Shane Pinto vs Matthew Knies

[Golden_Jet]

Well I guess we'll see this playoff who is better

One playoff doesn’t determine that lol, good grief.
Not too mention it’s being said before playoffs start.

Start a poll today then Knies or Brady.

 

[NyQuil]

You've been pretty dramatic lately.

Nice to know you're keeping track!

This brings up another point. Senators players are compared head to head against Toronto players in the poll section a lot

Not once has a Toronto player won any of those polls.

I mean, hfboards would rather have Stutzle than Matthews and tkachuk than marner

I’m sure they’d also rather Suzuki to Tavares and Hudson to knies

How does Toronto have a better team, in your opinion, if every player comparison poll on hfboards picks the sens player?

Post in thread 'Is Brady Tkachuk currently overrated?'

Oct 23, 2024

You understand that Brady Tkachuk was 24 y/o last season?

22 y/o : 0.85 PPG (30 goals)
23 y/o : 1.01 PPG (35 goals)
24 y/o : 0.91 PPG (37 goals)

Yes his 19, 20 and 21 y/o seasons were more "modest". Marner broke out at 21 but his 19 and 20 y/o seasons were more modest too

Stop being ridiculous, you might fool a couple of dummies with this kind of crap but you look more ridiculous than anything.

You’re making my point for me. 19 and 20 ‘modest’ for tkachuk is 40-ish points

But for Marner it’s 60-ish?

If 60 is modest 40 is shit, wouldn’t you agree?

We can agree to...

• Strangle

 

[Rob Brown]

In the Sens series thread on the mains we have 2 or 3 leafs posters saying they take Knies over Brady Tkachuk.

Cool, there was a whole thread about Stutzle vs. Matthews with many more than 2 or 3 voting for Stutzle.

Brady is obviously better than Knies, I think the point was to illustrate that Knies is closer to him than he is to Pinto. Stylistically he's more similar to Tkachuk than Pinto so the whole thread is sort of silly. Not a big deal.

 

[spiny norman]

Lopsided result.