Team MVPs and other team awards

overpass

Registered User
Jun 7, 2007
5,614
4,163
Ottawa, ON
Several NHL teams have given out team awards at the end of the season. Sometimes voted by writers and sometimes by players. It might be interesting to post them here.

I compiled team end of season awards from the Detroit Red Wings over Gordie Howe's career. The Windsor Daily Star (later the Windsor Star) usually published an article about the awards. In total, the following awards were given out.

Team MVP (voted by Detroit hockey writers)
Most goals (based on stats)
Most points (based on stats)
Best sportsmanship (aka the local Lady Byng)
Best rookie
Best defenceman
Three star award (for the player who had the most three star points in home games)
Unsung hero (named and awarded by the local fan club)
Players award - awarded by the players to one of their own. This one seems to have been a bit of a joke award, awarded to the "best actor under duress or injury", and it was a "handsome cup topped by a hockey player who was hoisting a large bull over his shoulder". I know they continued to award it through the end of the 60s but the papers stopped reporting the winner.

The first four awards above go back to 1945-46. The others were added at various points during the 50s and 60s. The yearly news article about the awards didn't always name the winner of the more minor awards, so these records are incomplete. The only one for which I have full records is the team MVP. I won't bother listing the leading goal and point scorer as those were based on easily available stats.

Detroit Red Wings team awards

SeasonMVPMost sportmanlikeBest rookieThree-star Selection CupBest defencemanUnsung HeroPlayers' Award
1945-46Bill QuackenbushCarl Liscombe
1946-47Ted LindsayBill Quackenbush
1947-48Sid Abel
1948-49Sid Abel
1949-50Sid AbelRed Kelly
1950-51Red KellyRed Kelly
1951-52Gordie Howe
1952-53Gordie Howe
1953-54Red Kelly
1954-55Bob GoldhamEarl ReibelTed Lindsay
1955-56Gordie HoweMarty PavelichGlenn HallMarcel PronovostAlex Delvecchio
1956-57Gordie Howe
1957-58Gordie HoweAlex DelvecchioBilly DeaAl Arbourcoach Jimmy Skinner
1958-59Gordie HoweAlex DelvecchioGordie HoweWarren GodfreyNorm Ullman
1959-60Gordie HoweGary AldcornMurray OliverGordie HoweNorm UllmanTerry Sawchuk
1960-61Gordie HoweNorm UllmanHank BassenGordie HowePete Goegan
1961-62Gordie HoweBruce MacGregorBill GadsbyVal FonteyneVic Stasiuk
1962-63Gordie HoweParker MacDonaldDoug BarkleyBill GadsbyDoug BarkleyMarcel Pronovost
1963-64Terry SawchukBruce MacGregorPit MartinMarcel PronovostAndre Pronovost
1964-65Norm UllmanAlex DelvecchioRoger CrozierRoger CrozierMarcel PronovostFloyd Smith
1965-66Gordie HoweAlex DelvecchioBert MarshallDoug Barkley
1966-67Gordie HoweTed HampsonNot awardedHenderson/Howe/UllmanGary BergmanTed Hampson
1967-68Gordie HoweAlex DelvecchioGary Jarrett/Roy EdwardsGordie HoweGary BergmanAlex Delvecchio
1968-69Gordie HoweAlex DelvecchioPoul PopielFrank MahovlichBob Baun
1969-70Roy EdwardsWayne ConnellyAl KarlanderGordie HoweCarl Brewer
1970-71Gordie HoweAlex DelvecchioTom WebsterGordie Howetrainer Lefty Wilson

Team MVPs
15 times - Gordie Howe
3 times - Sid Abel
2 times - Red Kelly
1 time - Bill Quackenbush, Ted Lindsay, Bob Goldham, Terry Sawchuk, Norm Ullman, Roy Edwards

Alex Delvecchio was a 7 time winner for best sportsmanship. Of the 9 seasons I found the winner for most 3 star selection points, Howe won 6 times and shared it once, Mahovlich and Crozier each won once, and Ullman and Henderson split it with Howe once.

Coach Jimmy Skinner won the players' award in 1957-58 for injuring his groin in a bench melee with Boston's Fern Flaman on February 17, 1958.

