Rumor: Sharks looking to trade up to #1

[impaaaaaact]

It’s Pagnotta so… you know. In fact, it’s a page reporting a pagnotta quote. So double skepticism, but it’s the offseason and I’m bored.

Sharks fans what is Grier offering up to go from Misa to Schaefer?

 

[Fatass]

It’s Pagnotta so… you know. In fact, it’s a page reporting a pagnotta quote. So double skepticism, but it’s the offseason and I’m bored.

Sharks fans what is Grier offering up to go from Misa to Schaefer?

Of course they are. Schaefer profiles (if he teaches his ceiling) as the next Potvin. I can’t see Darche trading that pick though, unless he’s a complete idiot.,

 

[BeranekAndNeck]

I don’t think Sharks have the expendable assets tbh. Isles could use a superstar D to kickstart their rebuild and nothing San Jose could realistically offer makes it worth passing that up.

 

[Juxtaposer]

Haven’t we discussed this enough already?

 

[n8]

It’s Pagnotta so… you know. In fact, it’s a page reporting a pagnotta quote. So double skepticism, but it’s the offseason and I’m bored.

Sharks fans what is Grier offering up to go from Misa to Schaefer?

It depends how desperate Grier is. I feel like the Islanders need a forward more than they need defensemen. Pending some sort of serious injury, if their blueline can stay healthy, it's not a bad collection of players. It seems like Romanov, Pelech, and Pulock were injured all season.

There's a chance the Islanders just skip on Schaefer. It's probably only a 20% but that's much higher than the chance the Islanders had to win the lottery.

Sharks probably shouldn't offer more than their 1st and 2nd. Maybe throw in the rights to some unsigned or minor prospect. If I'm the Islanders, I don't take any deal unless I know for certain that they aren't selecting Schaefer and they are able to just use this for some excellent asset management.

 

[Stuzchuk]

if they'd offer #2 & Dickinson, I'd sure listen

 

[themelkman]

if they'd offer #2 & Dickinson, I'd sure listen

Thats the kind of deal that sets back the sharks rebuild a good bit. Would be horrible value

 

[DudeWhereIsMakar]

I think the Islanders will take Hagens. It makes too much sense as he wants to be with the Islanders and grew up in Long Island.

 

[Juxtaposer]

if they'd offer #2 & Dickinson, I'd sure listen

Mute point because Dickinson is worth #3 in this draft all on his own.

It’s funny how Isles fans have convinced themselves that Schaefer being the consensus #1 overall means that he’s head and shoulders above Misa. That’s simply not the case.

Fantasize about getting Dickinson, Eklund, our 2026 1st, whatever you want. It’s not happening.

 

[Thrasymachus]

 

[Thrasymachus]

Thats the kind of deal that sets back the sharks rebuild a good bit. Would be horrible value

Well you see that is the thing, it depends on your perspective.

As an isles fan that sounds like great value

 

[AlwaysSunnyInTampa]

The Sharks can get (almost) anyone they want for 2nd overall pick. Listen at least. Do it for a kings ransom

 

[Martin Skoula]

Wouldn’t be a bad idea for the Isles so they can finally get something approaching a 1C

 

[Stuzchuk]

Mute point because Dickinson is worth #3 in this draft all on his own.

It’s funny how Isles fans have convinced themselves that Schaefer being the consensus #1 overall means that he’s head and shoulders above Misa. That’s simply not the case.

Fantasize about getting Dickinson, Eklund, our 2026 1st, whatever you want. It’s not happening.

Just a head's up, I'm not a Isles fans and regarding your post, it's not only Isles fans but the entirety on the industry that places Schaefer at number 1. There's a significant gap at 1-2 & a even bigger gap between 2-3. There's a clear concensus no.1 for 2025

 

[Thrasymachus]

Wouldn’t be a bad idea for the Isles so they can finally get something approaching a 1C

but then we miss out on the chance to finally get someone approaching a 1D

 

[DJN21]

Mute point because Dickinson is worth #3 in this draft all on his own.

It’s funny how Isles fans have convinced themselves that Schaefer being the consensus #1 overall means that he’s head and shoulders above Misa. That’s simply not the case.

Fantasize about getting Dickinson, Eklund, our 2026 1st, whatever you want. It’s not happening.

he's not.

 

[frightenedinmatenum2]

Islanders and Sharks swap picks.

The condition is that the Islanders get the higher of the two picks next year. No protection.

If the Islanders pick ends up higher than San Jose's, they get nothing. The value is in the additional unprotected shot at #1 next year.

 

[hohosaregood]

 

[Juxtaposer]

Just a head's up, I'm not an Isles fans and regarding your post, it's not only Isles fans but the entirety on the industry that places Schaefer at number 1. There's a significant gap at 1-2 & an even bigger gap between 2-3. There's a clear concensus no.1 for 2025

Who says there’s a significant gap between one and two? Again, Schaefer being consensus #1 is true hut it doesn’t mean there’s a significant gap between him and Misa. The Athletic did a round table with a bunch of prospect writers and they agreed that Schaefer was #1 but that Misa was in the same tier and that the the gap was Misa and the rest of the field.

he's not.

He is. But I am wildly curious who you from the 2025 draft you would take over him.

Islanders and Sharks swap picks.

The condition is that the Islanders get the higher of the two picks next year. No protection.

If the Islanders pick ends up higher than San Jose's, they get nothing. The value is in the additional unprotected shot at #1 next year.

Again, this is absolutely f***ing horrible for the Sharks. They aren’t giving up #2 and another top-5 pick for Schaefer and a mid 1st.

 

[Fatass]

And still the Islanders say no. Schaefer is Potvin. Insane to trade that away and say good bye to a dynasty,

 

[Gregor Samsa]

Thats the kind of deal that sets back the sharks rebuild a good bit. Would be horrible value

This. Better to have two blue chip prospects than one slightly better blue chip prospect

 

[hohosaregood]

And still the Islanders say no. Schaefer is Potvin. Insane to trade that away and say good bye to a dynasty,

Islanders got a long way to go before they have anything resembling a dynasty build

 

[Thrasymachus]

And still the Islanders say no. Schaefer is Potvin. Insane to trade that away and say good bye to a dynasty,

Lets pump the breaks a little

 

[AcerComputer]

If I'm SJ I offer a late 1st, maybe something else small. Otherwise I'd stand pat a 2nd OA and take Misa.

 

[A1LeafNation]

Islanders would be stupid to pass in Schaefer.