- Aug 13, 2018
- 326
- 953
We don't really discuss this much but mark my words, this is going to be a HUGE PROBLEM with the over-all health of the game....a good piece by Topher Scott....
We don't really discuss this much but mark my words, this is going to be a HUGE PROBLEM with the over-all health of the game....a good piece by Topher Scott....
So I think a lot of it boils down to "life isn't fair".
Admission to elite universities heavily favours the rich and powerful. You can do the right extra-curriculars, go to the right prep schools (which cost money). Even if you do get admitted, the tuition for Harvard is (holy shit!) $76k US. Not total - per year. (does include room and board). Even if my kid could get admitted I could never afford to send him.
And the biggest expense - travel! Now this is going to depend on ability and how popular hockey is in your area. But to go back to the article @Corso posted a bunch of U9s don't need to travel and be spending night in hotels to find quality opponents. Or if you do need to travel you can travel closer to home. I'm okay with the "out of town tournament experience" - it's always a highlight of the year. But you're paying for the experience - not hockey development.
Finally - does this mean that the hockey world is missing out on the next Gordie Howe - some farm kid who was a freak of nature? Maybe yes. But then what are you going to do about it? From a Hockey Canada perspective there probably are some tinkering they could do to develop top-end talent (I'm curious about a Canadian National Development Team) but it certainly isn't worthwhile to start offering free or subsidized power skating to tens of thousands of kids across Canada.
Ignore the costs for a second, how do parents give so much of their time away by having their kids in travel leagues? I made a travel baseball team when I was a sophomore in high school or so. When I saw the schedule it was an instant no from me. I really liked baseball, naturally good at it, had fun playing it, but I'm not traveling to Ohio from Illinois every other week to go play some random travel team that's apparently really good too. My cousin was in a travel soccer league, EVERY WEEKEND going all over the state, sometimes all over the country, for some dumb games. His parents would go with him everywhere too of course. It sounds like hell on earth.
Spoken like a true rookie parent. Youth sports has changed. I am probably older than you (48) and it is definitely different than I was a kid. When my daughter, now 11, started playing in the Rangers Learn to Play, I said I would put off travel until she was at least 13. What I didnt realize was unlike when I was a kid, "House League", at least around here was a pretty much a beginner program and after a year would be a waste of time. While I do not travel all over the country, we do travel all around a small state land wise (NJ) for games and clinics. Why? Because she loves playing, she loves working with her goalie coach and as a parent it is my job to help her pursue her passions. I am under no illusion that she is going to get a D1 scholarship or play professionally. If I am not going to spend my money and time on my kids, then what am I going to spend it on? It is not all about chasing a dream of going pro or even college for free.Ignore the costs for a second, how do parents give so much of their time away by having their kids in travel leagues? I made a travel baseball team when I was a sophomore in high school or so. When I saw the schedule it was an instant no from me. I really liked baseball, naturally good at it, had fun playing it, but I'm not traveling to Ohio from Illinois every other week to go play some random travel team that's apparently really good too. My cousin was in a travel soccer league, EVERY WEEKEND going all over the state, sometimes all over the country, for some dumb games. His parents would go with him everywhere too of course. It sounds like hell on earth.
We just had our first child, I CAN'T WAIT until he is old enough to start playing sports. If it's apparent that's something he likes I'm going to put him in local park leagues and then have him play for his local high school team. Maybe he'll get a scholarship or something. No way am I traveling all around the country so my 13 year old can go play baseball. Life is short, I don't know why people are so willing to do that. Humbly, I think 99% of these parents are totally chumping out. Wasting way too much of their money and their time. The odds of becoming a pro athlete are slim to none and even if your kid is clearly gifted in hockey (or whatever sport) the odds of him making it are basically non-existent.
To each their own but I think it's all one big silly ruse.
Yup. Last weekend (MLK weekend) my daughter's entire organization went to a tourney in another state We stayed in the same hotel. We took over the lounge in the lobby. One parent even hooked up his laptop to the hotel tv so we could watch the Rangers game on one tv and the Bills-Ravens game on the other. Rented a few conference rooms so the kids can all hang out. Ordered food and made it a party. Yes, we cleaned up after ourselves so the staff wasnt left to do it. One father even asked for a vacuum, but I guess they werent allowed to lend it out. We took all the pizza boxes out to the dumpsters ourselves, as well. My kid's team was able to play 4 very competitive games against teams we have never played. Went 2-2 won two 1-goal games, lost a 1-goal game and lost in a shootout. Parents had a great time just hanging out with each other and having a few drinks.So I'll let you in on a hockey parent secret: out of town games are fun for the parents.
So this is only my experience as a hockey parent in Canada. Maybe travel baseball in the US is different.
