Fred22406Capsfan
Registered User
- Jan 19, 2020
- 424
- 560
Rewatching Game of Thrones
- Thread starter Fred22406Capsfan
- Start date
- Aug 24, 2011
- 28,799
- 13,838
Yeah dude she’s like 12
Fred22406Capsfan
Registered User
- Jan 19, 2020
- 424
- 560
John Price
Gang Gang
- Sep 19, 2008
- 385,736
- 30,855
I watched for the first time and the lack of detail in the war in season 1 is jarring. Apparently they didn't have the budget for some big battle
Stopped watching midway through season 2. should probably start watching again.
Stopped watching midway through season 2. should probably start watching again.
hangman005
It's my first day.
When you get to season 6 just let you imagination take over
To be fair I didn't hate hate the conclusion, parts were dumb but I saw from a mile away, others would just need further fleshing out.
With the benefit of hindsight the big problem is that the results themselves aren't the problem. Like you said, it all needed more time to be fleshed out.When you get to season 6 just let you imagination take over
To be fair I didn't hate hate the conclusion, parts were dumb but I saw from a mile away, others would just need further fleshing out.
Dany's madness needed more time in the oven and her cooking the Tarlys is not a good enough showing of that development. I can buy that Dany would roast innocents in King's Landing at some point but it really just seems like a total out of left field moment. Prolong the events of the war, show that the Dany-Jon forces needed time to recuperate. You can build up Jamie's heel turn in the process. I mean you can do so much by drawing out the remaining war after the end of the Long Night instead of having everything more or less resolve the next episode.
I can buy that Bran's path leads him to be King but not when you show me a couple seasons of him being a catatonic future seer with seemingly little to no interest in people. "Why do you think I came all this way?" f*** off with your "it should've been obvious if you were paying attention" smugness.
I can buy that the revelation of Jon being the true heir of, let's say the Targaryen lineage (because both the Targareyens and Baratheons owed their "birthright" to the throne to conquest) didn't amount to him actually ruling Westeros. Even without the script smacking the viewer with "I dun wan eht" over and over again, it's very on brand that Jon wouldn't want to take on that role. He was barely comfortable being the King of the North but took the role to unite as many houses as he could against the Night King because he saw it as the only hope for humanity's salvation. The problem is, taking that agency away from him and not having it brought up when the high council was determining succession is just such a flat way to reach that outcome, and the concept that the only reason he couldn't be named King was because Grey Worm and the remaining strength of Dany's forces would keep the war going is so f***ing stupid.
And then there's nothing that will make Arya being the one to kill the Night King work for me. It's entirely unearned. It should have either been Jon or Bran. With Jon a lot of people say Arya killing the Night King ruins Jon's arc as the hero to save Westeros from the Long Night. I take a wider position because if it hadn't been for the work Jon did to unite the North and get Dany on his side, the Night King certainly wins. He's still the savior even if he didn't commit the act to end it all personally. But still, Arya's story didn't connect with the Night King at all. Bran and Jon's did directly. Bran's arc would be so much better if through some Three Eyed Raven magic he gave his life to stop the Night King threat. Then you can have Arya assassinate Cersei if you're not gonna have Jamie do it.
NyQuil
Big F$&*in Q
I never really liked Jon "Plot Armor" Snow so I was pleased to see all of his heroic trappings taken away.
Scotianhab
Registered User
The deaths of Jamie & Cersei were so bad. Cersei being fed to Drogon would have been much better. Jamie should have died fighting somebody.
BackToTheBrierePatch
Eff Cancer
I think Joffrey needed to suffer more when he was assassinated
- Jun 23, 2020
- 5,976
- 8,657
A lot of the "we ran out of time" stuff could have been solved by abandoning the utterly pointless Dorne and Braavos plots and a lot of the torture porn ("you already hate Meryn Trant, and he's an irrelevant character anyway, but let's include a lengthy scene where we make him a pedophile just to make you even more uncomfortable" or literally every scene involving Ramsey Snow, who is an important but far over-used character and whose demise led the showrunners to replace him with the even more insufferable Euron Greyjoy).
Seriously, there's probably four hours of just this stuff from season 5 onward that could be used to advance the plots and develop the characters that matter.
Seriously, there's probably four hours of just this stuff from season 5 onward that could be used to advance the plots and develop the characters that matter.
All of it? Okay then..
Why? He suffered a pretty horrific death even if it was quick.
Yeah, I have seen it all before... and I like the Nights Watch.
Would be cool if they would do a prequel about the building of The Wall and the early years of the Nights Watch.
Mr Fahrenheit
Valar Morghulis
- Oct 9, 2009
- 7,905
- 3,579
Jon got shit for being high born but the Nights Watch had 5 high born right before he got there
The Crypto Guy
Registered User
- Jun 26, 2017
- 28,414
- 37,132
- Aug 24, 2011
- 28,799
- 13,838
It needed 10 more episodes to stick the landing but otherwise it’s one of the best shows I’ve ever seen. Such a great job balancing out a dozen or so different characters
Primary Assist
The taste of honey is worse than none at all
- Jul 7, 2010
- 6,087
- 6,142
The prestige television equivalent of the Leafs Game 7 4-1 collapse vs the Bruins
LeafalCrusader
Registered User
Show died on the crapper with with Tywin.
6 and 7 are still fine for me. I actually dislike s5 more than 6 and 7, personally. Certainly a decline after 4. 8 is a goddamn mess that drags the total package down.
Felidae
Registered User
- Sep 30, 2016
- 12,125
- 15,308
Season 5 gets a lot of crap and rightfully so, but Shireen's death is still the worst on the show for me, and honestly one of the worst I've seen on any show. Even if the Red Wedding and Ned's demise were more shocking and impactful to the story as a whole. The actress really nailed those screams.
The Crypto Guy
Registered User
- Jun 26, 2017
- 28,414
- 37,132
I mean, the red wedding scene was probably a top 3 scene of the show if not the best. You can't compare that to the Shireen death scene. Which i don't think was THAT horrible, it showed what a terrible leader and person Stannis was, and how the lady in red could manipulate people. It had it's purpose but definitely not too memorable like the Red Wedding.
NyQuil
Big F$&*in Q
The books peaked at #3 too.
So it's not all D&B's fault.
So it's not all D&B's fault.
