I think you need to look at lots of factors when assessing the season, if they lose today...
How far did they go in the playoffs? Further than ever before in this era. Yes, G7 is further. Check
Where did they finish in the regular season? First Atlantic division title of the era. Check
Success in first year with a new coach and new system. Yep, the above two points are success and we have a new coach. Check
Key players under contract beyond this season. Matthews, Nylander, Knies (RFA), Laughton, Domi, Rielly, Tanev, McCabe, Carlo, OEL, Benoit, Stolarz, and Woll.
Growth from younger guys and prospects with a chance to contribute over the next year or two. That's Knies, Woll, Holmberg, Robertson, Cowan, Quillan, Hildeby, Akhtyamov, maybe even Danford and one of the kids we just signed.
Cap space. We can bring it all back. If we lose tonight...12.5 x 8 for Mitch and 5 x four or five (years) for JT. Done. We are saving $3.5M on those two (combined) and we use the cap increase (and move our Kampf and Jarnkrok) to cover Knies, Woll and McCabe increases. We still have room to add.
What would NOT running it back actually look like? We need to get better and not JUST different. Maybe we turn the $22M for our two UFAs into Bennett, Ekblad and Marchand? Are we better? Can we possibly even pull this off? Plan B might be let them walk and sign a bunch of guys for one year deals and then get McDavid. Some risk to that for sure....maybe we pull for Edmonton to win this year if we don't, to make that more likely to happen?