Not only has that bridge been burned, the entire area around it has been leveled. I’m sure some fans would welcome him back, but I don’t think fans outside of Isles fans understand just how hated he is on the Island. The guy left in his prime after stringing the team along which resulted in the team getting nothing for him. The way he left has ruined any chance of him being seen or recognized as an Islander legend. While Butch Goring absolutely deserved to have his number 91 retired, I don’t think it’s a coincidence that that happened right after Tavares left. The team and fan base has essentially erased him from Islander memory. MAYBE if he came back and won a Cup things would be different, but it will never be the same as if he were an Islander for life. He’s pretty much ruined any kind of legacy he could’ve had, doubly so if he doesn’t win a Cup in Toronto or wherever else he goes.It's not the right time for the Isles to make a splash like that IMO but I do hope they mend the bridge at some point. Would suck never being able to bring back one of their GOATs. I feel like everyone should have been able to move on by now.
He also just got 3 goals and 0 assists in his last 11 playoff games.Ha, guy just scored 38 goals. Y'all are like 2 year 5 million a year seems fair.
Not too much to add to this. He lied through his teeth so the Isles got nothing in return for him. The team did nothing while he was here(whether thats his fault or the organization for not putting a better team on the ice, or both.) He was robotic, emotionless, and showed NO passion at all, ever. I don't think there's many Isles fans who have a warm spot in thier heart for this guy. We moved on long ago. Let him stay on Toronto.Not only has that bridge been burned, the entire area around it has been leveled. I’m sure some fans would welcome him back, but I don’t think fans outside of Isles fans understand just how hated he is on the Island. The guy left in his prime after stringing the team along which resulted in the team getting nothing for him. The way he left has ruined any chance of him being seen or recognized as an Islander legend. While Butch Goring absolutely deserved to have his number 91 retired, I don’t think it’s a coincidence that that happened right after Tavares left. The team and fan base has essentially erased him from Islander memory. MAYBE if he came back and won a Cup things would be different, but it will never be the same as if he were an Islander for life. He’s pretty much ruined any kind of legacy he could’ve had, doubly so if he doesn’t win a Cup in Toronto or wherever else he goes.
Not too much to add to this. He lied through his teeth so the Isles got nothing in return for him. The team did nothing while he was here(whether thats his fault or the organization for not putting a better team on the ice, or both.) He was robotic, emotionless, and showed NO passion at all, ever. I don't think there's many Isles fans who have a warm spot in thier heart for this guy. We moved on long ago. Let him stay on Toronto.
My personal opinion: Marner and Tavares will both sign in Carolina, as both will find that team as the best shot at a Stanley Cup. Marner will either get a 7x14 or an 8x13 (sign-and-trade) and Tavares will take a high-dollar, 1 year contract at $11-12M.
Doubt he leaves. Could see him retiring if leafs don’t want him back.IMO he can easily get more than Stammer's 4*8M from last summer. There are so many teams looking for a center so TOR fans thinking he'll re-sign for 4-5M is silly.
All these teams could use JT:
BOS
CAL
COL
FLA if Bennett leaves
LAK
MIN
StL
TB
VAN
WPG
I personally have but I can assure you that A TON of islander fans are still quite angry.It's not the right time for the Isles to make a splash like that IMO but I do hope they mend the bridge at some point. Would suck never being able to bring back one of their GOATs. I feel like everyone should have been able to move on by now.
Seven years later, who is to say he doesn't have major regrets? Thoughts can change, evolve...''I've never thought about playing anywhere else ''
Well that's the worst take I've ever seen.Doubt he leaves. Could see him retiring if leafs don’t want him back.