The "no.1" line/Carlyle's usage of centers | Page 3 | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League

The "no.1" line/Carlyle's usage of centers

Can someone care to explain why Tyler Bozak is firmly entrenched on the Leafs first line all the time?

The JVR-Bozak-Kessel might be the "no.1" line of the team but they aren't very effective as a unit. They are constantly in their own end, they give up a ton of chances & this is inspite of the fact Bozak seems to be good on the draws. Why not try someone else in the middle? Why does Tyler Bozak have this golden boy status with this organization when he has done nothing on the ice to justify it?

Why not Grabovski? I'm sitting there watching the Philly game & seeing our "genius" coach put Grabovski with the super talented Colton Orr. On top of putting him with McClement/ Komarov all season & dumb media types/fans want to ***** about the guys numbers. This guy has consistently out-produced Bozak in his time here but never really gets the ultimate shot on the top line, never plays on the first PP unit. Now he doesn't even get linemates that can help him produce offense & contribute to the team.

To me this is a chronic misuse of talent without even bringing up Kadri, who inspite of having the best season of any center on the team, combined with his playmaking potential, never gets the top PP time either.

Isn't it time we tried someone else up there? Especially now when there seems to be options?

Faceoffs matter. The coach you're sarcastically whizzing on got this bunch into the playoffs for the first time in ages. I like Grabovski too, I think he has a lot of fire in his belly but this is Carlyle's way of getting him to play with that fire every night. If he did, he probably would be on the first line despite being poor on the draw. Bozak has done a great job of winning faceoffs, and he's contributing enough on offense while playing against other team's top lines that he's worth having there.
 
What is this statement......Joey Crabb was much better with just slightly less playing time together as well as Kulie and C Mac were better with a far larger sample size....Crabb was 75%

MGK was a really excellent line.

All I'm saying is that it's a myth that Kessel and Grabo don't work well together. They clearly score a lot of goals and shoot the puck a lot. I wouldn't use those numbers to say that they will definitely be good together in the future. Just that they have been good together in the past. I doubt if they were paired together that they would maintain that level of domination. But I think Grabo-Kessel would outshoot opponents and play in the offensive zone where Bozak-Kessel get outshot and play in the defensive zone.

In the past it may have been better to keep them separate, but now that Kadri is a top 6 center, we actually have 2 top six centers, and we should play them in top 6 positions. Either Kadri-Kessel or Grabo-Kessel would be fine by me. Need to get Bozak off the top PP unit and stop giving him 20 minutes a night.
 
MGK was a really excellent line.

All I'm saying is that it's a myth that Kessel and Grabo don't work well together. They clearly score a lot of goals and shoot the puck a lot. I wouldn't use those numbers to say that they will definitely be good together in the future. Just that they have been good together in the past. I doubt if they were paired together that they would maintain that level of domination. But I think Grabo-Kessel would outshoot opponents and play in the offensive zone where Bozak-Kessel get outshot and play in the defensive zone.

In the past it may have been better to keep them separate, but now that Kadri is a top 6 center, we actually have 2 top six centers, and we should play them in top 6 positions. Either Kadri-Kessel or Grabo-Kessel would be fine by me. Need to get Bozak off the top PP unit and stop giving him 20 minutes a night.

MGK started the year together and did not play that well.....

I'm with the group that believe that Grabo and Kessel would not be an effective pairing.

Grabo is most effective playing a cycle game and Kessel is least effective in playing that type of game.....there is no fit here in my eyes.

Moving Kadri to play with Kessel, makes us easy to defend against....
 
MGK started the year together and did not play that well.....

I'm with the group that believe that Grabo and Kessel would not be an effective pairing.

Grabo is most effective playing a cycle game and Kessel is least effective in playing that type of game.....there is no fit here in my eyes.

Moving Kadri to play with Kessel, makes us easy to defend against....
Lupul tends to play a cycle game and is still quite compatible with Kessel. As long as you create space for Kessel, he'll thrive. Grabovski would actually be rather effective due to his cycle game and intense playing style. In fact, JVR's performance would significantly improve as well.
 
To the people who think Grabovski is a offensive/chemistry black-hole: who is the most talented winger Grabovski has played with for any length of time? MacArthur? Kulemin?

Offensively, all those players can do is shoot hard. They see success with Kadri because he does all over the work for them. Grabovski's poor offensive chemistry with Kulemin and MacArthur (long-term) might be because those players can't cycle and maintain puck possession in the offensive zone with Grabovski to create anything sustainable.

I find the myth that Grabovski and Kessel don't work together annoying, because they have never been tried together for any significant length of time (particularly with a solid left winger). Grabovski would give Kessel a centreman who can keep puck possession and make plays in the offensive zone while still being competent defensively. Bozak is a poor puck possession player, which means Kessel spends more time setting up Bozak for scoring chances than vice versa.

Unfortunately, even if Bozak went elsewhere as a UFA, Carlyle still wouldn't consider putting Grabovski on Kessel's line until Grabovski can consistently win faceoffs.
 
To the people who think Grabovski is a offensive/chemistry black-hole: who is the most talented winger Grabovski has played with for any length of time? MacArthur? Kulemin?

Offensively, all those players can do is shoot hard. They see success with Kadri because he does all over the work for them. Grabovski's poor offensive chemistry with Kulemin and MacArthur (long-term) might be because those players can't cycle and maintain puck possession in the offensive zone with Grabovski to create anything sustainable.

I find the myth that Grabovski and Kessel don't work together annoying, because they have never been tried together for any significant length of time (particularly with a solid left winger). Grabovski would give Kessel a centreman who can keep puck possession and make plays in the offensive zone while still being competent defensively. Bozak is a poor puck possession player, which means Kessel spends more time setting up Bozak for scoring chances than vice versa.

Unfortunately, even if Bozak went elsewhere as a UFA, Carlyle still wouldn't consider putting Grabovski on Kessel's line until Grabovski can consistently win faceoffs.

I agree with everything but he is over 50% on the draw, its not even that.
 
1. Kessel/Grabo ... Kessel/Kadri ... Kadri/Grabo ... the most obvious reason is that these pairings are simply too small. Bozak is our Biggest Centre size wise. this is an organizational fault.
 
Yea Bozak finished on at least 50% of sweet dishes of Kessel. Good Hockey eye you have :shakehead




Yea...Last 2 years that is what he was doing especially when the KGM Line was lighting it up :shakehead

That line hasn't clicked in a year and a half at least.
 
Lupul Kadri Kulemin
jVR Bozak Komorov
MacA McClement Kessel
Orr Grabovski McLaren
 
If Grabovski and Kessel don't work well together, then why have the Leafs scored at nearly double the rate when they're on the ice together at even strength?

If Grabovski and Kessel don't work well together, then why have the Leafs scored 58% of the goals while they're on the ice together?

If Grabovski and Kessel don't work well together, then why is it that the Leafs outshoot their opponents by the same margin that the Chicago Blackhawks do when Grabovski and Kessel are on the ice together?

http://stats.hockeyanalysis.com/showplayer.php?pid=55&withagainst=true&season=2010-12&sit=5v5

The whole "they both like to have the puck" thing and therefore shouldn't play together is nonsense. Grabbo is a puck possession forward. He's good at getting the puck and keeping it. Phil Kessel is an elite scoring winger who has difficulties with puck possession.

Grabo getting pucks, protecting them, and then passing them to Phil sounds like a good plan to me.

Guess everyone is just going to ignore this post? Well done buddy:handclap:
 
Truth is Bozak is married to Kessel for reasons unknown. They are married even Lupul can be experimented elsewhere, you cant even put Kessel down for poor performance on Grabs line. Something funny with that its very queer behaviour on the coaches part.

What exactly are you implying?:sarcasm:
 
Lupul tends to play a cycle game and is still quite compatible with Kessel. As long as you create space for Kessel, he'll thrive. Grabovski would actually be rather effective due to his cycle game and intense playing style. In fact, JVR's performance would significantly improve as well.

Grabovski doesn't have the brains to play with elite players, he has skill, but he has absolutely no idea how to use those skills. He's back into one of his 10+ games of ice cold play after his predictable 1 or 2 good games where his fans will rejoice, Grabo is a monster. Truth is he has always been a streaky bullet in a tunnel.
 
Grabo and Kessel don't work together. The facts prove this. See SmoulderingGoodTime's post.

If you're not convinced, look at Kessel's stats with other players:

http://stats.hockeyanalysis.com/showplayer.php?pid=580&withagainst=true&season=2010-12&sit=5v5

When he plays with Bozak, they score 0.831 GF/20 and give up 1.013 GA/20.
When he played with Grabo for like 230 minutes, the Leafs were scoring 1.656 GF/20 and giving up 1.220 GA/20.

Oh, whoops, I just accidentally showed that Grabo is the player that Kessel has the most chemistry with out of any Leaf forward in the last two years! How silly of me. Let's pretend that never happened.

He actually worked pretty well with Kulemin too in limited time. Kessel is not a special flower who needs Bozak/Lupul to score. In fact, even this season, when playing with Bozak the Leafs score 0.934 GF/20 and get 0.975 GA/20. So the myth that Bozak is covering for Kessel's defensive deficiencies is exactly that - a myth. Over the last 3 seasons, Bozak and Kessel have been consistently outscored at even strength by the opposition .So what's the worst that could happen by changing his center?
 
Oh sorry, I forgot we're not supposed to use facts around here.

*cough* well I am an expert who actually watches games *adjusts glasses*, and let me tell you, that Kessel boy needs a good Canadian kid with moxy, grit, hustle and intangibles to get him going. You young kids out there, you need to understand how the game is played. No Belarusian has ever won the cup. They don't have our Canadian culture of winning in their blood! It's genetics! I watch the games and I know.
 
Grabo and Kessel don't work together. The facts prove this. See SmoulderingGoodTime's post.

If you're not convinced, look at Kessel's stats with other players:

http://stats.hockeyanalysis.com/showplayer.php?pid=580&withagainst=true&season=2010-12&sit=5v5

When he plays with Bozak, they score 0.831 GF/20 and give up 1.013 GA/20.
When he played with Grabo for like 230 minutes, the Leafs were scoring 1.656 GF/20 and giving up 1.220 GA/20.

Oh, whoops, I just accidentally showed that Grabo is the player that Kessel has the most chemistry with out of any Leaf forward in the last two years! How silly of me. Let's pretend that never happened.

He actually worked pretty well with Kulemin too in limited time. Kessel is not a special flower who needs Bozak/Lupul to score. In fact, even this season, when playing with Bozak the Leafs score 0.934 GF/20 and get 0.975 GA/20. So the myth that Bozak is covering for Kessel's defensive deficiencies is exactly that - a myth. Over the last 3 seasons, Bozak and Kessel have been consistently outscored at even strength by the opposition .So what's the worst that could happen by changing his center?

Oh sorry, I forgot we're not supposed to use facts around here.

*cough* well I am an expert who actually watches games *adjusts glasses*, and let me tell you, that Kessel boy needs a good Canadian kid with moxy, grit, hustle and intangibles to get him going. You young kids out there, you need to understand how the game is played. No Belarusian has ever won the cup. They don't have our Canadian culture of winning in their blood! It's genetics! I watch the games and I know.

Beauty posts:handclap::laugh:
 
If Grabovski and Kessel don't work well together, then why have the Leafs scored at nearly double the rate when they're on the ice together at even strength?

If Grabovski and Kessel don't work well together, then why have the Leafs scored 58% of the goals while they're on the ice together?

If Grabovski and Kessel don't work well together, then why is it that the Leafs outshoot their opponents by the same margin that the Chicago Blackhawks do when Grabovski and Kessel are on the ice together?

http://stats.hockeyanalysis.com/showplayer.php?pid=55&withagainst=true&season=2010-12&sit=5v5

The whole "they both like to have the puck" thing and therefore shouldn't play together is nonsense. Grabbo is a puck possession forward. He's good at getting the puck and keeping it. Phil Kessel is an elite scoring winger who has difficulties with puck possession.

Grabo getting pucks, protecting them, and then passing them to Phil sounds like a good plan to me.

Well done!
 
Grabo and Kessel don't work together. The facts prove this. See SmoulderingGoodTime's post.

If you're not convinced, look at Kessel's stats with other players:

http://stats.hockeyanalysis.com/showplayer.php?pid=580&withagainst=true&season=2010-12&sit=5v5

When he plays with Bozak, they score 0.831 GF/20 and give up 1.013 GA/20.
When he played with Grabo for like 230 minutes, the Leafs were scoring 1.656 GF/20 and giving up 1.220 GA/20.

Oh, whoops, I just accidentally showed that Grabo is the player that Kessel has the most chemistry with out of any Leaf forward in the last two years! How silly of me. Let's pretend that never happened.

He actually worked pretty well with Kulemin too in limited time. Kessel is not a special flower who needs Bozak/Lupul to score. In fact, even this season, when playing with Bozak the Leafs score 0.934 GF/20 and get 0.975 GA/20. So the myth that Bozak is covering for Kessel's defensive deficiencies is exactly that - a myth. Over the last 3 seasons, Bozak and Kessel have been consistently outscored at even strength by the opposition .So what's the worst that could happen by changing his center?

Oh sorry, I forgot we're not supposed to use facts around here.

*cough* well I am an expert who actually watches games *adjusts glasses*, and let me tell you, that Kessel boy needs a good Canadian kid with moxy, grit, hustle and intangibles to get him going. You young kids out there, you need to understand how the game is played. No Belarusian has ever won the cup. They don't have our Canadian culture of winning in their blood! It's genetics! I watch the games and I know.

:laugh::handclap:
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Ad

Ad