Seravalli: - Seravalli links Demko to Philly and Tocchet | Page 4 | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League

Seravalli: Seravalli links Demko to Philly and Tocchet

A team would definitely gamble on Silovs. He had a good NHL playoff run the season before and very good AHL playoff run. Like all young goaltenders, there's questions whether he's good enough to be a NHL goalie, but the potential is there.
He has a big weakness...not being able to track long range shots and he got beat many times in NHL this season due to long shots from close to Blueline. Lots of games where he gave up 6 goals. Again if any team picks him up on waiver, they would need to be ok with him having bad games as a backup.
 
I don't think it's an isolated case of a bad luck injury. Demko has a long list of injuries and this latest one is something never seen in the NHL before. That said there's not much sense in trading him. Either he bounces back and provides Vancouver with outstanding goaltending or he continues to battle injuries until his contract ends. I don't see any rival gms looking to take a huge risk on him unless they can aquire him for next to nothing
True, his trade value is low due to the uncertainty of his health. Which wouldn't make sense for Canucks to sell him when his value is at rock bottom. Better keep him and hope he has a healthy year. If he does have a healthy year and does play 60 games, am sure lots of teams will be punching the air for not getting him while his value was at the lowest.
 
True, his trade value is low due to the uncertainty of his health. Which wouldn't make sense for Canucks to sell him when his value is at rock bottom. Better keep him and hope he has a healthy year. If he does have a healthy year and does play 60 games, am sure lots of teams will be punching the air for not getting him while his value was at the lowest.
Absolutely, but there's the catch 22. I don't think the Canucks would trade him for what his current trade value is. So a gm may make a low offer hoping to take advantage, but I doubt the Canucks bite. On the flip side i don't think any gm is going to offer much of value due to the uncertainty. Of the games he did dress for this season he was only really good in maybe half of them
 
A team would definitely gamble on Silovs. He had a good NHL playoff run the season before and very good AHL playoff run. Like all young goaltenders, there's questions whether he's good enough to be a NHL goalie, but the potential is there.
There's a slim chance Silov's gets claimed on waivers. Every team already has a goalie duo and/or a prospect in their system they would be calling up instead of him.

The only teams that have a remote possibility are:
Anaheim Ducks (if they trade Gibson and don't get a goalie back)
Buffalo Sabres (Maybe if Levi needs 1 more year in the A, but do you want to risk him getting upset)
Calgary (Maybe but doubt it, probably want an experienced backup)
Florida Panthers (doubt it as they are contenders and need a reliable backup for Bob)
Los Angeles Kings (would have to carry 3G so doubt it as they have Portillo)
Nashville Predators (actual chance)
Ottawa Senators (doubt it as they would have to carry 3G or lose Sogaard)
San Jose Sharks (Maybe but doubt it, probably not running a Askarov/Silovs tandem)
Seattle Krakken (doubt it as they would have to carry 3G or have Grub take a spot from Ostman/Kokko)
Tampa Bay Lightning (doubt it given they paid Johannsson 1.25M and are also contending)

So only 1 legitimate option as of today to make a claim but even then, if they are going to run it back, thye aren't going to wait around for October to roll around to see if they get Silovs on waivers. They are signing a better goalie in the summer.
 
There's a slim chance Silov's gets claimed on waivers. Every team already has a goalie duo and/or a prospect in their system they would be calling up instead of him.

The only teams that have a remote possibility are:
Anaheim Ducks (if they trade Gibson and don't get a goalie back)
Buffalo Sabres (Maybe if Levi needs 1 more year in the A, but do you want to risk him getting upset)
Calgary (Maybe but doubt it, probably want an experienced backup)
Florida Panthers (doubt it as they are contenders and need a reliable backup for Bob)
Los Angeles Kings (would have to carry 3G so doubt it as they have Portillo)
Nashville Predators (actual chance)
Ottawa Senators (doubt it as they would have to carry 3G or lose Sogaard)
San Jose Sharks (Maybe but doubt it, probably not running a Askarov/Silovs tandem)
Seattle Krakken (doubt it as they would have to carry 3G or have Grub take a spot from Ostman/Kokko)
Tampa Bay Lightning (doubt it given they paid Johannsson 1.25M and are also contending)

So only 1 legitimate option as of today to make a claim but even then, if they are going to run it back, thye aren't going to wait around for October to roll around to see if they get Silovs on waivers. They are signing a better goalie in the summer.
You're ignoring goalies being injured at the start of the season. Every year there's a few starter/backups that are on IR, so that instantly opens up a few more options.

