I'm sorry for the Duguay fans here but tho I liked him as a player as he was a good Ranger, as a broadcaster he was terrible. He brought nothing to the table other than some horrible looking outfits and he looked so out of place.
I'm not sure Valliquette adds much more either but he's a tad better than Duguay. I dunno, it's really not a big deal at all. The only one to me who adds anything to the broadcast teams besides Sam and Micheletti is Dave Maloney who actually does do some pretty decent interviews.
Not sure if Al Trautwig has gotten his shit together but I for one wouldn't mind him back if the Rangers would have him, as I liked him. Hopefully he's better these days as to this day I'm not sure we have been told what happened to him other than he looked terrible physically the last time we saw him.