Meh, cool name plate ala Flyers and interesting (but not unique) helmet design. I dislike textual baseball style logos like these but the jersey design overall is good and close enough to what they already have so I like that. It's a meh for me but a positive meh, I'm ok with these. Would like it more if they just had the main logo instead. Oh yeah, and the octopus eyes tag is cute. Love that.
The Columbus one is a bit better imo just for the logo. That's a sick main logo rendition of the cannon. Not sure about the bright triangular angles on the arms though.
They both should look pretty good on the ice against one another.