Rating the 2013-14 Wild Roster Numerically

[DUMBA55]

I thought it would be interesting to ask HFWild board members to individually rate each player on the 2013-14 Wild Roster by assigning them a single numerical rating which is linked to their overall skill on a scale from 0-100 based on their individual attributes. Essentially this would be their real-life rating on a game like NHL14. I thought it would be interesting to look at the disparity that people may have when rating each player on this years Wild squad keeping in mind that we are rating them based on their current performance, and not factoring in their future 'potential factor'. With that being said, I will go first:

Forwards
Kyle Brodziak: 79
Matt Cooke: 82
Charlie Coyle: 83
Justin Fontaine: 76
Mikael Granlund: 82
Erik Haula: 78
Dany Heatley: 80
Mikko Koivu: 87
Zenon Konopka: 78
Torrey Mitchell: 81
Nino Niederreiter: 83
Zach Parise: 93
Jason Pominville: 89
Mike Rupp: 75

Defensemen
Keith Ballard: 79
Jonas Brodin: 86
Matt Dumba: 77
Nate Prosser: 76
Marco Scandella: 80
Jared Spurgeon: 82
Clayton Stoner: 77
Ryan Suter: 94

Goalies
Niklas Backstrom: 81
Josh Harding: 90
Darcy Kuemper: 73

 

[Lapa]

Forwards
Kyle Brodziak: 77
Matt Cooke: 81
Charlie Coyle: 81
Justin Fontaine: 77
Mikael Granlund: 82
Erik Haula: 77
Dany Heatley: 79
Mikko Koivu: 89
Zenon Konopka: 75
Torrey Mitchell: 81
Nino Niederreiter: 83
Zach Parise: 91
Jason Pominville: 86
Mike Rupp: 77

Defensemen
Keith Ballard: 82
Jonas Brodin: 85
Matt Dumba: 78
Nate Prosser: 75
Marco Scandella: 85
Jared Spurgeon: 84
Clayton Stoner: 77
Ryan Suter: 92

Goalies
Niklas Backstrom: 83
Josh Harding: 88
Darcy Kuemper: 72

 

[Jarick]

Right now?

I'll do on a scale of 5-10:

Forwards
Kyle Brodziak: 6
Matt Cooke: 6.5
Charlie Coyle: 6.5
Justin Fontaine: 5.5
Mikael Granlund: 8
Erik Haula: 7
Dany Heatley: 7
Mikko Koivu: 8.5
Zenon Konopka: 5
Torrey Mitchell: 5.5
Nino Niederreiter: 7.5
Zach Parise: 9
Jason Pominville: 8.5
Mike Rupp: 5

Defensemen
Keith Ballard: 6.5
Jonas Brodin: 8
Matt Dumba: 5
Nate Prosser: 5
Marco Scandella: 8
Jared Spurgeon: 7.5
Clayton Stoner: 6.5
Ryan Suter: 9

Goalies
Niklas Backstrom: 6.5
Josh Harding: 10
Darcy Kuemper: 5

 

[MK9]

DUMBA55

Is....is that supposed to read the way it looks?

 

[DUMBA55]

Is....is that supposed to read the way it looks?

Perhaps..

 

[MK9]

Perhaps..

Ok, good. I was just hoping it was intentional. If it wasn't, that was going to be even more amusing.

 

[tomgilbertfan]

Forwards
Kyle Brodziak: 65
Matt Cooke: 70
Charlie Coyle: 75
Justin Fontaine: 65
Mikael Granlund: 80
Erik Haula: 68
Dany Heatley: 70
Mikko Koivu: 85
Zenon Konopka: 57
Torrey Mitchell: 70
Nino Niederreiter: 80
Zach Parise: 90
Jason Pominville: 88
Mike Rupp: 50

Defensemen
Keith Ballard: 70
Jonas Brodin: 85
Matt Dumba: 48
Nate Prosser: 55
Marco Scandella: 80
Jared Spurgeon: 80
Clayton Stoner: 75
Ryan Suter: 93

Goalies
Niklas Backstrom: 70
Josh Harding: 95
Darcy Kuemper: 45

 

[mezcal]

Cool idea. I love the 1-100 rating system.

