Movies: Sully

Osprey

Registered User
Feb 18, 2005
27,909
10,774
Eastwood's political stances ring a little transparent in this one. He paints the government investigators as villains trying to bring down a heroic pilot, when in reality they were just doing their job. If they didn't conduct an investigation, they would have been negligent in their duties.
It is sad that his right wing political leanings are increasingly permeating his movies. I still liked it Hanks was solid as usual as was Aaron Eckhart.

If his personal leanings are being reflected in his films, then it's rather tame by Hollywood standards. Hollywood is well known for worse. Perhaps we're just so accustomed to certain villains and messages that we suspect an agenda only when they're different than what we usually get. Perhaps we're just assuming that Eastwood interjects his personal views into his professional work because that's what we've come to expect out of Hollywood.

In my opinion, Eastwood doesn't come anywhere close to using his films to promote personal views like others in Hollywood do. For example, James Cameron's films absolutely drip with his personal views, and he's the lone writer on most of his films. Eastwood, in contrast, doesn't have a single writing credit in his entire career. That doesn't mean that he's had no say in narrative direction, but his films haven't been his stories nearly as much as some might think. I see him as a throwback to the old Hollywood directors who would take a good story (written by someone else) and try to shoot the best film from it as efficiently as possible, before directing became about more than that.
 
Last edited:

chicagoskycam

Land of #1 Overall Picks
Nov 19, 2009
25,582
1,834
Fulton Market, Chicago
chicagoskycam.com
I understand it happens all the time, but keep in mind if not for Sullenberger, Eastwood would've used the names of real people to screw over just so he could have a better story. Sorry, but that creativity while saying "based on a true story" is just kind of a put off.

Also

[spoil]
Yes, they did question them the day after. The NTSB usually tries to do it sooner than later, that way events are not forgotten. Sullenberger himself was a safety rep and had been involved with other investigations and incidents himself and probably knew what was coming. Questions about drinking and stress at home are not unusual and if the pilot doesn't make it, they interview family and friends. The most difficult question Sullenberger was probably asked was why he didn't tell the passengers they were going into the water (lack of time, he didn't want them fooling around with life jackets instead in brace position).

Could 1549 have made it back to the airport? Not really. In simulations done, the test pilots were sometimes able to make it back, but that was knowing what was going to happen and turning back immediately. When added human factors and real world situation and the 30 seconds that it took 1549, they were not as successful. Also, no one had to tell them this, the NTSB did these on their own. In fact I don't think Sullenberger knew of the findings of these tests until the NTSB revealed them to him.

About 5 days after the incident Robert Benzone, one of the NTSB people, spoke with the media and complimented Sullenberger and Skiles talking about how impressed he was with how calm they were. In fact during the recorder playback with the pilots (which didn't happen for another 4 months and was only in a room full of people), Sullenberger notes the NTSB basically wanted to get the thoughts of the pilots on everything.[/spoil]

Meh, I think Eastwood has done a great job post acting career. Some minor gripes but nothing major. They really did make the NTSB investigators out to be some jerks, Anna Gunn plays one of them.

The other good part of the film is him dealing with instant celebrity.
 

Voight

#winning
Feb 8, 2012
42,094
18,638
Mulberry Street
I like how they didn't try and make the entire movie about just the crash landing and instead included the investigation and all that.

Hopefully will see it this week or next weekend.
 

hocky

Registered User
Apr 8, 2011
635
0
Surprised how well received this one is. Thought it was over the top cheesy. The actual crash and rescue scene was well done though.
 

Dr Pepper

Registered User
Dec 9, 2005
71,391
17,059
Sunny Etobicoke
Surprised how well received this one is. Thought it was over the top cheesy. The actual crash and rescue scene was well done though.

It was, it really showed the coordinated effort involved in getting everyone to safety.

Yes, everyone....including that one woman who just jumped into the water and started bobbing away from the group, for some reason. :laugh:
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad