Toggle sidebar

Prospect Info: The First Annual Jaster Prospect Ranking List

Winger98

Winger98

Moderator
Feb 27, 2002
23,684
6,169
Cleveland
Alright folks, here it is. We're going to do this like Jaster proposed, and just post your top 10 to 20 prospects, or message them to me if you don't want to publicly share. The list will be created with a point system weighted inversely from where they are listed, so

1=20 points
2-19 points
3=18 points
etc.

List posting will be open for a week, from today thru next Saturday (2/9 to 2/15). I might close the thread until I have the results to post. Might not. We'll wait and see how it goes and if anyone has any strong feelings about it. I figure we'll then do another prospect ranking after the draft, maybe do separate polls for that since it'll be summer and no hockey to scream about.
Click to read more...
 
Winger98 said:
Alright folks, here it is. We're going to do this like Jaster proposed, and just post your top 10 to 20 prospects, or message them to me if you don't want to publicly share. The list will be created with a point system weighted inversely from where they are listed, so

1=20 points
2-19 points
3=18 points
etc.

List posting will be open for a week, from today thru next Saturday (2/9 to 2/15). I might close the thread until I have the results to post. Might not. We'll wait and see how it goes and if anyone has any strong feelings about it. I figure we'll then do another prospect ranking after the draft, maybe do separate polls for that since it'll be summer and no hockey to scream about.
Click to expand...
Any ranking criteria to use to have some sort of common basis? For example, NHL readiness, NHL projected games played, majority of career slot projections, longevity on the wings or NHL career etc?

The cupboard is pretty well stocked, so some sifting and sorting guidelines would be helpful...or is this going to to be a free-wheeling exercise?
 
  • Like
Reactions: RRhoads
LongTimeDRWF said:
Any ranking criteria to use to have some sort of common basis? For example, NHL readiness, NHL projected games played, majority of career slot projections, longevity on the wings or NHL career etc?

The cupboard is pretty well stocked, so some sifting and sorting guidelines would be helpful...or is this going to to be a free-wheeling exercise?
Click to expand...

nope. Just personal feelings. If you want to argue for your choices in your post, go ahead, but I leave the reasoning entirely up to the people making the lists.

RRhoads said:
What is the max age, and games played in the NHL?
Click to expand...

Personally, I consider Ed, Kasper, and Soderblom as having graduated. The quickest and easiest determination might just be if someone is still eligible for rookie of the year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LongTimeDRWF and RRhoads
1. Axel Sandin Pellikka
2. Sebastian Cossa
3. Trey Augustine
4. Dmitri Buchelnikov
5. Michael Brandsegg Nygard
6. Nate Danielson
7. Jesse Kiiskinen
8. Max Plante
9. Emmitt Finnie
10. William Wallinder
11. Shai Buium
12. Carter Mazur
13. Amadeus Lombardi
14. Ondrej Becher
15. Anton Johansson
 
  • Like
Reactions: Holden Caufield
I’ll just use prospects that haven’t been regulars for the big club the last few weeks.

1)ASP
2) Cossa
3) Buchelnikov
4) MBN
5) Augustine
6) Mazur
7) Plante
8) Kiiskinen
9) Buium
10) Danielson
11)Lombardi
12) Wallinder
13)Finnie
14)Dylan James
15) NDN

Thought I would have Finnie ranked higher. But grab a life jacket… this pool is deep! Couldn’t get him past 13.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: lilidk
1. MBN
2. Karate Kid aka Danielson
3. Buchelnikov
4. ASP
5. Cossa
6. Finnie
7. Buium
8. Plante
9. Mazur
10. Cleveland (duh)
 
  • Like
Reactions: 14ari13
1. ASP
2. MBN
3. Cossa
4. Buchelnikov
5. Danielson
6. Augustine
7. Finnie
8. Mazur
9. Kiiskinen
10. Plante
11. Buium
12. Lombardi
13. Dylan James
14. Red Savage
15. Tuomisto
16. Wallinder
17. Anton Johansson
18. Ondrej Becher
19. Brady Cleveland
20. John Whipple
 
1) Nate Danielson
2) Sebastian Cossa
3) Axel Sandin-Pellikka
4) Trey Augustine
5) Michael Brandsegg-Nygard
6) Dmitri Buchelnikov
7) Carter Mazur
8) Amadeus Lombardi
9) Shai Buium
10) Max Plante
11) Emmitt Finnie
12) Jesse Kiiskinen
13) Dylan James
14) Ondrej Becher
15) Antti Tuomisto
16) William Wallinder
17) Anton Johansson
18) Brady Cleveland
19) Red Savage
20) Noah Dower-Nilsson
 
  • Like
Reactions: OgeeOgelthorpe
1. ASP
2. Cossa

3. Augustine
4. Danielson
5. MBN

6. Plante
7. Buchelnikov
8. Kiiskennen
9. Lombardi
10. Mazur
11. Buium
12. Finnie
13. AnJo
14 Becher
 
Last edited:
GoBoltz56 said:
RIP Jaster
Click to expand...
I thought he put me on his ignore list so I didn't see of his posts. He just left the board without any notice and any goodbye? Strange.

The prospects.
I don't follow the prospects at all and I barely know their names. So I have to ask if any of these who are not top 10 have any chance of making it to the NHL.
 
norrisnick said:
If I were to guess, he's self-restricting so he doesn't get himself banned. Or he got banned. One of the two.
Click to expand...

Or maybe he's just busy.

I just moved back to MI and started a new job. I haven't had time to watch games, much less post. Besides, I can't comment if I'm not watching games. Kinda sucks because they're finally playing well.

It's a lot more convenient to watch games on the West Coast, the games are 3 hours earlier. I go to sleep before 10pm now....
 
  • Like
Reactions: Winger98
Where ever Jaster is hope everything is going alright :(

1) Sebastian Cossa
2) Axel Sandin-Pellikka
3) Nate Danielson
4) Michael Brandsegg-Nygard
5) Carter Mazur
6) Trey Augustine
7) Dmitri Buchelnikov
8) Shai Buium
 
  • Like
Reactions: Holden Caufield
Yeah… not loving the title of this thread when the guy just suddenly stopped posting after 17 years of being a member
 
  • Like
Reactions: Go Wings
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom