InjuredChoker
Registered User
i agree, that seems like a plan.
if abdelkader asks for the moon on his next contract, i'd look to move him, smith and pick and/or prospect for dman. it won't get elite dman but it will get a good one.
Smith, 5pts, -5 in last 38 games
- Thread starter SoupGuru
- Start date
i agree, that seems like a plan.
if abdelkader asks for the moon on his next contract, i'd look to move him, smith and pick and/or prospect for dman. it won't get elite dman but it will get a good one.
Wouldn't Kindl be #8? Behind Marchy and XO? Unless we just let Smith go and don't sign anyone to replace him.
I like your scenario though. Trade Smith in a package for someone or let him go and sign one of the upcoming UFAs. Bring up XO/Marchy full time and let them rotate in with E/Q/whoever is struggling or injured. Kindl stashed in GR or miraculously shipped out. I would feel so much better about our defense if this happened.
Henkka
Registered User
Marchenko and Ouellet are still waiver free and swap 6th D duties 50/50.
Kronner - RD
DeKeyser - Q
Ericsson - Ouellet/Marchenko
Kindl
After next season, Quincey is let walk and both Ouellet and Marchenko will become regulars.
Ricelund
̶W̶e̶ ̶l̶i̶k̶e̶ ̶o̶u̶r̶ ̶t̶e̶a̶m̶
I doubt Abdelkader will ask for the moon. I think he'll be a Wing for life.
I'm absolutely fine with that. I had no clue on their waiver status. I miss Capgeek. Looks loads better already with a RD, E off the top pairing, and Kindl/Lashoff out of the top6.
So with the new addition of Zidlicky, does smiths role on this team change at all?
I really like Marchenko, and would hate to see him sent down. But once Quincey comes back, is it built into Holland & Babcocks DNA to send Marchenko back to GR instead of dumping Kindl because of xp?
What if Smith plays a forward/D hybrid role, and we dress 7 defenseman a game?
Assuming everyone is healthy:
F
Tatar - Dats - Helm
Abbs - Z - Gus
Weiss - Sheahan - Cole
Smith - LG - Miller
hs: Andersson , Cleary
D
Kronner - Zidlicky
KQ - DDK
Ericcson - Marchenko
hs: Kindl
PP1
Z - Dats - Nyquist - Tatar
Kronner
PP2
Weiss - Sheahan - Abbs/Cole
KFQ - Zidlicky
PK1
Lg - Miller
KQ - DDK
PK2
Helm - Smith
Kronner - Ericcson/Zidlicky
Or would that be silly? I think Smith could be great in that role. Would be more of a grinder than Jurco and he could be great in a gritty forward/pker look.
I really like Marchenko, and would hate to see him sent down. But once Quincey comes back, is it built into Holland & Babcocks DNA to send Marchenko back to GR instead of dumping Kindl because of xp?
What if Smith plays a forward/D hybrid role, and we dress 7 defenseman a game?
Assuming everyone is healthy:
F
Tatar - Dats - Helm
Abbs - Z - Gus
Weiss - Sheahan - Cole
Smith - LG - Miller
hs: Andersson , Cleary
D
Kronner - Zidlicky
KQ - DDK
Ericcson - Marchenko
hs: Kindl
PP1
Z - Dats - Nyquist - Tatar
Kronner
PP2
Weiss - Sheahan - Abbs/Cole
KFQ - Zidlicky
PK1
Lg - Miller
KQ - DDK
PK2
Helm - Smith
Kronner - Ericcson/Zidlicky
Or would that be silly? I think Smith could be great in that role. Would be more of a grinder than Jurco and he could be great in a gritty forward/pker look.
Found this funny and telling at the same time. Players were asked who would be the wings emergency goalie
http://blogs.windsorstar.com/sports/who-would-be-wings-emergency-goalie
http://blogs.windsorstar.com/sports/who-would-be-wings-emergency-goalie
Since the thread got bumped, I thought I'd update the stats and continue the stretch of games. 5pts, -5 in those 38 games.
I'd love to hear the tone of voice Babcock used when saying we should focus on getting out of the zone first. Was it sarcastic or was he trying to make a point?
I'd love to hear the tone of voice Babcock used when saying we should focus on getting out of the zone first. Was it sarcastic or was he trying to make a point?
Pavels Dog
Registered User
Babcock doesn't go easy on Smith. Would not be surprised at all to see Smith in the pressbox for Game 1 of the playoffs.
would rather see him in the pressbox now. get marchy or oullette some more nhl experience if we're really gonna play them in the playoffs
Can someone tell me what are they waiting for with this so called kid who just turned 26 and hasn't shown nothing. Shouldn't they just trade him before he totally Kindlizes himself.
They should but he isn't a player in which he's the main piece in a trade, he's a piece that is added to the deal. It's going to be interesting to see what happens to him
You want to trade him because he is bad, but you expect other teams to want him? Professional scouts see the same things that Wings fans do.
Kronwalled55
Detroit vs. Everybody
Toronto wanted him as a piece in a Phaneuf trade.
Where exactly is your proof of that? Twitter speculation? Perhaps Holland wanted to move Smith and Toronto wanted nothing to do with him. See, we can both play the speculation game.
Yeah I agree.
Well I'm not saying he's so bad he has no value basically. But sure it's possible that it's already decreased to a level that it's better to just keep him than trade him.
Toronto wanted him as a piece in a Phaneuf trade.
They also wanted Mantha/Larkin.
Smith may have been nothing more than a warm body in that trade. He certainly wasn't a main "piece."
Laser Rayzor
Cautiously Optimistic
We have at least 9 NHL level D (maybe more with Jensen) in the organization and 7 of them are under contract for next season. Marchy and XO both have proved they belong in the show so obviously Kindl is the easy choice to get rid of but if the Wings really can't give him away what are the chances Smitty is the odd man out next season?
Frk It
Mo Seider Less Problems
- Jul 27, 2010
- 36,865
- 15,742
No worries, we're going to trade him for Phaneuf at the draft
Seriously though, I think they will re-visit that potential trade this summer.
Cyborg Yzerberg
Registered User
KasperTheGrittyGhost
Registered User
Watched the game from my company's suite last night, I thought he had one of his best games of the year. He was the only defenseman with a pulse it seemed, and his skating through the neutral zone was solid. In the third period Ericsson got benched, and Smith was pushed up with Kronwall and Dekeyser at times.
After reading through the gdt, I think lots of you are biased on him. Lots of hate going his way, I don't think he deserves all of it.
After reading through the gdt, I think lots of you are biased on him. Lots of hate going his way, I don't think he deserves all of it.
Smith did have a pretty good game last night. Still think we should go with a Kronwall-Smith pairing for a while, just to see how it goes. Ericsson has been awful.
