Proposal: The three way trade you're about to hate (DAL-SJS-ARI)

[Kcoyote3]

To SJS: (+0.983 million)

Chychrun
Khudobin

To DAL: (-0.583 million)

Burns at 5 million (3 million retained x 4 seasons)
Barabanov
Cogliano

To Ari: (-0.40 million)

Klingberg -flipped to a contender for 1st/prospect
2024 1st from SJ
Brandon Coe/Ozzy Wiesblatt


SJS does this because they want to rebuild their D, Burns is still valuable, Dallas is likely on his trade list, and at 5 million he's valuable to a team. Barabanov and Cogliano are not in the long-term plans. Sharks goalie depth is bad, and Khudobin may help that, or just help balance out the cap aspect. Chychrun is young, a LD who can provide offense. Sharks top 4 looks like Chychrun-Karlsson, Ferraro-Merkley for the foreseeable future. Trade fits a retooling team.

Dallas does this because they get a Klingberg replacement at 5 million. They also get some forward depth for the playoff push this year. They get Khudobin off the books too, frees up a little more space for next year, re-sign Barby or Pavs if you want to. Pavs and Burns together again could be fun. Trade fits a contending team trying to extend their window.

Arizona does this because they get a 1st from SJ in 2024, which is a gamble for SJ, if they're still bad that could be a very high pick, plus a good forward prospect, and likely another 1st/prospect for Klingberg to a contender. Trade fits a rebuilding tear down team.

Click to read more...

 

[Bluto]

I think everyone says no.

 

[Johno]

Keep Cogliano the hell away from us!

 

[Alaskanice]

To SJS: (+0.983 million)

Chychrun
Khudobin

To DAL: (-0.583 million)

Burns at 5 million (3 million retained x 4 seasons)
Barabanov
Cogliano

To Ari: (-0.40 million)

Klingberg -flipped to a contender for 1st/prospect
2024 1st from SJ
Brandon Coe/Ozzy Wiesblatt


SJS does this because they want to rebuild their D, Burns is still valuable, Dallas is likely on his trade list, and at 5 million he's valuable to a team. Barabanov and Cogliano are not in the long-term plans. Sharks goalie depth is bad, and Khudobin may help that, or just help balance out the cap aspect. Chychrun is young, a LD who can provide offense. Sharks top 4 looks like Chychrun-Karlsson, Ferraro-Merkley for the foreseeable future. Trade fits a retooling team.

Dallas does this because they get a Klingberg replacement at 5 million. They also get some forward depth for the playoff push this year. They get Khudobin off the books too, frees up a little more space for next year, re-sign Barby or Pavs if you want to. Pavs and Burns together again could be fun. Trade fits a contending team trying to extend their window.

Arizona does this because they get a 1st from SJ in 2024, which is a gamble for SJ, if they're still bad that could be a very high pick, plus a good forward prospect, and likely another 1st/prospect for Klingberg to a contender. Trade fits a rebuilding tear down team.

Well thought out and I wouldn’t cry if it happened.

 

[Viqsi]

Full breakdown:

San Jose gives up: SJS 2024 1st, Brandon Coe/Ozzy Weisblatt, Alexander Barabanov, Andrew Cogliano, Brent Burns ($3m retained)
San Jose gets: Jacob Chychrun, Anton Khudobin

Dallas gives up: Anton Khudobin, John Klingberg
Dallas gets: Brent Burns ($3m retained), Alexander Barabanov, Andrew Cogliano

Arizona gives up: Jacob Chychrun
Arizona gets: John Klingberg, SJS 2024 1st, one of Brandon Coe/Ozzy Weisblatt

Not sure if the thread delivers on its promise, but I can definitely see potential for it to do so. Particularly for Dallas.

 

[MNRube]

Don’t know much about Barabonov, but I think Dallas is going to pass. Have to think they get more from Klingberg elsewhere.

