How is he going to score 20 at center when we have Yurov-Rossi-Ek down the middle?
Prospect Info: Riley Heidt, C, 64th Overall, 2023 NHL Draft
- Thread starter Digitalbooya
- Start date
It’s funny because they took it upon themselves to be a buzzkill by talking up Heidt in the Stramel thread. Isn’t it interesting what a little scrutiny can dig up.
Regardless, he shouldn’t play in the WHL next year. That’s the main point I’m trying to make. He’s clearly shown that league is too easy for him.
- Dec 10, 2012
- 40,647
- 18,952
I'm all for scrutinizing stuff, that's why we're here. I'm also pretty sure we had these same conversations when Beckman was leading that league in points. Reasons why it does/doesn't matter in the long run, all of it. Honestly there are a lot of similarities between the two.
Yeah it's a stupid rule. I thought at one time NHL teams could apply for exceptions but maybe I'm just making that up.
MuckOG
Registered User
- May 18, 2012
- 15,866
- 5,846
Which is why I hate that CHL/NHL agreement. I understand why it's in place, but in specific circumstances (like this) it could possibly hurt the players development. He may or may not be ready to play in the AHL next season, but it sure would be nice to have that option if after camp the Wild think he's ready.
- Aug 9, 2011
- 3,271
- 2,221
- Dec 10, 2012
- 40,647
- 18,952
Wright is such a weird situation.
The way I understand the rules, a player has to either be 20 by the end of the calendar year, or they have to have played four seasons in the CHL.
1) The 2020-21 season that the OHL didn't play counts as a season played
2) A "season" actually only needs to be 25 games
Wright played 58 games in 2019-20, a credited full season in 2020-21 due to the covid lockout, and a full season in 2021-22.
Then in 2022-23 he "made the team" out of camp, but only played in 7 of the 18 games he was with the team, however, apparently being scratched for 5 straight games allowed Seattle to send him to the AHL, but only for two weeks. Then after WJC, he had to go back to Windsor because he wasn't 20 and hadn't played four seasons.
However, he only technically played 24 games last season (not the 25 needed), and he's still not 20, so by the letter of the law he should be back in Windsor, but he's not.
Now what makes this interesting for us is that this will technically be Heidt's third season in the WHL, however, he played 22 games in 2020-21. So if they make the exception for Wright at 24 games, why can't they make the exception for Heidt at 22 during the same covid lockout season that the OHL didn't even play (but got credit for in regards to the transfer agreement)?
During Covid junior aged players were allowed to play in the AHL because some of the junior leagues were shut down. ROR played 33 games for Iowa, then went back to the OHL next season. That would normally never happen.
The whole point of the rule is to allow the CHL to thrive as a business. Not many fans would show up if they kept leaking their better players to the AHL. While that might help the AHL for a while, it would definitely hurt the business model of the CHL, many of whom are right on the edge in terms of profitablity. It would hurt the NHL if it's most important feeder league went bankrupt.
The whole point of the rule is to allow the CHL to thrive as a business. Not many fans would show up if they kept leaking their better players to the AHL. While that might help the AHL for a while, it would definitely hurt the business model of the CHL, many of whom are right on the edge in terms of profitablity. It would hurt the NHL if it's most important feeder league went bankrupt.
Last edited:
I have to think the Wild would have a point in regards to Heidt being allowed to leave for the AHL in re: number of seasons played. I mean, he missed it by three games during a COVID season? Please… The most games played by a single player that year was 24. Heidt played all of the games he could for his team (22).
- Dec 10, 2012
- 40,647
- 18,952
I'm hoping we have someone in the organization who notices this. Should be a pretty open and shut case to allow Heidt to play in the AHL next season if so, based on precedent.
Khusnutdinov-Yurov-Kaprizov
Heidt-Rossi-Boldy
Ohgren-Ek-Stramel
I don’t hate either lineup.
- Dec 10, 2012
- 40,647
- 18,952
Especially with Ohgren and Khusnutdinov and maybe Yurov
The AHL is a man's league. I don't know how strong, or mature Heidt is. Sometimes it's better to be patient, though i do wish there was another option like the NCAA available. With the rule changes in college sports regarding amateurism, i wonder how long it will be before someone from the CHL challenges the rules regarding them gaining entry into college?
I got in an argument with someone over this; his draft season (20-21) doesn't count toward his season because he didn't get an exceptional status. So, that wouldn't count. So technically he has three seasons.
Exceptional player status; Bedard, Wright, Day, Veleno, Crosby - what they received. Bedard got to play a year earlier than most other players. So did Wright.
- Aug 9, 2011
- 3,271
- 2,221
Dr Jan Itor
Registered User
There's a minimum age you have to be to play in the CHL, unless you apply for and are granted "exceptional status". Basically being WAY too good for the whatever the level below the CHL is.
I might be misremembering but I thought when they granted Wright AHL eligibility they also mentioned that others might be looked at on a case by case basis and they may have even mentioned Heidt by name.
DANOZ28
Registered User
DANOZ28
Registered User
let me clarify lets say 3 or 4 years from now kaprizov (if he stays) rossi yurov then 2nd line boldy heidt ohgren then 3rd khusnutdinov jee zuccy last 2 speedy guys like duhaime & dewar and a tuff guy whether its foligno or maroon or mystery dude. would that really be so bad?
- Aug 5, 2011
- 28,594
- 1,534
Ad
Latest posts
-
Devils team discussion (news, notes and speculation) - season begins!- Latest: DerekDevils30
-
-
-