Any surprises?
  • Defenceman Bill Quackenbush over Harry Lumley and Jack Stewart in 1945-46 is a surprise. Lumley and Stewart were 4th and 5th in Hart voting.
  • Ted Lindsay winning MVP in 46-47 when he was 4th in team scoring, and then losing the next three to Sid Abel is also unexpected.
  • Red Kelly beat Gordie Howe in 50-51, when Howe won the Hart. Overall, only two MVPs for Howe from 50-51 through 54-55 is strange. Imagine if Connor McDavid only won two team MVPs in a five year stretch!
  • Defensive ace Bob Goldham's career year in 54-55 managed to get an MVP in a down year for Howe.
  • No surprise that Howe dominated the team MVP voting for almost two decades. Terry Sawchuk beating him out in 63-64 is a bit of a surprise, another case where local writers didn't agree with the leaguewide voting.
  • For best defenceman, Marcel Pronovost managed to win two against tough competition from the older Gadsby and the younger Barkley. And veteran Bob Baun's win in 68-69 over Gary Bergman wasn't what you would expect if you looked at the stats.
 
Last edited:
Sawchuk only once.

And that was in '64, way after the dynasty, not one of the 5 times he led the league in wins.

It was his last year in Detroit, when the team finished 4th... in a 6-team league.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, as a kid, I remember the Oilers giving out these team awards in the final home game of each season. (I remember Jari Kurri being team MVP in 1989, for example.)

I wonder where there is a list of these... you'd think each club's website would list them somewhere.
 
Yeah, as a kid, I remember the Oilers giving out these team awards in the final home game of each season. (I remember Jari Kurri being team MVP in 1989, for example.)

I wonder where there is a list of these... you'd think each club's website would list them somewhere.

2019-20 EDM_01.png
2019-20 EDM_02.png
2019-20 EDM_03.png
 
pnep delivers as usual

@The Panther as an Oilers fan, could you shine light on why the Unsung Hero-award wasn’t awarded in 2000-01. As simple as every hero ultimately having been sung, or no one really deserved another song besides the already sung heroes?
 
I sometimes wonder if @pnep isn't actually some kind of hockey-God living in another dimension... He exists to tantalize us mere mortals with his pearls of historical and statistical riches.
pnep delivers as usual

@The Panther as an Oilers fan, could you shine light on why the Unsung Hero-award wasn’t awarded in 2000-01. As simple as every hero ultimately having been sung, or no one really deserved another song besides the already sung heroes?
I do not know. (In 2000-01, I was living on a subtropical island and chasing as many girls as I could.)
 
  • Haha
Reactions: pnep
pnep delivers as usual

@The Panther as an Oilers fan, could you shine light on why the Unsung Hero-award wasn’t awarded in 2000-01. As simple as every hero ultimately having been sung, or no one really deserved another song besides the already sung heroes?
There were some major front office changes in 2000 which may or may not have had to do with it.
 
Boston Bruins team awards

Most are listed on wikipedia. I'll put a table here for easier season-by-season comparison.

Elizabeth C. Dufresne Trophy
Best performance in home games, as voted by Boston hockey writers

Gallery Gods Award
Awarded by the Gallery Gods, a longtime fan group in the second balcony, to their favourite player. More recently it has been defined as going to the player with the most hustle and determination. While it has been awarded since the mid-30s, only the winners since 2006 are listed on Wikipedia. I found some winners from older seasons in newspaper archive, but I'm still missing most winners.

Seventh Player Award
The player who performed beyond expectations. Originally established and awarded by TV broadcasters WSBK-TV, now awarded by fans.

Three Stars Award
Given to the top three players with the most three stars points in home games.

John P. Bucyk Award
For charitable and community endeavors.



SeasonElizabeth C. Dufresne Trophy Gallery Gods AwardSeventh Player AwardThree Stars Award (first)Three Stars Award (second) Three Stars Award (thirdJohn P. Bucyk Award
1935–36Tiny Thompson
1936–37Tiny Thompson
1937–38Eddie Shore
1938–39Eddie ShoreEddie Shore and Dit Clapper
1939–40Dit Clapper
1940–41Dit ClapperMilt Schmidt
1941–42Bobby Bauer, Woody Dumart, Milt Schmidt
1942–43Frank Brimsek
1943–44Bill Cowley
1944–45Jack Crawford
1945–46Jack Crawford
1946–47Milt Schmidt
1947–48Frank Brimsek
1948–49Pat Egan
1949–50Milt Schmidt
1950–51Milt Schmidt
1951–52Jim Henry
1952–53Fleming Mackell
1953–54Jim Henry
1954–55Leo Labine
1955–56Terry SawchukCal Gardner
1956–57Jerry Toppazzini
1957–58Jerry ToppazziniJerry Toppazzini
1958–59Vic Stasiuk
1959–60Bronco Horvath
1960–61Leo Boivin Don McKenney
1961–62Doug MohnsDoug Mohns
1962–63Johnny BucykTommy Williams
1963–64Eddie JohnstonEddie Johnston
1964–65Ted Green
1965–66Johnny Bucyk
1966–67Bobby Orr Bobby Orr
1967–68Phil EspositoPhil Esposito
1968–69Phil Esposito Ed Westfall
1969–70Bobby Orr John McKenzie
1970–71Phil EspositoWayne CashmanFred Stanfield
1971–72Bobby Orr Derek Sanderson
1972–73Phil EspositoGregg SheppardDallas Smith
1973–74Phil Esposito, Bobby Orr Don Marcotte, Carol VadnaisBobby OrrPhil EspositoGilles Gilbert
1974–75Bobby Orr Terry O'ReillyPhil EspositoBobby OrrGregg Sheppard
1975–76Gregg Sheppard Gregg SheppardJean RatelleGregg SheppardJohnny Bucyk
1976–77Jean RatelleGary Doak/Jean RatelleGary DoakJean RatelleBrad ParkPeter McNab
1977–78Terry O'Reilly, Brad ParkStan Jonathan/Brad ParkStan JonathanTerry O'ReillyPeter McNabBrad Park
1978–79Rick Middleton Rick MiddletonRick MiddletonPeter McNabTerry O'Reilly
1979–80Ray Bourque Ray BourqueRick MiddletonTerry O'ReillyRay Bourque
1980–81Rick Middleton Steve KasperRick MiddletonPeter McNabRay Bourque
1981–82Rick Middleton Barry PedersonRick MiddletonBarry PedersonRay Bourque
1982–83Pete PeetersPete PeetersPete PeetersRick MiddletonPete PeetersRay Bourque
1983–84Rick Middleton Mike O'ConnellRick MiddletonBarry PedersonRay Bourque
1984–85Ray Bourque Keith CrowderRay BourqueKen LinsemanKeith Crowder
1985–86Ray Bourque Randy BurridgeRay BourqueKen LinsemanKeith Crowder
1986–87Ray BourqueCam NeelyCam NeelyRay BourqueBill RanfordSteve Kasper
1987–88Cam NeelyBob SweeneyGlen WesleyCam NeelySteve KasperRay Bourque
1988–89Randy Burridge Randy BurridgeCam NeelyRay BourqueRandy Burridge
1989–90Ray Bourque John CarterCam NeelyRay BourqueAndy Moog
1990–91Cam Neely Ken Hodge, Jr.Cam NeelyRay BourqueCraig Janney
1991–92Vladimir Ruzicka Vladimir RuzickaAndy MoogRay BourqueVladimir Ruzicka
1992–93Adam Oates Don SweeneyAdam OatesJoe JuneauRay Bourque
1993–94Ray Bourque Cam NeelyCam NeelyRay BourqueAdam Oates
1994–95Cam Neely Blaine LacherCam NeelyRay BourqueBlaine Lacher
1995–96Ray Bourque Kyle McLarenAdam OatesRay BourqueBill Ranford
1996–97Jozef Stumpel Ted DonatoRay BourqueTed DonatoJozef Stumpel
1997–98Jason Allison Jason AllisonByron DafoeJason AllisonRay Bourque
1998–99Byron Dafoe Byron DafoeByron DafoeRay BourqueJason Allison
1999–00Joe Thornton Joe ThorntonJoe ThorntonKyle McLarenSergei SamsonovSteve Heinze
2000–01Jason Allison Bill GuerinJason AllisonBill GuerinJoe ThorntonDon Sweeney
2001–02Brian Rolston Bill GuerinByron DafoeBrian RolstonJoe ThorntonHal Gill
2002–03Joe Thornton Mike KnubleJoe ThorntonGlen MurrayMike KnubleNick Boynton
2003–04Andrew Raycroft Andrew RaycroftAndrew RaycroftJoe ThorntonGlen MurrayMartin Lapointe
2005–06Patrice BergeronP.J. AxelssonTim ThomasPatrice BergeronBrad BoyesTim ThomasP. J. Axelsson
2006–07Marc SavardTim ThomasTim ThomasMarc SavardTim ThomasGlen MurrayPatrice Bergeron
2007–08Marco SturmPhil KesselMilan LucicTim ThomasMarc SavardMarco SturmZdeno Chara
2008–09Marc SavardMilan LucicDavid KrejciMarc SavardZdeno CharaTim ThomasAaron Ward
2009–10Patrice BergeronMark RecchiTuukka RaskPatrice BergeronDavid KrejciTuukka RaskShawn Thornton
2010–11Tim ThomasShawn ThorntonBrad MarchandTim ThomasPatrice BergeronMilan LucicAndrew Ference
2011–12Brad MarchandZdeno CharaTyler SeguinTim ThomasPatrice BergeronMilan LucicBrad Marchand
2012–13Patrice BergeronPatrice BergeronDougie HamiltonTuukka RaskPatrice BergeronTyler SeguinGregory Campbell
2013–14David KrejciBrad MarchandReilly SmithTuukka RaskDavid KrejciPatrice BergeronTuukka Rask
2014–15Tuukka RaskMilan LucicDavid PastrnakPatrice BergeronTuukka RaskBrad MarchandDougie Hamilton
2015–16Loui ErikssonMatt BeleskeyBrad MarchandPatrice BergeronTuukka RaskDavid KrejciJimmy Hayes
2016–17Brad MarchandDavid PastrnakDavid PastrnakTuukka RaskPatrice BergeronBrad MarchandDavid Pastrnak
2017–18Brad MarchandKevan MillerCharlie McAvoyTuukka RaskBrad MarchandPatrice BergeronTim Schaller
2018–19Brad MarchandJake DeBruskChris WagnerBrad MarchandPatrice BergeronDavid PastrnakZdeno Chara
2019–20David PastrnakBrandon CarloCharlie CoyleDavid PastrnakTuukka RaskBrad MarchandPatrice Bergeron
2020–21Brad MarchandBrad MarchandNick RitchieBrad MarchandPatrice BergeronCraig SmithCharlie Coyle
2021–22David PastrnakCharlie McAvoyJeremy SwaymanDavid PastrnakBrad MarchandPatrice BergeronNick Foligno
2022–23Linus UllmarkCharlie CoylePavel ZachaDavid PastrnakLinus UllmarkBrad MarchandPatrice Bergeron
2023–24David PastrnakCharlie CoyleTrent FredericDavid PastrnakJeremy SwaymanBrad MarchandLinus Ullmark


