Ryan Reaves violent hit on Darnell Nurse. 5 min major + ejected (phone hearing scheduled)

[WillTheThrill]

When somebody does that to one of your comrades, you must defend your fallen soldier. Oilers didn’t want anything to do with that, shows what kind of team they are!

 

[Golden_Jet]

Clean hit, Nurse had his head down and exposed himself, worst of it came when his head was cut by his visor and head hitting the ice. Reavo is a tank.

Clean hit,

 

[Rants Mulliniks]

Let's for the sake of argument run with that statement.
Reaves sees Nurse, see that oh Nurse got his head down and thinks to himself...*but its okay, I'm coming shoulder height, he will get up to normal position...oh no he isn't...well let's ram him in the head...booyah! I got no responsibility for my actions as long as I can claim I thought he would raise himself up and committed to the hit already*

Fantastic argument for a "clean hit"!

Now process all of those thoughts in the milliseconds it takes for the event to happen.

 

[I am Canadian]

Reaves was clearly trying to blow him up and expected Nurse to not be staring at his feet for that long. He was excpecting Nurse to look up and protect himself, but obviously that didn't happen.

The responsibility is on Reaves to pull up as it's clear Nurse was bending and not looking at him, but let's not pretend that this was some head hunting event. 4-5 games is fair as the hit was directly to the head.

 

[SirKillalot]

Now process all of those thoughts in the milliseconds it takes for the event to happen.

I'm sorry but this didn't take milliseconds, Reaves even though not the greatest of players have been in the NHL for 15 years and is used to the speed of the game. More so than any of the fans.

 

[Peasy]

6 or more is in game hearing. So probably 5,

Yes I know that. My point is, if they had 5 in their mind to begin with, they would have likely just made it an in person hearing to increase it to 6+ if some new information changed their original thought. People have gotten in person hearings and only 5 games before.

 

[stats1]

Let's for the sake of argument run with that statement.
Reaves sees Nurse, see that oh Nurse got his head down and thinks to himself...*but its okay, I'm coming shoulder height, he will get up to normal position...oh no he isn't...well let's ram him in the head...booyah! I got no responsibility for my actions as long as I can claim I thought he would raise himself up and committed to the hit already*

Fantastic argument for a "clean hit"!

Reaves is just a plug. I’m not going to defend him but let’s not act like he went out of his to kill the guy. Everything is from Nurse not being aware of his surroundings. What’s the old saying “keep your head up” like I said if Nurse is looking up Reaves hits him in the chest. Reaves should also be more aware and recognize a vulnerable player

Imo Reeves takes responsibility here. Hes a very awkward player who has little to no skill. A player with body awareness and skill would make shoulder to shoulder contact. Nurse still might hit his head on the ice, considering the force of impact and he didn’t have his helmet cinched properly, but the initial contact would not have been to the head.

Both were in the wrong but the hit is so much worse caused by Nurse’s own idiocy.

 

[SirKillalot]

Reaves is just a plug. I’m not going to defend him but let’s not act like he went out of his to kill the guy. Everything is from Nurse not being aware of his surroundings. What’s the old saying “kept your head up” like I said if Nurse is looking up Reaves hits him in the chest. Reaves should also be more aware and recognize a vulnerable player

Yes Reaves is by far the sharpest tool in the shed. Of course Nurse should have kept his head up. But, players are responsible for being in a position to make a legit legal hit, not just the recipient. If he was such, he would have hit him in the chest and not the head. Then its up to Reaves to either not make the hit or adjust himself if possible to make the hit in a legal matter.

 

[Golden_Jet]

Clean hit, Nurse had his head down and exposed himself, worst of it came when his head was cut by his visor and head hitting the ice. Reavo is a tank.

So you’ll call that a clean hit, when Matthew’s take a shot in the head like that.

Suspension should be, Reaves has to play 30 minutes a night for 6 games.

 

[Sugi21]

Bad hit in todays rules so yes suspension worthy but where’s the communication by Nurse’s teammates? A simple “heads up” could have helped him out

 

[Fatass]

So you’ll call that a clean hit, when Matthew’s take a shot in the head like that.

Suspension should be, Reaves has to play 30 minutes a night for 6 games.

Would we see Matthews take a hit like that though? It’s highly unlikely Matthews puts himself into that position. He would see Reeves because he’d have his head up and read the play.

 

[Fogelhund]

On one hand it was a hockey play in the sense that Reaves was pursuing the puck on the forecheck even making an attempt on it before following through with the hit.

On the other he carelessly following through on a hit of an opponent in a vulnerable position and it was a clear headshot that could have ended up really bad.

Getting tossed from the game should take a game out of the suspension but Reaves has been suspended a few times already.

My guess is 3-4 games

Technically, Reaves suspension history number is zero. They clear out your history after 18 months. Dumb rule if you ask me, but it is the reality. 3-4 games now seems likely as well, given it isn't in person.

 

[The Crypto Guy]

Headshot. Probably accidental since he hasnt really been a dirty player for awhile but still a bad headshot. Why is nurse also skating like that with his head down?

Easy suspension.

 

[Byron Bitz]

When somebody does that to one of your comrades, you must defend your fallen soldier. Oilers didn’t want anything to do with that, shows what kind of team they are!

Agreed, cowardly of them to not fight Reaves after the hit.

 

[DropIt]

f***ing plug who's awful at hockey, maybe the worst player in the league, trying to get his spotlight for the season. Dirty af but I'm sure his pal in DoPs will give him just a game.

Why would Nurse get a game?

 

[Face Of Bear]

Reaves had Nurse lined up and Nurse put himself in a vulnerable position. Obviously you cant make that much head contact in todays nhl and get away with it (5 min major appropriate) but I dont think the hit was 'dirty' on Reaves part.

 

[Romang67]

Technically, Reaves suspension history number is zero. They clear out your history after 18 months. Dumb rule if you ask me, but it is the reality. 3-4 games now seems likely as well, given it isn't in person.

That's not how suspension history works. It only affects the salary forfeit.

What is a "Repeat Offender"?

A Player is considered a repeat offender for 18 months following his most recent incident that resulted in a suspension. His status as a repeat offender in this category is used to determine the amount of salary forfeited should he receive another suspension.

It is important to note that even if a Player is not defined as a repeat offender, his past history may come into consideration when determining future Supplemental Discipline.

 

[Golden_Jet]

How so? Toronto is the biggest and best hockey market in the world. World class city as well.

Because playing Reaves hurts leafs more, than a suspension. A suspension is better outcome for the leafs.

 

[Buzzguy]

Not as bad as the Jeannot hit. It’ll be 2-3 games.

 

[habdynasty]

5 games

 

[sampollock]

How so? Toronto is the biggest and best hockey market in the world. World class city as well.

How so? Toronto is the biggest and best hockey market in the world. World class city as well.

and has never won anything. best how?

5 games

10
he is guy that should not be playing anymore. out date goon

 

[Armourboy]

I honestly don't see what is really wrong with this kinda hit... Its unfortunate outcome, and there is definitely head contact, but Nurse is just looking down goin around the net and leaning forward. What is Reaves suppose to do if he wants to lay the body there? Just pull up and not because Nurse is skating around the net with his head down? Fast pace game, will always be situations like his that walk a fine line that can turn it to go either way.

He'll get suspended though for sure.

Poor edmonton down to just 2 NHL defence men now.

Actually hitting his body would be a good start?

 

[All Mod Cons]

As an aside, for fans of other teams, does your broadcast crew always push the suspension angle when one of your guys does something dodgy? Do they kind of make excuses (think Jack Edwards) or do they spend most of the intermission talking about what the supplemental discipline should be?

Same question for your play-by-play announcers.

 

[All Mod Cons]

I think he gets the max: 5 games

Absolutely. 3 games to match the Jeannot incident and then add the Leafs tax on.

Be nice to see Reevo and Parros go at it in the office.

 

[Fatass]

Reaves had Nurse lined up and Nurse put himself in a vulnerable position. Obviously you cant make that much head contact in todays nhl and get away with it (5 min major appropriate) but I dont think the hit was 'dirty' on Reaves part.

Agreed. Reeves is an awkward player. His very limited skill cause him to be dangerous. Really players of his limited skill don’t have purpose in the league anymore.