It is irrelevant who was rated higher, a GMs role in the draft is to choose the best player the team sees fit and will make the biggest impact.
Jimmy Mann was a flop
Babych was good but nothing like the other 3
Kyte was a tall bum
McBain could score here and there but was never a Neely
Stewart was their biggest bust in the Ferguson era.
Elyniuk had a few good seasons but Brian Leetch is well, Brian Leetch.
The thing is, these players may have developed into superstars on other teams but on the Jets team tehy were constantly surrounded by role players and had few top notch players.
Hawerchuk during this period was a perrenial all-star, Paul McLean was their sniper of sorts, Steen was talented but injured, Ellett was a good defenseman, Olausson was good offensively however for everyone of them there was so many Doug Smail, Laurie Boschman (who had 3 very good years, then we dealt him for Bob Brooke who didnt play a game for us), Gilles Hamel, Tim Watters, Mario Marois who were honestly nothing special. Winnipeg NEVER had a solid goaltender. Hayward during the 80s would have to have been our best and we dealt him for Steve Penny a prospect who was playing well on a defensive minded Canadiens and Jan Ingman a 1st round pick in 1981 who NEVER left Sweden. So in essence we dealt our best goaltender for a prospect goaltender. He traded Dave Christian a solid offensive player for a 1st rounder (Bobby Dollas), he traded Brian Mullen another offensive player for draft picks. Paul McLean was moved for Brent Ashton another role player. It just seemed that every single trade John Furguson made, made the team worse than it already was.