Most frequent winners of the Elizabeth C. Dufresne Trophy (MVP in Boston home games):


Ray Bourque
Brad Marchand
Bobby Orr
Phil Esposito
Rick Middleton
Milt Schmidt
Cam Neely
Patrice Bergeron
David Pastrnak
[td width="113px"]
7​
[/td]​
[td]
5​
[/td]​
[td]
4.5​
[/td]​
[td]
4.5​
[/td]​
[td]
4​
[/td]​
[td]
3.5​
[/td]​
[td]
3​
[/td]​
[td]
3​
[/td]​
[td]
3​
[/td]​

Most frequent times among the top 3 for the Three Stars Award



Ray Bourque
Patrice Bergeron
Brad Marchand
Tuukka Rask
Cam Neely
Rick Middleton
Tim Thomas
David Pastrnak
Joe Thornton
Peter McNab
Byron Dafoe
Marc Savard
Adam Oates
Jason Allison
Terry O'Reilly
David Krejci
Glen Murray
[td width="64px"]
20​
[/td]​
[td]
13​
[/td]​
[td]
9​
[/td]​
[td]
8​
[/td]​
[td]
6​
[/td]​
[td]
6​
[/td]​
[td]
6​
[/td]​
[td]
5​
[/td]​
[td]
5​
[/td]​
[td]
4​
[/td]​
[td]
3​
[/td]​
[td]
3​
[/td]​
[td]
3​
[/td]​
[td]
3​
[/td]​
[td]
3​
[/td]​
[td]
3​
[/td]​
[td]
3​
[/td]​

Eddie Shore certainly would have won more team MVPs if they went back further.

I'm a little surprised Milt Schmidt didn't win more team MVPs, but I guess he did miss some prime years to the war and had some injury shortened seasons.

In general, three stars voting favours goalies and forwards over defencemen, even with all the great defencemen who have played for the Bruins. Cam Neely six times over prime Ray Bourque. Six straight wins for Rick Middleton over Park and Bourque.

Very little recognition for Zdeno Chara. I guess that's the nature of defensive defencemen, to be overlooked.

Phil Esposito and Bobby Orr were pretty equal when it came to team MVP recognition.

