Tribute The Ten Best NSH Preds Ever Are:
- Thread starter Ben Grimm
- Start date
Should probably be more players from the 05-10 era on there.
Sullivan
DuMont
Arnott
To name a few
Radalov maybe, if you want to get booed.
Sullivan
DuMont
Arnott
To name a few
Radalov maybe, if you want to get booed.
How long do they have to be on the team to be considered? Are you counting the time they played only for the Preds or entire career?
Yeh this will definitely impact some answers.
Peter Forsberg is definitely one of the greats if you look at his entire career. If you are just looking at the 22 games he played in Nashville though.... i wouldnt even consider him here.
Last edited:
Armourboy
Hey! You suck!
Right. I would consider him a great player, but Spaling made more of impact than he did
Predsanddead24
Registered User
- Mar 7, 2019
- 5,754
- 6,303
Forsberg might actually be one of the biggest disappointments as a Pred ever. He wasn't bad but he also was a shell of his former self and we gave up quite a lot to get him.
Porter Stoutheart
Seen Stamkos?
- Jun 14, 2017
- 15,857
- 12,236
I kind of voted on all-round "bests", with a slight lean to "best years as a Pred", and an even fainter lean to longevity. I think I picked P.Forsberg, but obviously that has nothing to do with his time as a Pred. Arnott or Sullivan take that vote if you are just going by Pred-ness.
Feel like this should be just their time as a Pred. Otherwise you end up with situation with Brodeur and Gretzky as greatest Blue and Messier as greatest Canuck and it doesn't really represent the actual fan experience.
Gnashville
HFBoards Hall of Famer
It’s hard to include Peter Forsberg since he played like 17 games here. Certainly career wise he would be top 5 on that list but almost none of that was in Nashville.
