Guys...come on haha.
As much as I'm a big defender of small d-men (to a fault, as I'm told sometimes)...let's be real here, it's a 5'8" defenseman who doesn't have an elite skill set. He doesn't play like DeAngelo - that's a lazy, geographical comparison.
And I'm not saying Borgesi is untalented. But the threshold to play at 5'8" is so high and Borgesi needs to be able to lure in F1 and be able to beat him every single time and then beat him back up the ice because I don't think he's an elite puck carrier and I don't think that the length of his stride enables that anyhow (he's a terrific skater, but length of stride can eat you up from a forechecking angles perspective).
Look, things change, the game evolves...but teams that took some shots at sub 5'10" d-men have been disappointed by the ROI and last I checked, that mini trend has started to reverse a bit. Borgesi isn't the guy that's gonna break the mold...folks are still wondering if Lane Hutson or Domenick Fensore can do it still...
There's been exactly one d-man born after 1960 that has played (50 NHL games) at 5'8" or shorter...Francis Bouillon...and he was an absolute cannonball.