Toggle sidebar

The Martin St Louis Thread

  • Xenforo Cloud upgraded our forum to XenForo version 2.3.4. This update has created styling issues to our current templates, this is just a temporary look. We will continue to work on clearing up these issues for the next few days and restore the site to it's more familiar look, but please report any other issues you may experience so we can look into. Thanks for your patience and understanding.
Rapala said:
Exactly we are going into year three of it now and from where I sit it hasn't really worked.
But that isn't on coaching when talking about or dealing with concepts or modern hockey. :dunno:
Click to expand...
2-1-2 is pretty basic and the players should have been doing it since they were teenagers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rapala
nhlfan9191 said:
I’m not calling for St. Louis to get fired right this moment but one of the most important things I think they need to do during this rebuild is break the language barrier for head coaches. It’s going to cripple any success we have in the future. We can’t keep playing with a handicap to 31 other teams.
Click to expand...

So you're advocating for an non-French speaking coach regardless of aptitude.
Bravo.

Plenty of teams make a point of not hiring French-speaking coaches and end up playing under their roster capacity -- the Toronto Maple Leafs being a prime example.

(For the record, I was advocating for Jon Cooper in like 2012 before he even had a stint in the NHL, so don't play the "you mean close-minded French card" to me)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rapala
I wouldn't give a hoot what language the coach speaks but if you're not from the city, all I'll say is just shut up. It's not your place. And I'm not a white-Franco (albeit I am Franco and from the city).
 
13 out of the 32 coachs have a french name but only a handle consider themselfs french.

Brind'Amour - French
Montgomery - Part French
Richardson - Part French
Lalonde - French
Maurice - French
St. Louis - French
Brunette - French
Roy - French
Laviolette - French ..... Bro..
Bannister - French
Berube - French
Tourigny - French
Tocchet - French

The math isn't mathing.

I guess the people here are afraid of assimilation because they've seen it happen right in front of their eyes?

Just my 2 cents
 
MXD said:
So you're advocating for an non-French speaking coach regardless of aptitude.
Bravo.

Plenty of teams make a point of not hiring French-speaking coaches and end up playing under their roster capacity -- the Toronto Maple Leafs being a prime example.

(For the record, I was advocating for Jon Cooper in like 2012 before he even had a stint in the NHL, so don't play the "you mean close-minded French card" to me)
Click to expand...
It's such a non issue I laughed like hell the other night when some journalist was advocating for more Franco assistants.
Bruno Gervais cut him off saying it's irrelevant Hockey Business behind closed doors is always conducted in English.
I mean seriously. Nobody complains when Marc Denis does his interviews in English and then simply translates after the fact.
 
I remember how badly Randy Cunneyworth was treated when they made him interim coach, he never coached again and it was through no fault of his own.
 
Tyson said:
I remember how badly Randy Cunneyworth was treated when they made him interim coach, he never coached again and it was through no fault of his own.
Click to expand...

He was also a terrible coach, which is a much better explanation as to why he didn't get another coach gig.

Rapala said:
It's such a non issue I laughed like hell the other night when some journalist was advocating for more Franco assistants.
Bruno Gervais cut him off saying it's irrelevant Hockey Business behind closed doors is always conducted in English.
I mean seriously. Nobody complains when Marc Denis does his interviews in English and then simply translates after the fact.
Click to expand...
There was only one person advocating for a "linguistically" specific type of coach, and it's the guy who wanted the next coach to be non-French speaking.

I'm still not exactly sure what Trevor Letowski does behind the bench. Is he the lone Non-French assistant?

As far as I know, there's only 3 Queb/French speaking head coaches in the NHL as we speak : St-Louis, Roy and Tourigny. Not counting Montgomery for the purposes of the exercice (he's totally quebecois and does speak some French as far as I know) I'm not sure there's a lot of inefficiency here -- 3 makes sense, considering the space held by Quebec in North American hockey. Could be a bit higher, but it does not really have to.

It's all about market inefficiencies.
 
Last edited:
nhlfan9191 said:
I’m not calling for St. Louis to get fired right this moment but one of the most important things I think they need to do during this rebuild is break the language barrier for head coaches. It’s going to cripple any success we have in the future. We can’t keep playing with a handicap to 31 other teams.
Click to expand...
Nope. Deal with it and find a way.
 
Yoor said:
As a frenchy here...I could not agree more. We have had bad coaches as a result of this for some time now. The media will get over it...it has to happen. Been saying this for a while.
Click to expand...
It’s not so much that the coaches were consistently bad, it’s that most of them were pretty similar or on their second tenure. Rehiring coaches really shows that they are reaching.

I wouldn’t have minded bringing back Vigneault, though.

They finally have a players coach after years of grouchy guys. Now they need a technical coach, something they haven’t had since Vigneault.
 
MXD said:
So you're advocating for an non-French speaking coach regardless of aptitude.
Bravo.

Plenty of teams make a point of not hiring French-speaking coaches and end up playing under their roster capacity -- the Toronto Maple Leafs being a prime example.

(For the record, I was advocating for Jon Cooper in like 2012 before he even had a stint in the NHL, so don't play the "you mean close-minded French card" to me)
Click to expand...
That is not what I’m saying at all. If we’re in a situation where we’re talking about recycling coaches like Michel Therrien again, we should be looking elsewhere. The talent for coaches that are French is too small to be limited ourselves to only them.
 
At this point why don't we waive the veterans that clearly don't give a f anymore. If Dvorak and Anderson don't want to give 100% effort, send them to Laval. They are beyond sunk cost level. Give a shot to ABB and Roy at least they'll somewhat care.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pomee
MXD said:
So you're advocating for an non-French speaking coach regardless of aptitude.
Bravo.

Plenty of teams make a point of not hiring French-speaking coaches and end up playing under their roster capacity -- the Toronto Maple Leafs being a prime example.

(For the record, I was advocating for Jon Cooper in like 2012 before he even had a stint in the NHL, so don't play the "you mean close-minded French card" to me)
Click to expand...

Maybe I'm missing the point but are you suggesting the leafs go out of their way to make sure their coach doesn't speak French?

Whether it's the leafs or anyone else, I don't think anyone cares whether a coach happens to speak French as long as they know English. The exception is probably Pittsburgh when they hired hlinka, who I believe knew zero French and extremely limited English.

As far as the language barrier goes, I think the organization took some positive steps in hiring merit over language with the way they brought in Jeff gorton. So maybe that is an indication thay they will get creative in hiring merit over language behind the bench as well at some point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rapala
morhilane said:
I personally think it's more an effort problem than a sense one.
Click to expand...
Either way and I don't think the Hybrid System is as easy as is being made out.
It's the primary responsibility of the coaching staff to get the effort out of the players.
Those who can't or don't get fired ..
It isn't something Marty has struggled with in the past which is why it seems like something is wrong.
 
Rapala said:
Either way and I don't think the Hybrid System is as easy as is being made out.
It's the primary responsibility of the coaching staff to get the effort out of the players.
Those who can't or don't get fired ..
It isn't something Marty has struggled with in the past which is why it seems like something is wrong.
Click to expand...
We are slowly watching MSL slowly imploding. I don't wish it, I just think it's happening.
The Cumbaya era is over
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stive Morgan, Habano and nhlfan9191
Rapala said:
Either way and I don't think the Hybrid System is as easy as is being made out.
It's the primary responsibility of the coaching staff to get the effort out of the players.
Those who can't or don't get fired ..
It isn't something Marty has struggled with in the past which is why it seems like something is wrong.
Click to expand...
It's also not super complex or something that players haven't seen or played in throughout their amateur and professional careers.

But just like anything else in life if you stop doing something only to return to it a few years later it takes a bit of time to shake off the rust and get back into the groove. Honestly the biggest fault for MSL is probably that he mishandled training camp and so we are spending these first few weeks shaking working off the hesitancy/rust when ideally that would have happened at TC.
 
Tyson said:
We are slowly watching MSL slowly imploding. I don't wish it, I just think it's happening.
The Cumbaya era is over
Click to expand...
Frankly, the Cumbaya era should be over.

In yr 3/4 or the rebuild it is perfectly acceptable to raise the expectations and demand more from the GM, coach, and players.

I think some on here would be perfectly comfortable drafting top 10 for many years to come.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stive Morgan, Forum93 and Habano
Tyson said:
I remember how badly Randy Cunneyworth was treated when they made him interim coach, he never coached again and it was through no fault of his own.
Click to expand...
Because he is not made to be a headcoach in any NHL market.
 
Tyson said:
He was good in the AHL. I just didn't like how he was treated because he wasn't francophone. The idiocy of Gauthier and Molson was the cause
Click to expand...
Was doomed the second it happened. Molson had the backbone of a jelly fish. He could have ended that nonsense right then.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Habano
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

  • ... and 1 more.
    • Total: 9 (members: 6, guests: 3)

    Ad

    Latest posts

    Ad

    Upcoming events

    Ad

    Top Bottom