 

[Poppy Whoa Sonnet]

If I were Arizona I'd only consider it if I got SJ's unprotected 2023 1st and push hard for that. Klingberg return will be a late 2022 1st and B prospect most likely, you can't move Chychrun without getting something really exciting in the return.

 

[SnuggaRUDE]

 

[PacificOceanPotion]

Yes please.

 

[JesusNPucks]

From this Dallas fan, I’d do it.

 

[Jacob582]

They're not retaining $12M over four years.

 

[Rory]

I don’t want Cogs back but burns at 5 mil is pretty tempting. He will for sure replace klingbergs numbers.

 

[Dr Pepper]

Yeah I don't see Dallas bringing Cogs back, the rest of the deal looks enticing though.

 

[rt]

Makes zero sense for Arizona. Trade your own damn Klingberg.

 

[zwixrr]

If you brought in a 4th team as a partner for Arizona to ship Klingberg off to to guarantee a pick then yes it probably makes sense for all parties.

 

[Kcb12345]

Get Cogliano out of that deal rn....will give you a 1st to keep him out

 

[rt]

If you brought in a 4th team as a partner for Arizona to ship Klingberg off to to guarantee a pick then yes it probably makes sense for all parties.

A late ‘22 1st, a ‘24 1st and Coe/Wiesblatt should not be enough for Chychrun. Maybe if it was Coe AND Wiesblatt.

 

[Kcoyote3]

Didn't realize Cogliano wore out his welcome with Dallas lol

Thought he could help the PK for them

 

[ThorNton Apologist]

This is not a trade SJ should be making. Chychrun definitely helps but he doesn’t make the sharks a playoff team

 

[Groo]

This is not a trade SJ should be making. Chychrun definitely helps but he doesn’t make the sharks a playoff team

He'd be a long term player for the Sharks

 

[fasterthanlight]

I don't love it from the sharks perspective --- Khudobin gives us Reimer, Hill, and Khudobin next year, which feels meh... So we're giving up Burns with retention, Wies, Barabanov, and a 1st for Chychrun... Chychrun is really good, and I would love him, but seems like a bit too much...

 

[Djp]

To SJS: (+0.983 million)

Chychrun
Khudobin

To DAL: (-0.583 million)

Burns at 5 million (3 million retained x 4 seasons)
Barabanov
Cogliano

To Ari: (-0.40 million)

Klingberg -flipped to a contender for 1st/prospect
2024 1st from SJ
Brandon Coe/Ozzy Wiesblatt


SJS does this because they want to rebuild their D, Burns is still valuable, Dallas is likely on his trade list, and at 5 million he's valuable to a team. Barabanov and Cogliano are not in the long-term plans. Sharks goalie depth is bad, and Khudobin may help that, or just help balance out the cap aspect. Chychrun is young, a LD who can provide offense. Sharks top 4 looks like Chychrun-Karlsson, Ferraro-Merkley for the foreseeable future. Trade fits a retooling team.

Dallas does this because they get a Klingberg replacement at 5 million. They also get some forward depth for the playoff push this year. They get Khudobin off the books too, frees up a little more space for next year, re-sign Barby or Pavs if you want to. Pavs and Burns together again could be fun. Trade fits a contending team trying to extend their window.

Arizona does this because they get a 1st from SJ in 2024, which is a gamble for SJ, if they're still bad that could be a very high pick, plus a good forward prospect, and likely another 1st/prospect for Klingberg to a contender. Trade fits a rebuilding tear down team.

Arizona gets screwed over the most.

 

[Pinkfloyd]

Arizona definitely gets screwed out of Chychrun here.

 

[Stubu]

I think everyone says no.

We don't, so please explain why you say no.

(I would probably say no but I'd explain.)

 

[powerstuck]

He'd be a long term player for the Sharks

But that supposes he goes from one rebuilding team for a few years to another rebuilding team for a few years. Usually players that want out, wanna get out of the ''rebuilding'' and into ''competing''.