The best current player, who was a high draft pick, that did NOT have a break out rookie season?

[Voight]

Nobody (*) seriously doubted a goaltender who put those numbers up in a season where he started year as an 18-year-old. There's a reason goalies don't regularly wander in and start in the NHL as a teenager.

(*) I'm sure someone seriously doubted Fleury, but not anyone relevant.

Not to mention he was playing on an awful team that was clearly tanking for Ovechkin.