

[vatali]

Who ever gets san jose's first says thank you and runs

 

[Sports2]

I think Dallas has their hands full with the Benn and Seguin contracts. Even at 50% I think they would hold off purely for length of the contract.

 

[ThePlanet]

This is one of those cases where somehow everyone loses, and absolutely no one wins.

Easy no from this SJ fan.

 

[Kcoyote3]

This is one of those cases where somehow everyone loses, and absolutely no one wins.

Easy no from this SJ fan.

If everyone loses, no one wins so I’m happy with the balance

 

[ThePlanet]

If everyone loses, no one wins so I’m happy with the balance

Just practicing my Maddenisms.

 

[The Tourist]

Cogliano yuck. I suffered enough with him on Dallas the last few years. Least favorite player in the league. He shoots like a 12 yr old.