Serious Debate - Goaltending

[AhosDatsyukian]

The borg has done a wayyyyyyyyy wayyyyyyyyyy better job that can not be put into words patchworking the goaltending than RF ever did.

I think the hope was in the 6 seasons of patchwork we would have found an elite goalie somewhere in the draft.

It's not looking like we have an elite goalie in the system right now, but I do trust them to find someone to plug the hole if need be.

There's no reason to give up on Koochie being our longer term answer as a 1a or even clear #1. He's still really young for a goalie and has stretches of absolute elite dominance. Long stretches at that too. Question is can he develop longer term consistency as that's where he's missing right now. And can he bring his lows up a bit higher than they are now.

Not counting on that 100% and we should constantly be evaluating options at the position but I feel pretty decent about our young goalie pipeline (incl. kooch).

The issue this year really was relying on a guy like Freddie who we've known for a while now just cannot be relied upon.

 

[Chrispy]

If it’s not crazy long term I’m not as worried about Martin as all that. Last year he came in and played fine for a stretch when we were in a similar predicament. If it it becomes weeks at a time though we will need to figure something out

If they can get one of Andersen or Kochetkov back by the 25th, that would be great. I think Martin can survive Ottawa, STL, at PHI, at NJ, at CBJ (although they need a second goalie for one of those last 3; 3 in 4 nights is too much.)

But after that is Dallas, NYR, and a H&H with Florida. Need one of the top 2 goalies for that stretch.

 

[Anton Dubinchuk]

He's a below average starting goaltender. It is what it is. If any team can handle that it's us. It'd be great if he were better.

 

[Oogie Boogie]

Freddie is burnt toast.

 

[Borsig]

We should have ejected on freddie. We KNEW his "not ready freddy" act would f*** us. Here we are.

Honestly PK isn't much better with the injuries either, but at least he comes back in a reasonable time

 

[baconandbread]

Cue the music...

 

[Svechhammer]

There's no reason to give up on Koochie being our longer term answer as a 1a or even clear #1. He's still really young for a goalie and has stretches of absolute elite dominance. Long stretches at that too. Question is can he develop longer term consistency as that's where he's missing right now. And can he bring his lows up a bit higher than they are now.

Not counting on that 100% and we should constantly be evaluating options at the position but I feel pretty decent about our young goalie pipeline (incl. kooch).

The issue this year really was relying on a guy like Freddie who we've known for a while now just cannot be relied upon.

IMHO, Kooch is absolutely the kind of goalie who can get scorching hot for a playoff run and you can win a Cup because of him. He can have a game where he lets in a couple bad goals, but he also doesn't let one bad game turn into 2 or 3.

 

[User13452]

So Andersen is pretty much toast who knows when he’s back and he can’t be relied upon at all. Time to start checking out the trade market for a goalie

 

[Blueline Bomber]

We should have ejected on freddie. We KNEW his "not ready freddy" act would f*** us. Here we are.

Honestly PK isn't much better with the injuries either, but at least he comes back in a reasonable time

I mean, at least with this recent injury, it was Walker falling skate first into his leg. No goalie is going to feel right after that happens.

 

[chaz4hockey]

IMHO, Kooch is absolutely the kind of goalie who can get scorching hot for a playoff run and you can win a Cup because of him. He can have a game where he lets in a couple bad goals, but he also doesn't let one bad game turn into 2 or 3.

Re: PK--he does seem to lose focus in a game in which he gives up a bad goal. Hopefully, over time via maturity and development he will just shake it off (ie, Game 6 Rangers goalie gave up a couple of bad ones bur then stonewalled the Canes that helped lead to the win).

 

[chaz4hockey]

PK maybe back sooner:

https://x.com/i/web/status/1857472456451104987

 

[Svechhammer]

Kooch is just fine, but we're going to still call up Perets anyway?

hmmmm

 

[cptjeff]

Kooch is just fine, but we're going to still call up Perets anyway?

hmmmm

Ready in a few days doesn't mean ready now. If nothing else, we need a backup for tomorrow.

 

[Boom Boom Apathy]

Got it. I thought it was about all of Canes Gt including PK.

It is, but it was the comparison between Andersen and PK that was what I was going for. Without Andersen playing, it kind of moot to some extent. When I get more free time, which won't be until after Thanksgiving, I'll try to update.