Sanderson vs Seider vs Power vs Dobson

[Mrb1p]

Youre right, its not… but its the point as to why your opinion is, and is to be, summarily dismissed.

Explain what Sanderson has done to he considered in the same breath as a multiple 49+ points D who just had a 70 points season while being good defensively and only two years older?

 

[The Devilish Buffoon]

Explain what Sanderson has done to he considered in the same breath as a multiple 49+ points D who just had a 70 points season while being good defensively and only two years older?

Lmao youve already moved the goalposts on your original statement. Example 2 as to why Id caution anyone who tries to engage you in serious conversation

Habs don’t have any defence, as good as Sanderson.

Hutson
Dobson
Guhle
Reinbacher
Seider
Mailloux
Xhekaj
Power
Barron
Harris
Zub
Struble
Sanderson

Duh

 

[Mrb1p]

Lmao youve already moved the goalposts on your original statement. Example 2 as to why Id caution anyone who tries to engage you in serious conversation

Hutson
Dobson
Guhle
Reinbacher
Seider
Mailloux
Xhekaj
Power
Barron
Harris
Zub
Struble
Sanderson

Duh

Instead of flaming away why don't you try to argue your point?

I can't understand how you could argue Sanderson over Seider or Dobson, it's complete homerism. Even I who thinks Guhle is as good as Sanderson wouldn't attempt such a thing. They are just flat out better and a lot more proven than Sanderson. The little runway left on all three players doesn't change much.

I can see an argument for Power and I do think Sanderson has been better thus far, but it requires us to ignore the immense potential that Power has, probably one of the highest potential in all of the league. I know Owen is already showing more offensively even despite being incredibly raw.

What's your argument? I'm curious.

How do we excuse Sandersons 5v5 production even though he got semi-favourable deployment?

 

[Golden_Jet]

Yes they do but thats not the point of the thread?

Who?
not seeing it

 

[Mrb1p]

Who?
not seeing it

Not going to derail the thread.

 

[The Devilish Buffoon]

Instead of flaming away why don't you try to argue your point?

I can't understand how you could argue Sanderson over Seider or Dobson, it's complete homerism. Even I who thinks Guhle is as good as Sanderson wouldn't attempt such a thing. They are just flat out better and a lot more proven than Sanderson. The little runway left on all three players doesn't change much.

I can see an argument for Power and I do think Sanderson has been better thus far, but it requires us to ignore the immense potential that Power has, probably one of the highest potential in all of the league. I know Owen is already showing more offensively even despite being incredibly raw.

What's your argument? I'm curious.

How do we excuse Sandersons 5v5 production even though he got semi-favourable deployment?

You initially said Sanderson doesnt belong in the conversation and are now saying he is currently better than Powers.

Why would I argue any point with you? You dont even say what you believe or believe what yoy say?

Had you said that Dobson and Seider are in a tier of their own (i.e. what you believe and what you are arguing in this post), you would have gotten a very different reaction.

Good day to you

 

[Aladyyn]

Instead of flaming away why don't you try to argue your point?

I can't understand how you could argue Sanderson over Seider or Dobson, it's complete homerism. Even I who thinks Guhle is as good as Sanderson wouldn't attempt such a thing. They are just flat out better and a lot more proven than Sanderson. The little runway left on all three players doesn't change much.

I can see an argument for Power and I do think Sanderson has been better thus far, but it requires us to ignore the immense potential that Power has, probably one of the highest potential in all of the league. I know Owen is already showing more offensively even despite being incredibly raw.

What's your argument? I'm curious.

How do we excuse Sandersons 5v5 production even though he got semi-favourable deployment?

Individual production is so far down on the list of things to judge defensemen on...

 

[Mrb1p]

You initially said Sanderson doesnt belong in the conversation and are now saying he is currently better than Powers.

Why would I argue any point with you? You dont even say what you believe or believe what yoy say?

Had you said that Dobson and Seider are in a tier of their own (i.e. what you believe and what you are arguing in this post), you would have gotten a very different reaction.

Good day to you

Did you even read the question in the poll?