Boston league MVPs who didn't win team MVP:
Eddie Shore in 35-36 (Tiny Thompson was Bruins MVP)
Bill Cowley in 40-41 (Dit Clapper was Bruins MVP)
Bill Cowley in 42-43 (Frank Brimsek was Bruins MVP)
Bobby Orr in 70-71 (Phil Esposito was Bruins MVP)
Phil Esposito in 73-74 (he shared team honours with Orr)
 
I compiled team end of season awards from the Detroit Red Wings over Gordie Howe's career. The Windsor Daily Star (later the Windsor Star) usually published an article about the awards. In total, the following awards were given out.
Forgive me if I missed these in your OP, but I think I found some more in the March 29, 1952 Hockey News.

Two other players also came in for glory as a reward for their play with the Wings. Defenseman Bob Goldham was picked as the most sportsmanlike member of the team, and received the Citron Trophy. Selection was made by the Hockey Writers Association.

Center Glen Skov was tagged the outstanding rookie by the Detroit Sports Broadcasters Association, and received their annual plaque.
Another reward is made annually by the For ’Em Club, a fan organization, to “an unsung nonplaying member of the Detroit Hockey organization.” This year it went to Fred Hubert, the team publicist.

For a backward glance at some of the individual high spots in Detroit’s hockey history, following are the players who have received the most-valuable and most-sportsmanlike awards the past 10 seasons:

Hockey Writers Trophy (most valuable) — Jack Stewart (1943), Carl Liscombe (1944), Sid Howe (1945), Bill Quackenbush (1946), Ted Lindsay (1947), Sid Abel (1948, 1949 and 1950), Red Kelly (1951) and Gordie Howe (1952).

Citron Trophy (most sportsmanlike) — Mud Bruneteau (1943), Bill Quackenbush. (1944), Murray Armstrong (1945), Carl Liscombe (1946), Bill Quackenbush (1947), Jim McFadden (1948), Bill Quackenbush (1949), Red Kelly (1950 and 1951) and Bob Goldham (1952).
 
  • Like
Reactions: overpass
Looking at the Edmonton ones, there are some oddities (to me):

1979-80
Team MVP = Blair MacDonald
-- Like, really...?? Obviously they did this to avoid giving too much to that blond teenager, but if you're the MVP of the League you should probably be named MVP of your team....

1980-81
Top First-Year Oiler = Glenn Anderson
-- This makes no sense. Andy was great, with 30 goals in his first 58 NHL games... but he scored only 53 points (+4). Jari Kurri scored 75 points in 75 games and was +27. This should have been a total no-brainer.

1982-83
Defenceman of the Year = Charlie Huddy
I'm okay with Kevin Lowe winning this over Coffey for 1981-82 --- c.1982 was the peak of Kevin Lowe's career, and he was a great shut-down guy on a club that wasn't designed to play much defence. And I love Huddy, but... over 1983 Coffey?? Coff scored 96 points and went +52. Even though Huddy led the League with a +61, I have a hard time seeing this one.

1987-88
Defenceman of the Year = Kevin Lowe
Yeah, no. The best Oiler Dman this season was Steve Smith. Smitty had 55 points and went +40. (Lowe officially passed his prime with this season.)

1988-89
Molson Cup award (points accumulated for being one of the 3-stars of the game) = Grant Fuhr
-- I've no idea how Fuhr won this. He appeared in 59 games, so I guess that was the biggest factor. This was easily the worst season of his career between 1981-82 and 1990-91 (with the possible exception of 1982-83). He went 23-26-6 and had a -6 GSAA.

1992-93
Team MVP = Bill Ranford
-- I mean, I get that he appeared in 67 games, but with a 17-38-6 record and a -2 GSAA, how valuable can he be? The problem is, it was such a disastrous season that basically no other player deserved it either. They should have given it to the goal-judge or the zamboni driver.

1993-94
Team MVP = Bill Ranford
-- The team was a little more competitive only because they could now score a bit. The MVP should have been Doug Weight or Jason Arnott.

Most popular player = Shayne Corson
-- WTF? "Popular" with who, exactly...? Maybe one of the top-3 most disliked Oilers, ever.

2000-01
Team MVP = Tommy Salo
Salo appeared in A LOT of games and did fine, but Doug Weight had 90 points on a club where one guy (besides him) scored over 20 goals. (Besides, Salo was team MVP in 2000 and again in 2002 and 2003, so did they have to give him this one, too?)

2003-04
Team MVP = Ethan Moreau
Coaches loved Moreau, and I get it --- a great two-way guy, good on the PK. But... I dunno. Seventh in team scoring, 12 assists all season. Maybe go with the zamboni driver again.

2014-15
Team MVP = Ryan Nugent-Hopkins
I like the Nuge, but why was this not at least shared with Jordan Eberle, who led the team in scoring?
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad