Player Discussion: Tampa Bay Lightning All Time Player Ranking #13

[JoVel]

1. Nikita Kucherov 87,9 %
2. Martin St. Louis 46,2 %
3. Victor Hedman 59,4 %
4. Steven Stamkos 50,0 %
5. Andrei Vasilevskiy 78,9 %
6. Vincent Lecavalier 95,5 %
7. Brayden Point 68,8 %
8. Brad Richards 64,0 %
9. Ryan McDonagh 57,1 %
10. Ondrej Palat 73,7 %
11. Ben Bishop 55,6 %
12. Nikolai Khabibulin 64,7 %

 

[RSchmitz PhD]

I think I'd go Boyle here. ~6 seasons of being one of the best offensive D in the league.

 

[DFC]

Voted Johnson, mainly for the peak years, but I'm second guessing it now and thinking maybe I should have gone with Killer for the consistency. Johnson had two really strong playoff runs too, and was arguably our best skater in the 2015 SCF run.

And he had an impact on the 2021 cup win.

 

[JoVel]

Voted Johnson, mainly for the peak years, but I'm second guessing it now and thinking maybe I should have gone with Killer for the consistency. Johnson had two really strong playoff runs too, and was arguably our best skater in the 2015 SCF run.

And he had an impact on the 2021 cup win.

I think Killorn's 2021 run is quite underappreciated too. Probably our third best forward behind just Kucherov and Point. And he had a couple of other really good playoff runs too.

But yeah, Johnson's entire 2014-15 season is quite a bit better than anything Killorn did, both regular season and playoffs. That player is probably one of my favorites all time, even if it lasted for just one season.

 

[Hoek]

I'll give the nod to Killer for consistency, and he did hit another level at the end, which is impressive.

 

[DistantThunderRep]

The sheer Killorn disrespect here is f***ing unreal.

 

[Stormbreaker]

Killer all day

 

[RussianBum86]

Modin scoring 30 goals should be a vote for him alone. Dude was dropping 40 goals in the dead era. Killer, Palat, and TJ couldn't do that with wide open offensive days.

 

[DFC]

Modin scoring 40 goals should be a vote for him alone. Dude was dropping 40 goals in the dead era. Killer, Palat, and TJ couldn't do that with wide open offensive days.

When?

 

[Todd1a]

1. Nikita Kucherov 87,9 %
2. Martin St. Louis 46,2 %
3. Victor Hedman 59,4 %
4. Steven Stamkos 50,0 %
5. Andrei Vasilevskiy 78,9 %
6. Vincent Lecavalier 95,5 %
7. Brayden Point 68,8 %
8. Brad Richards 64,0 %
9. Ryan McDonagh 57,1 %
10. Ondrej Palat 73,7 %
11. Ben Bishop 55,6 %
12. Nikolai Khabibulin 64,7 %

Got to go killer at 13

 

[RussianBum86]

When?

01 to 05. The top players were scoring 120 points compared to 140 and you got mugged a lot more every play and every shift. The current playoffs were less physical then most regular season games.

 

[Stammertime91]

31 isn't 40. At least here in reality.

 

[DFC]

View attachment 1045087
01 to 05. The top players were scoring 120 points compared to 140 and you got mugged a lot more every play and every shift. The current playoffs were less physical then most regular season games.

When did he score 40 though?

 

[Sky04]

lmao

 

[Sky04]

View attachment 1045087
01 to 05. The top players were scoring 120 points compared to 140 and you got mugged a lot more every play and every shift. The current playoffs were less physical then most regular season games.

Did you really just highlight 05-06 when Johnson scored 29 goals in a year where the leading scorer had 87 points

 

[Stammertime91]

Did you really just highlight 05-06 when Johnson scored 29 goals in a year where the leading scorer had 87 points

Did you quote the right guy?



I am so f***ing confused in this thread. I got one guy saying Modin scored 40 when he hit 31 and then you're putting (Tyler?) Johnson in 2005-2006 when Johnson was 15 years old lmao

 

[JoVel]

Did you quote the right guy?



I am so f***ing confused in this thread. I got one guy saying Modin scored 40 when he hit 31 and then you're putting (Tyler?) Johnson in 2005-2006 when Johnson was 15 years old lmao

I think what Sky means here is "did you highlights Modin's 2005-06 season, when Johnson scored 29 in 2014-15 (Jamie Benn's 87 point Art Ross season)".

 

[Stammertime91]

I think what Sky means here is "did you highlights Modin's 2005-06 season, when Johnson scored 29 in 2014-15 (Jamie Benn's 87 point Art Ross season)".

Thank you for the grade A narration Morgan Freeman. However would I manage this thing called life without you feeding my brain the proper wiring from europe.

 

[JoVel]

Thank you for the grade A narration Morgan Freeman. However would I manage this thing called life without you feeding my brain the proper wiring from europe.

I'm afraid it's not going to look great on your CV that you had a non native speaker explain to you how your language works.