The thing is Campbell has allowed 4 or more goals about a billion times and all of his recent wins came against the worst teams in the league. Skinner has been lukewarm getting his feet under him in the playoffs but compared to Campbell over the year he has been Mr. Consistency.
I see a LOT of risk in starting Campbell, and yet, he has good career playoff numbers and he helped us win game 4. Some people say theres no bad decision to be made here, but I completely disagree. If Campbell comes in and lays an egg as per his usual this year, we are going to be in serious trouble- the amount of runway is running out and the Kings are playing good hockey.
Skinner is more likely to give you a solid steady effort, Campbell is a risk-reward proposition hoping he is hot right now. I dont know what to do but if you make the wrong choice it could cost you the series. We need to score 5 goals to have a chance in most Campbell starts.