The Flames are the worst at player development
- Thread starter sonic92
- Start date
Jacob582
Registered User
- Oct 16, 2012
- 10,164
- 3,777
So what is it? Are the Flames the worst at player development or do you want to bring the young players up because the old guys aren't performing?
Voight
#winning
One could argue they are doing what's best for the players development. Instead of putting them in the lineup too early they let them mature first.
They are a Stanley Cup contender who will likely finish 2nd or 3rd in the conference. This is their window the time is now, they cant be playing unproven prospects when they have experienced veterans.
- Oct 23, 2014
- 29,850
- 42,276
Nothing wrong with letting your prospects play big minutes in the Ahl instead of getting them fourth line minutes and scratch duty.
Every team has situations they can complain about. Columbus is the opposite. They bring kids in and if they are high picks they let them play in the NHL for better or worse. Sillinger clearly needs development time and shouldnt be in the NHL. Bemstrom was given a spot when he came over and had shown many times AHL time would be good. Chinakhov looked lost at times last year but pretty amazingly turned into a completely different player this year but now doesnt get enough icetime like Johnson
Team_Spirit
95% Elliotte
- Jul 3, 2002
- 39,744
- 21,989
23Monahan
Registered User
- Jul 2, 2018
- 947
- 1,252
Totally agree. Why the f*** is Lucic in our top 6 when we have capable young fast players. Why are we set on never devoloping players and trading away every pick for older players? We have never had a top 3 pick and even if we did I'm sure we would f*** it up. Perpetual mediocrity is what it leads to, and if this current core doesn't figure it out it will be a very shitty 5-8 years with all out overblown contracts.
But thats what a shitty owner that only cares about selling tickets now gets you, sometimes things need to be rebuilt to be better, I really hope the guys prove me wrong but I felt with Tkchuck and Gaudreau both leaving the time was now. Treliving definitely made some decent trades and signings to salvage it, and we could trade those contracts for picks (hopefully huberdeau too if he gets going), but it's just not what the flames do.
Mickey Marner
Registered User
23Monahan
Registered User
- Jul 2, 2018
- 947
- 1,252
We have had some busts forusre. But hard to always land top players when youre picking 10 or over most years. Our highest pick in franchise histroy is sam bennet, who is currently playing as a solid top 6 center for the panthers.
But the biggest problem is how we utilize players, quite a few of our current draft picks do well in other organizations, as they seem to give them a chance over shitty 4th line grinders, while our prospects rot in the ahl or are traded away for older guys
We are the only nhl team to not graduate a prospect since 2018, 2017 was ruzicka who is a press box seat warmer, and valimaki who is currently playing his best hockey in Arizona.
The Flames are the only NHL team to not graduate a single draft pick since 2018
It's been a while since the Calgary Flames drafted a player who went o...
flamesnation.ca
SeanMoneyHands
Registered User
- Apr 18, 2019
- 15,288
- 14,667
Sutter has a lovefest for Lucic and Lewis (Toffoli too) from when played under him in LA. Zary and Pelletier showed in pre-season they aren't NHL ready. They were outplayed by the flames vets.
Doug Prishpreed
Registered User
I'd also look at the team that drafted Laffy and Kakko and question their ability to develop. On the other hand, they have Miller and Buchnevich...
Kinda hard to show you are ready when playing with ahlers.
They didn’t get a fair shake. Same with Matthew Phillips. As a side note, the flames haven’t graduated a prospect from the past 5 drafts yet… only team in the nhl with that accomplishment.
SeanMoneyHands
Registered User
- Apr 18, 2019
- 15,288
- 14,667
I do agree with you that there should be at least 2 rookies in the Flames lineup for player development. Having 4 grinders in Lucic, Ritchie, Rooney and Lewis all in the lineup at once is redundant. The rookies should be given at least 20 games to show what they can do in the regular season.
23Monahan
Registered User
- Jul 2, 2018
- 947
- 1,252
Flames vets were given everychance to suceed, even in preseason we were playing rooney in the top 9, while our AHL players played together, they never got a chance to play with the big boys, because the decision was already made by sutter.
SeanMoneyHands
Registered User
- Apr 18, 2019
- 15,288
- 14,667
Agreed. What i want to know is why do the Flames need 4 vet grinders in the lineup as full time regulars? Both Pelletier and Phillips should be in the lineup.
Figgy44
A toast of purple gato for the memories
- Dec 15, 2014
- 13,903
- 9,216
What? Really?
Calgary Flames Draft History at hockeydb.com
Oh, you're right.
Hmm... It seems the 17 draft is starting to get their legs under them. 18 the highest draft picks were 4th rounders. 19 is getting closer. Phillips is the only one I think that is languishing, but would you want a guy smaller than Gaudreau in our bottom 6 (most likely 4th line) playing a Sutter system? Probably not.
Pelletier I assume would be playing in Lucic's spot if Lucic's contract expired last season vs the end of this one, but he's got size concerns as well. With the contract structure having so many raises next season I wouldn't be surprised if we graduate 2-3 prospects next year. I think flanking Backlund with Pelletier and Phillips would be a pretty solid and decently sheltered 3rd line.
Some Other Flame
Registered User
- Dec 4, 2010
- 8,051
- 10,388
Water is wet, etc.
Super old news and something that is unlikely to change so long as that clown Edwards owns the team and keeps hiring more clowns that think like him.
Flames had a spot open in the nine entering the season. Both Pelletier and Phillips had great years in the AHL last year. Zary was the best forward prospect in camp. The team instead went with 35 year Trevor Lewis and followed up that great decision by putting Lucic in the top six for the past two games.
And then they wonder why the team lacks energy and speed.
Super old news and something that is unlikely to change so long as that clown Edwards owns the team and keeps hiring more clowns that think like him.
Flames had a spot open in the nine entering the season. Both Pelletier and Phillips had great years in the AHL last year. Zary was the best forward prospect in camp. The team instead went with 35 year Trevor Lewis and followed up that great decision by putting Lucic in the top six for the past two games.
And then they wonder why the team lacks energy and speed.
Straight Fire
Registered User
Fixed to Ruin
Come wit it now!
