The guy had zero going for him beyond some muscles. Even then, he wasn't exceptionally strong, so it wasn't all that impressive, it was nothing more than the look. Sure he'd be stronger than those of us on here, but if you're going to be the jacked up guy, then I want to be wowed with some feats of strength.
I'm not too fond of the power guys, I prefer the technical elements, but I do enjoy at times watching something and thinking wow, that is impressive as a display of power. He never did that. Cena does that, Cesaro does that, Ryback was just a block of muscles and nothing else.
Was a little amusing when he was the bully guy, but even then it wasn't some star level stuff that was going on.