When you go to an out-of-town hockey tournament though, you get away from work. You stay at a hotel. Maybe you get away from your spouse, or maybe it's a chance to get out of town with your spouse. You're eating out at restaurants (and ordering drinks). You go back to the hotel. Kids are splashing around in the pool, or running amuck in the halls - while the parents drink.
It's a big parents party.
Now none of this has to do with player development. Your kid is not going to get better because you travel to play. You can almost certainly find quality opposition locally. You're spending money that isn't going to improve your kids game.
But it is fun for parents, and no where near hell on earth (if you can afford it). Which is why I like having one out-of-town tournament per year just for the experience of it, but otherwise think it's a waste of money.
It is starting over here. Barcelona has/had an academy in Arizona. My friends kid went to it because he was starting HS during covid and wasnt going to be able to play where we were. There are private academies for hockey. Not aware of any association with NHL teams though. But, European soccer does not have a draft. So not sure it would be wise for the NHL teams to start something like this.I'm going to have to take a look more into the European development model to see what can fit over here. I do know that European soccer clubs sponsor their own sport academies that cover the full cost to play and travel. In time, due to the emerging demographic crisis (in all hockey playing nations), this is something that the NHL may have to strongly consider.
It is starting over here. Barcelona has/had an academy in Arizona. My friends kid went to it because he was starting HS during covid and wasnt going to be able to play where we were. There are private academies for hockey. Not aware of any association with NHL teams though. But, European soccer does not have a draft. So not sure it would be wise for the NHL teams to start something like this.
They do. Each US team sponsors a "Learn to Play". Includes head to toe equipment to start. It is how most kids around here get started.Those hockey "academies" are terribly expensive and yes, I understand that there is no draft in the various European soccer leagues, but I think the NHL needs to do a lot more at the grass roots level in order to help with costs.
Since I've commented in a number of these threads, I'll add something I haven't written in a previous one. The huge disadvantage hockey has with cost is the surface/venue it's played. Grass fields or wooden courts are nowhere near as expensive to maintain as a rink that is only used for one sport.
My comparison...my older son is a swimmer. Same concept/issue. We have to pay $380/month plus a separate cost for meets (priced by event, typically another $60-80 a month). A lot is based on the maintenance of the pool.
I feel like the cost of ice is not that big a concern.
Just looking at City of Edmonton - most expensive ice (so winter, 4-11pm) is $335/hr. For comparison the better quality baseball diamond will run $50/hr.
But break it down per kid, that's roughly $10/kid for two teams (game or shared practice) and $20/kid for one team (single team practice). That's obviously not nothing, but hardly insurmountable.
If you're just playing community hockey, so volunteer coaches, lets say two hours per week (one game and one practice) that's what - $120 for one month.
Where hockey rapidly gets expensive is once you start throwing in travel, plus paid coaches, probably a demand for a bunch of swag, tournaments...
Just as one example since it's fresh in my mind. My kid just signed up for a spring hockey team. This is a for-profit team, not run by a local club. The cost for a 3 month season is $1600. That's 20 hours of practice, 3 tournaments, exhibition games, team apparel (jersey, socks, pants shell, workout gear), paid coach, 8 hours skill development. I bet you the cost of ice itself inly only 1/4 to 1/3 of the total price. I believe one of those tournaments is out of town so factor in cost of a hotel and travel on top.
Like I said, the schedule for my travel league would've had me going as far as Ohio from Illinois and everywhere in-between. That's too much. In Illinois we had a park league for 10-12 year olds, there was "Minors" and "Majors". The best kids all went to the "Majors" and we had a ton of fun. It had to have been something like 2 games a week and two practices a week. I think we at most had to drive 30 minutes away traffic pending. The same deal in the "Pony" league for 13-15 year olds. There was Pony A, AA, AAA. The kids who REALLY LOVED baseball would find a way to supplement high school ball with usually AAA. l was content enough with high school baseball and didn't want to travel that much so a travel league was out of the question. It's too much of a time commitment. I wanted to play baseball, see my friends, my family, play videogames, go see movies, etc...have a life.Spoken like a true rookie parent. Youth sports has changed. I am probably older than you (48) and it is definitely different than I was a kid. When my daughter, now 11, started playing in the Rangers Learn to Play, I said I would put off travel until she was at least 13. What I didnt realize was unlike when I was a kid, "House League", at least around here was a pretty much a beginner program and after a year would be a waste of time. While I do not travel all over the country, we do travel all around a small state land wise (NJ) for games and clinics. Why? Because she loves playing, she loves working with her goalie coach and as a parent it is my job to help her pursue her passions. I am under no illusion that she is going to get a D1 scholarship or play professionally. If I am not going to spend my money and time on my kids, then what am I going to spend it on? It is not all about chasing a dream of going pro or even college for free.