You don't think a team like Tampa would gamble on Silovs over Johansson? JoJo is a perennial backup with a sub .900 SV%, they can easily waive him and nobody will claim. For Seattle, there's a good chance Grubuaer gets bought out. In Florida, Bob is 36 and his contract is up soon.

It still hinges on how high a team is on Silovs, but if Tampa/Florida/Seattle/etc. see potential in him, they'll be claiming him and giving him a cup of coffee.
 
Absolutely, but there's the catch 22. I don't think the Canucks would trade him for what his current trade value is. So a gm may make a low offer hoping to take advantage, but I doubt the Canucks bite. On the flip side i don't think any gm is going to offer much of value due to the uncertainty. Of the games he did dress for this season he was only really good in maybe half of them
He played good on stretches but since he was constantly injured, you can't really judge him on those games since he never got into a rhythm
 
Canucks would get a 3rd, maybe a 2nd for Demko until he has shown he is healed from last years injury. That doesn't move the needle in terms of getting a C. Certainly not at the risk of dealing a goalie like Demko.
the Florida pick is basically a second rounder and the risk profile on Demko is less
Than one the on a lste
First rind pick. Of working out, which statistically is the likely outcomes.
 
I don't even know if he's stirring the pot. The whole thing is just him trying to put two and two together. Nowhere does he even suggest that the Nucks are actually trying to move him. Just that maybe they might.

Frank ponders out loud a lot, which is basically the only thing people do on podcasts. When he does that he's just sort of throwing shit out there—not necessarily reporting a rumor he's heard—but it gets filtered through two or three stages of fan interpretation and suddenly it becomes A REAL RUMOR and people get pissed off at Frank when nothing happens.

That's literally what's happening in this thread. The headline says he "links" Demko to Philly, but the post itself immediately notes that he was just "wondering." Very different things, but people only read the big (and incorrect) text.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Qwijibo
Frank ponders out loud a lot, which is basically the only thing people do on podcasts. When he does that he's just sort of throwing shit out there—not necessarily reporting a rumor he's heard—but it gets filtered through two or three stages of fan interpretation and suddenly it becomes A REAL RUMOR and people get pissed off at Frank when nothing happens.

That's literally what's happening in this thread. The headline says he "links" Demko to Philly, but the post itself immediately notes that he was just "wondering." Very different things, but people only read the big (and incorrect) text.
Freidman does the same, but people like to assume because they are insiders that whatever they are wondering or thinking must have something more to it
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rich Nixon
Why the hell would Demko be "very loyal to Tocchet"?

Tocchet wasn't a long term coach. He wasn't the coach that made him a starter. Very strange turn of phrase.

I can see Philly being interested. I can even see Demko maybe wanting a fresh start. But the loyal to Tocchet thing is weird and reeks of "former coach is now coaching over here" line drawing.

Then again this is Frankie who is only marginally more successful with his rumors than Eklund.

And really, Demko has very little value right now. Everyone knows that when healthy he is a fantastic goaltender. They also know that there is no guarantee he is going to play more than a couple dozen games.

Doesn't make sense for the canucks to move him and instead makes more sense to see if he can regain form. Not just for their season but for his trade value. Only way I see them moving him is if a GM offers up something close to what a healthy Demko is worth or if they really need the cap space.

I also don't think Silvos enters into the discussion. He's had a great playoff. But he was not good this year as a whole. He will have to earn a job and not be given it.
Players develop, especially goalies, they always develop late.

Everybody knew he has amazing athleticism, the biggest problem with him is tracking shots from the outside, if he can improve on that, he can easily be a goalie in the NHL.

And from what we have seen in the AHL, he’s been absolutely unbelievable
 
The Canucks only have two options:

Extend him and gamble
Trade him this offseason

The wait and the approach makes no sense, because let’s say hypothetically he has a great season, now he’s going to cost significantly more.

And losing him for nothing makes no sense either
 
The Canucks only have two options:

Extend him and gamble
Trade him this offseason

The wait and the approach makes no sense, because let’s say hypothetically he has a great season, now he’s going to cost significantly more.

And losing him for nothing makes no sense either
They have the 3rd option of running a 3 goalie rotation. It's not ideal but with Demkos injury issues it's also not out of the question
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

Ad

Ad