Proposal: Ryan Pulock or Noah Dobson for your Top 6 Winger or Center

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
3 casts offs — Perunovich, Deangelo, Boqvist — are playing well for the Islanders. The sample size is like 5-6 games and way too small to be talking about trading far more reliable and trusted players like Dobson or Pulock. Isles fans need to calm down. Aint none of Perunovich, Deangelo, Boqvist the next coming of Dennis Potvin. Dobson on the other hand is still young, and in spite of some up-and-down play, there is no way he should be traded from LI right now.
Dobson is at best a “B” unit PPQB and is often gets outworked/outmuscled in his own zone. For what he’s going to cost based on his inflated numbers from last season, his size/handedness, and draft position, they are better off spending that cap space on scoring. Just look at their GF/GA, their problem is not defense, it’s scoring.
 
I wish there was some way to make a Boeser + Lekkerimaki/Hoglander + Picks/Prospect+ for Pulock and Barzal type deal work. But i'd imagine that's probably a non-starter for the Isles. Especially if they don't think they could get Boeser extended. It'd solve a lot of problems for Vancouver and give the Isles a chance at a pretty big reset of their own.
Barzal would be a non starter even if Boeser was extended with that package. That would also be a 3 steps forward and 6 steps back type of move for the Isles.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Glorydays22
Pulock has a NTC
How has he been playing this year?
(I know he is injured right now)
Mid. Steady and boring

I wish there was some way to make a Boeser + Lekkerimaki/Hoglander + Picks/Prospect+ for Pulock and Barzal type deal work. But i'd imagine that's probably a non-starter for the Isles. Especially if they don't think they could get Boeser extended. It'd solve a lot of problems for Vancouver and give the Isles a chance at a pretty big reset of their own.
Yep, non starter here

Why would Montreal accept that? It’s no slight on Dobson but be realistic
A fan of the MTL canadiens offered this. I don’t look a gift horse in the mouth
 
A sizable one. Don’t mind Knies as a main piece but we need to bridge the gap between minute crunching 70 point RHD and young winger on pace for 60 points playing on a line with Auston Matthews and Mitch Marner.
Interesting.

So something like Knies + Danford + another prospect + 1st '27 for Dobson + something decent.
 
Why would Islanders move Dobson?

Tale any 3 roster players you want outside of Bedard
Because he likely wants 7-8 million a year and it makes more sense for the isles to allocate that money into the top 6. With Palmieri likely leaving in FA, Barzal out long term and the power play at the bottom of the league the team needs another solid forward up front.
 
Why would Islanders move Dobson?

To upgrade the forwards. Which means either would would need a top end forward back in a deal or say we can make a big move in UFA season(very unlikely) we might need his cap space to open room on the roster and then we could trade him for picks/prospects(although in this case we still might try find other options to free up caproom, but if you could find a young player on a ELC who potentially could play above that contract it might make sense)

I know it's jumping the gun a bit but the theory is we probably can sign D'Angelo at half the price and get a close to or equal amount of offense.
 
Pulock has a NTC
How has he been playing this year?
(I know he is injured right now)
He’s been solid and i can’t really explain why Isles fans have wanted to dump him for this long. I guess the worst thing you can say about him is that he has a lethal shot but can’t really use it as well as we’d like but hes a solid defenseman, think his game will age well. Easy second pair guy who won’t be overwhelmed if he has to play first pair.

Has a full NTC, just married and bought a house, so I strongly doubt he’ll waive. NTC becomes limited in 2027.
 
Trying to imagine what a Vancouver offer even looks like. Gotta think Petterson is unavailable at this point… maybe something like a signed Boeser + Raty + a first?


Byfield
We have little need for a Dman with recent additions and the prospects coming. What we need is a playmaking winger
 
Barzal would be a non starter even if Boeser was extended with that package. That would also be a 3 steps forward and 6 steps back type of move for the Isles.

Lets have another Generation Lindros like trade ...

Canucks send E. Petey + Boeser + Carson Soucy + to Islanders

Canucks send
Lekkerimaki + first to Maple Leafs

Islanders send
Noah Dobson + Anders Lee pick to Maple Leafs

Maple Leafs send
Mitch Marner to Canucks

Islanders send
Brock Nelson (extended) and a first to Canucks

Maple Leads send
their first and Ryan Reaves to the Isles

Now why?

Isles can put Barzal to the wing and also have brock boeser and still have 2 1b centers, Scouy is a cheapp Dobson replacement.

Maple leafs replace a super star scoring machine with a playoff winning gritty power winger, defense is greatly improved ad enough futures that the sting of losing marner to the fans in not that bad (really great return)

Canucks get a replacement for pettersson, not a super star but a bo horvat light like guy, but receive probably the best player in the deal overall marner.
 
Lets have another Generation Lindros like trade ...

Canucks send E. Petey + Boeser + Carson Soucy + to Islanders

Canucks send
Lekkerimaki + first to Maple Leafs

Islanders send
Noah Dobson + Anders Lee pick to Maple Leafs

Maple Leafs send
Mitch Marner to Canucks

Islanders send
Brock Nelson (extended) and a first to Canucks

Maple Leads send
their first and Ryan Reaves to the Isles

Now why?

Isles can put Barzal to the wing and also have brock boeser and still have 2 1b centers, Scouy is a cheapp Dobson replacement.

Maple leafs replace a super star scoring machine with a playoff winning gritty power winger, defense is greatly improved ad enough futures that the sting of losing marner to the fans in not that bad (really great return)

Canucks get a replacement for pettersson, not a super star but a bo horvat light like guy, but receive probably the best player in the deal overall marner.
This trade is a bigger disaster than the Leafs once the 2nd round of the playoffs is in view. Ryan Reaves belongs in Toronto until he hangs em up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Glorydays22

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad