Interviews - A+. Much documented but they are great at opening guys up and getting premium quality from them.
Hockey analasys - B. They make a comical amount of mistakes, yes. Some takes and insights are interesting, if you don't take them too seriously and remember their bias. When the guys share their own perspectives as previous players or from hockey people they know, they add some good context here and there.
Other talk- C-. Last episode (Johnny Hockey interview) I skipped ahead literally until like the 35:00 mark before they talked about anything worth my time. Some of their pop culture talk is interesting (they convinced me to watch Tiger King), but the vast majority is not all that interesting. And for the love of hockey, I am sick of hearing about their social media and promotions and events and things like that! mention it quickly at the end of the episode, don't spend the first half hour of a podcast talking about freaking Chicklets Cup.