dukeofjive
Registered User
I voted for the older guys because a part from kane the other 2 kids are too soon in there careers, i could see Mathews becoming top 3 american player to suit up in the nhl.
Can we get a "Too soon to tell" option? The potential is there but anything can happen over 15 or so years, injuries etc. I'm a huge Matthews fan but he and Eichel got a long way to go. Kane the proof is already there he has for sure proven himself in the tier of Roenick/Modano/Hull.
Brett Hull won a Hart and is one of the greatest goal scorers of all time. Kane vs Hull is still a debate. It's going to be very tough for either to pass him. It might be easier to pass Modano.
Your Leaf harassments skills are special but your agenda is sad. Why the Mods ignore you is quite a puzzle.I had to vote the oldies because Matthews was a weak link. Hard to go against Kane, though.
Brett Hull was as one dimensional as they get but when that One dimension puts you in the category of one of the greatest goal scorers of all time then it’s pretty special. I find it funny how Mike Bossy is universally and rightfully respected but somehow it seems Brett Hull is looked at in a lesser light? Maybe it’s because his dad was a legend or he had the rep of being laid back?
Brett was an absolutely phenomenal goal scorer. Being compared to Brett Hull is a huge compliment full stop.
When all said and done
Kane
Matthews
Eichel
Hull
Modano
Roenick
Hull is in another category right now, but I think Matthews, Eichel, and Kane will all be viewed as better than Roenick and Modano post career.
Not American maybe? I mean, if you threw McDavid on the younger guy's list, they'd be winning in a landslide. sooooo...Kind of killed the older guy's fate when you threw Roenick in there. Now if you would swap him out with Jagr they would be winning by a landslide.
This part doesn't compute for me. I don't see that watching him and the stats certainly don't say it.If the weak link is the best goal scorer since Ovechkin
This part doesn't compute for me. I don't see that watching him and the stats certainly don't say it.