Forwards
Kyle Brodziak: 80
Matt Cooke: 81
Charlie Coyle: 82
Justin Fontaine: 77
Mikael Granlund: 83
Erik Haula: 73
Dany Heatley: 75
Mikko Koivu: 88
Zenon Konopka: 73
Torrey Mitchell: 78
Nino Niederreiter: 83
Zach Parise: 91
Jason Pominville: 88
Mike Rupp: 70

Defensemen
Keith Ballard: 80
Jonas Brodin: 87
Matt Dumba: 75
Nate Prosser: 70
Marco Scandella: 82
Jared Spurgeon: 83
Clayton Stoner: 78
Ryan Suter: 93

Goalies
Niklas Backstrom: 83
Josh Harding: 90
Darcy Kuemper: 70

 

[Dampland]

Forwards
Kyle Brodziak: 81
Matt Cooke: 83
Charlie Coyle: 84
Justin Fontaine: 76
Mikael Granlund: 79
Erik Haula: 78
Dany Heatley: 80
Mikko Koivu: 89
Zenon Konopka: 78
Torrey Mitchell: 81
Nino Niederreiter: 83
Zach Parise: 91
Jason Pominville: 88
Mike Rupp: 75

Defensemen
Keith Ballard: 79
Jonas Brodin: 88
Matt Dumba: 73
Nate Prosser: 78
Marco Scandella: 82
Jared Spurgeon: 85
Clayton Stoner: 81
Ryan Suter: 94

Goalies
Niklas Backstrom: 85
Josh Harding: 92
Darcy Kuemper: 77

 

[tomgilbertfan]

Man I wish you guys taught my classes. If i could have a 6.31 GAA, with a .625 SV% this year and get a mid 70s rating that'd be awesome.

 

[Hall of Faber]

Man I wish you guys taught my classes. If i could have a 6.31 GAA, with a .625 SV% this year and get a mid 70s rating that'd be awesome.

Ha. I don't understand why Darcy is being rated. If he is on this list so should Carson McMillan.

 

[57special]

OP,

You have too many zeros on the Heatley rating.

 

[57special]

]Forwards
Kyle Brodziak: 77
Matt Cooke: 81
Charlie Coyle: 82
Justin Fontaine: 72
Mikael Granlund: 82
Erik Haula: 77
Dany Heatley: 43
Mikko Koivu: 89
Zenon Konopka: 72
Torrey Mitchell: 75
Nino Niederreiter: 82
Zach Parise: 91
Jason Pominville: 86
Mike Rupp: 60

Defensemen
Keith Ballard: 78
Jonas Brodin: 88
Matt Dumba: 76
Nate Prosser: 75
Marco Scandella: 82
Jared Spurgeon: 84
Clayton Stoner: 77
Ryan Suter: 92

Goalies
Niklas Backstrom: 80
Josh Harding: 93
Darcy Kuemper: 53

 

[tyratoku]

Forwards
Kyle Brodziak: 76
Matt Cooke: 83
Charlie Coyle: 80(C) 83(RW)
Justin Fontaine: 77
Mikael Granlund: 84
Erik Haula: 78
Dany Heatley: 79
Mikko Koivu: 87
Zenon Konopka: 78
Torrey Mitchell: 81
Nino Niederreiter: 83
Zach Parise: 90
Jason Pominville: 87
Mike Rupp: 75
Jason Zucker: 76

Defensemen
Keith Ballard: 81
Jonas Brodin: 86
Matt Dumba: 75
Nate Prosser: 74
Marco Scandella: 81
Jared Spurgeon: 81
Clayton Stoner: 78
Ryan Suter: 95

Goalies
Niklas Backstrom: 83
Josh Harding: 88
Darcy Kuemper: 70

Compared to most I inflated some of the younger guys a bit and downgraded the higher level guys, but meh. Fun thread though. Added Zucker, btw.

 

[youvegotit]

Forwards

Kyle Brodziak: 80
Matt Cooke: 78
Charlie Coyle: 81
Justin Fontaine: 76
Mikael Granlund: 83
Erik Haula: 74
Dany Heatley: 72
Mikko Koivu: 89
Zenon Konopka: 68
Torrey Mitchell: 76
Nino Niederreiter: 81
Zach Parise: 90
Jason Pominville: 86
Mike Rupp: 65

Defensemen

Keith Ballard: 79
Jonas Brodin: 85
Matt Dumba: 75
Nate Prosser: 71
Marco Scandella: 81
Jared Spurgeon: 82
Clayton Stoner: 78
Ryan Suter: 95

Goalies

Niklas Backstrom: 77
Josh Harding: 88
Darcy Kuemper: 73