I also think you may have a different understanding of what is meant by "travel sports". For most teams, travel simply means you are driving to another rink to play a game and other teams will come to your home rink. Yes, there are some elite teams in this area that travel greater distances, but that is because their kids are so much better that if they played with a non-elite travel they would simply dominate every game. Yes, I have seen those players. Or, teams that are so much better than every other more local team that they win every game 15-0 (or worse) and outshoot their opponents 75-3. No, I am not exaggerating. Before I had kids I umpired travel baseball and there were some teams that played local games just for practice and beat every team by the mercy rule.
My younger one has no interest in playing hockey as "It is too cold...." but did say she wants to start skating again and maybe try figure skating. I explained the rink is just as cold, and she seems ok with it. Starting her up again in the spring as she has other stuff going on through mid-match.
By you referring to your cousin's schedule as "...some dumb games.." tells me you simply did not love baseball as much as your cousin loves soccer. Which is fine. When I was 16 I received a call from a coach in our town asking if I wanted to play on his Babe Ruth team. Would be "travel" all around Nassau County. Wasn't interested. My local Little League had Senior division that went up to 15, and at 16 I aged out and was done with baseball. A bunch of my friends joined because they just wanted to play. I said, "thank you, but no thank you" as I was more focused on lifting for football and track.
Wow...that sounds super cheap for ice maintenance and expense (utilities).I feel like the cost of ice is not that big a concern.
Just looking at City of Edmonton - most expensive ice (so winter, 4-11pm) is $335/hr. For comparison the better quality baseball diamond will run $50/hr.
But break it down per kid, that's roughly $10/kid for two teams (game or shared practice) and $20/kid for one team (single team practice). That's obviously not nothing, but hardly insurmountable.
If you're just playing community hockey, so volunteer coaches, lets say two hours per week (one game and one practice) that's what - $120 for one month.
Where hockey rapidly gets expensive is once you start throwing in travel, plus paid coaches, probably a demand for a bunch of swag, tournaments...
Just as one example since it's fresh in my mind. My kid just signed up for a spring hockey team. This is a for-profit team, not run by a local club. The cost for a 3 month season is $1600. That's 20 hours of practice, 3 tournaments, exhibition games, team apparel (jersey, socks, pants shell, workout gear), paid coach, 8 hours skill development. I bet you the cost of ice itself inly only 1/4 to 1/3 of the total price. I believe one of those tournaments is out of town so factor in cost of a hotel and travel on top.
And, I read an article about the soccer academies. Basically, the downside of them if the kids do not make it to the pro teams. Education is not a high priority. If I can find it, I will post it. Feel like it was in the Athletic.
Ignore the costs for a second, how do parents give so much of their time away by having their kids in travel leagues? I made a travel baseball team when I was a sophomore in high school or so. When I saw the schedule it was an instant no from me. I really liked baseball, naturally good at it, had fun playing it, but I'm not traveling to Ohio from Illinois every other week to go play some random travel team that's apparently really good too. My cousin was in a travel soccer league, EVERY WEEKEND going all over the state, sometimes all over the country, for some dumb games. His parents would go with him everywhere too of course. It sounds like hell on earth.
We just had our first child, I CAN'T WAIT until he is old enough to start playing sports. If it's apparent that's something he likes I'm going to put him in local park leagues and then have him play for his local high school team. Maybe he'll get a scholarship or something. No way am I traveling all around the country so my 13 year old can go play baseball. Life is short, I don't know why people are so willing to do that. Humbly, I think 99% of these parents are totally chumping out. Wasting way too much of their money and their time. The odds of becoming a pro athlete are slim to none and even if your kid is clearly gifted in hockey (or whatever sport) the odds of him making it are basically non-existent.
To each their own but I think it's all one big silly ruse.
Since I've commented in a number of these threads, I'll add something I haven't written in a previous one. The huge disadvantage hockey has with cost is the surface/venue it's played. Grass fields or wooden courts are nowhere near as expensive to maintain as a rink that is only used for one sport.
My comparison...my older son is a swimmer. Same concept/issue. We have to pay $380/month plus a separate cost for meets (priced by event, typically another $60-80 a month). A lot is based on the maintenance of the pool.
Different sport, but a buddy of mine had a daughter that was a borderline elite gymnast. Her mom had been one, too, not NCAA-level but it was obvious where the daughter got the talent from.So I'll let you in on a hockey parent secret: out of town games are fun for the parents.
But it is fun for parents, and no where near hell on earth (if you can afford it). Which is why I like having one out-of-town tournament per year just for the experience of it, but otherwise think it's a waste of money.